Might as well start this now ...

Howe best by a mile

6- Howe ( Fantastic all day . Skills were sublime )

5 - M.Jones ( Far from outstanding , but our only successful runner )

4 - Frawley ( overwhelmed , but focused all day )

3 - Trengove ( actually looked fit and played accordingly , though was still swamped )

2 - McKenzie ( hard at it all game , but rarely hurt opposition )

1 - Jamar ( merely for weight of knockouts , but unfortunately little support from onballers )

1 - Jamar ( merely for weight of knockouts , but unfortunately little support from onballers )

Absolutely not.

He was rucking against Zac Clarke. Clarke is awful. He's only playing because Sandilands and Griffin are injured.

To take 0 marks all day is pathetic for a ruckman. 1 kick is just as bad.

Jamar was rank.

Howe

Terlich

Davey

McKenzie

Jones N

Garland

6. Howe

5. Trengove

4. N.Jones

3. M.Jones

2. Frawley

1. Mckenzie

Honourable mentions to Garland and Terlich.

Who cares.

6 Howe

5 Trengove

4 Terlich

3 JonesM

2 JonesN

1 McKenzie

Get some real people running the club before even considering who the "best" players are.

Who cares.

Get some real people running the club before even considering who the "best" players are.

Such negativity. This is a positive thread to reward those who actually try.

6. Howe

5. Terlich

4. M Jones

3. N Jones

2. Trengove

1. Garland

HoweTerlichDaveyMcKenzieJones NGarland

x 2. Only blokes who went hard at the footy once today. When the footy miraculously made it into our forward 50, davey was the only bloke who made any attempt to keep it there. Watch him nev and tapscott, learn something ffs

1. Mckenzie (put effort in which is something a majority need to look at, his & Nicho's shortfalls would not stand out as much if some other players put the effort in neither of them are any worse than Matt DeBoer, Adam Selwood, Brad Dalziell or others on AFL lists who are surrounded by quality Mids)

M.Jones

Terlich he will be a big out if broken ribs confirmed

Trengove

N.Jones he is all heart and god he would be a great asset in a good side

Howe a must keep for this club

6. Howe
5. M. Jones
4. Terlich
3. Trengove
2. N. Jones
1. Garland

Worst On Ground goes to Jamar. 20 something nothing hit outs against a d-grade ruckman and a rookie listed ruckman. 1 kick. 0 handballs. 0 marks. 6 tackles because he was too slow to ever get a hold of the ball.
Awful performance. He has quickly fallen away as a player, and the fact he still has 2.5 years of his contract remaining is a huge concern for us. At his best he would always compete hard, provide a marking option around the ground and feed it off to runners passing by after clunking the marks from kick outs, long kicks to the wing etc. This made up for the fact he never had a high disposal count.
Now he is a liability. if he wins a tap it goes straight to his feet and is useless. As soon as the centre bounce is done he falls over and we effectively play a man down from then on around the ground as he struggles to jog along to where ever he thinks the next stoppage will be. He wouldn't and shouldn't get a game at any AFL club based on form.

Edited May 27, 201312 yr by Lord Travis

6. Howe - really good.

5. Trengove - possibly his best for a couple of years.

4. Terlich - continues to impress.

3. N Jones - if only he had some decent midfield support!

2. McKenzie - a bit closer to the Jordie we know and admire.

1. M. Jones - ok

PROGRESS VOTING ROUND 9

70. Nathan Jones

59. Matt Jones

56. Colin Garland

54. Jeremy Howe

39. Dean Terlich Jack Viney

31. Colin Sylvia

26. Jack Grimes

25. James Frawley

24. Aaron Davey

23. Shannon Byrnes Michael Evans

16. Max Gawn

12. James Magner

11. Luke Tapscott

8. Mitch Clark

6. Lynden Dunn Tom McDonald

4. Jordie McKenzie Jack Trengove Jack Watts

3. Mark Jamar

2. Rohan Bail

1. Sam Blease Chris Dawes