Tom Scully in September ...

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

All that aside, I truly hope that all Demon supporters are above 'booing' Tom when we play GWS.

If we were as professional as a club such as the Pies, both on-field and off-field, I doubt he would have left. If the truth be known, we're probably as close to a flag as GWS is.

Don't know what happened to my previous response but if you believe this you are a [censored].

And I will boo Tom for treating my club as a practice club. I blame the AFL for his defection, I blame him for [censored] around with us!

And I'mn sick of hearing this wouldn't happen to a "stronger" club.

Oh we'll see next year with the Dons and Hurley!! Alright?

[old55 23,810]

Looks like Richmond weren't the big danger after all. ;-)

Not that it makes any practical difference - but I still believe he postponed his decision until the end of the season for the reasons I've already posted. Heading up to Sydney with his family was a very strong indicator of his intentions but he didn't want to make an announcement at the airport - GWS want to have their press conference. "Lying" there doesn't indicate a trend to me.

I'm very unhappy that he's gone and would have much preferred that he stay - I was very excited when we drafted him. It was always likely that he'd go - if it's $6M over 6 years vs say $3M over 5 years what do you expect? MFC hasn't been in a pristine state this year so clearly that hasn't helped our case either, but it's about the money mainly I reckon. I don't blame him for going and I don't see how he could have handled it any other way. But as a parochial MFC supporter I'll love to hate him in future.

Hopefully we can get some reasonable compensation and somehow convert that into a star. We've avoided some salary inflation and they can't take anyone else off us.

[Jack Jack 415]

Oh we'll see next year with the Dons and Hurley!! Alright?

And nothing would be sweeter than a year of Pies woes with constant Pendlebury speculation.

[H_T 3,049]

Don't know what happened to my previous response but if you believe this you are a [censored].

Name calling, flaming is frowned upon @ D'Land and will be removed/deleted upon mods discretion. Followed by warning(s)/banning where permitted. It was deleted with another.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

So anyone else still believe this mercenary is a kid with integrity and good character? The little [censored] has lied to our faces all year culminating in his "just going up to have a look around" comments yesterday. I can see now why Sheedy rates him so highly he is a man after his own heart.

Just got in to Hong Kong and saw the news on here, I agree absolutely that he has lied to us all year and he was gone in October it's all be a charade to try and retain some semblance of credibility for him.

At last we can call a spade a spade he was lying pure and simple and if any still believe it was a last minute decision they are naive in the extreme.

[hardtack 10,758]

BOOOOOYAH.

And next time The Ox goes to air with a call like that, take it the bank boys.

Take it to the bank ... just like our boy Tom did.

CAAAAARNA DEEEEES!!!! B)

I will cite Sloonie's post from your self promoting twaddle RR:

I gave it to Schwarz on Twitter about this, but he was right. Good on him. Would have been better if he could have said 100 percent, but oh well.

And RR you are such a [censored]. You are filled with joy over this aren't you, admit it??? Sully leaving vindicates you, and you can't wait to stick the boots into someone for wanting to believe in loyalty, and someone who was a Dee.

Rpfc is this sites best poster. You are the sanctimonious germ!!!

To which my response was going to be (it was rightfully locked before I could finish posting):

It was a 50/50 bet and Schwarz managed to come up smelling of roses.

As for the rest of your post... +1 Agree completely. Give it a rest RR!

Edited September 12, 2011 by hardtack

[7-UP 107]

let's not forget we almost fired Schwab because of this kid?

It could have been much worse for us.

[beelzebub 23,389]

Billy...theres a whole board dedicated to trading..thats why its there.. A concept too far ??

But just as quick aside. We dont know our picks yet. We dont know all whos on offer. I dont know who WE are prepared to trade ( other than Warnock, obviously Bate and Morton) do you.To get value you might need to offer it..

Youre so smart Billy..did yo figure out all that by yourself..do you have friends ?

Heres the thing.. were talking about Scully here. . I know you find it hard to resist having a crack at me. I do feel special Billy ...I do.

Try limitiing discussion to the topics. The trade board is that way >>>>>>>>

Back to Scully

[Guest Range.Rover]

Not even a wittle bit of cwedit for the old Rangey?

Oooooohhh diddums

Edited September 12, 2011 by Range.Rover

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Looks like Richmond weren't the big danger after all. ;-)

Not that it makes any practical difference - but I still believe he postponed his decision until the end of the season for the reasons I've already posted. Heading up to Sydney with his family was a very strong indicator of his intentions but he didn't want to make an announcement at the airport - GWS want to have their press conference. "Lying" there doesn't indicate a trend to me.

I'm very unhappy that he's gone and would have much preferred that he stay - I was very excited when we drafted him. It was always likely that he'd go - if it's $6M over 6 years vs say $3M over 5 years what do you expect? MFC hasn't been in a pristine state this year so clearly that hasn't helped our case either, but it's about the money mainly I reckon. I don't blame him for going and I don't see how he could have handled it any other way. But as a parochial MFC supporter I'll love to hate him in future.

Hopefully we can get some reasonable compensation and somehow convert that into a star. We've avoided some salary inflation and they can't take anyone else off us.

+1

It's all about the money. To say anythig else is more lies... I was excited when we drafted him because I knew he was gong to be a star.

That's all done now. Time to move on. Big compo or riot! sick of this [censored]!

[demons1964 3]

I can understand why he left, who wouldn't take that money? Still makes me feel a little sick and hollow though

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/tom-scully-to-join-gws-20110912-1k4t0.html

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Not evev a wittle bit of cwedit for the old Rangey?

Oooooohhh diddums

You were unloved as a child weren't you?

[45HG 1,559]

So it was 75 desks in the end was it?

What a shame.

[Guest dieharderdee]

I can beleive he said yesterday he was just going for a look around.

[censored] [censored] scully money in the bank.

You look like a fool. all be it a rich fool.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,959]

Looking at this from another perspective, if Channel 7 is required to show a GWS game on a Friday night, perhaps Melb v GWS will be the game they'll pick. On the same logic, of course, they could pick GWS v Bulldogs/Fremantle/Adelaide, but you'd think from Channel 7's point of view the Scully factor would provide a better marketing opportunity than any of Ward/Palmer/Davis. Of course, GWS may still poach a bigger scalp (Goddard, perhaps?) but in the meantime, if I were Channel 7 and had to have a GWS game on Friday night, this is the one - and probably the only one - I'd choose.

[hardtack 10,758]

Not even a wittle bit of cwedit for the old Rangey?

Oooooohhh diddums

Credit for what? When I was 15 years old I guessed that man would eventually walk on the moon's surface... I was so disappointed when NASA never recognised that fact!

As Sloonie said... no decent supporter would feed their ego by preying on the misery of fellow supporters. You really are a drop kick RR; and like the drop kick, perhaps you should be phased out as well?

[Guest Range.Rover]

Credit for what? When I was 15 years old I guessed that man would eventually walk on the moon's surface... I was so disappointed when NASA never recognised that fact!

As Sloonie said... no decent supporter would feed their ego by preying on the misery of fellow supporters. You really are a drop kick RR; and like the drop kick, perhaps you should be phased out as well?

Yeah you're a 'real supporter' as opposed to those of us with our eyes actually open.

Keep 'em coming ...

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,959]

Actually, Scully going to GWS might also encourage the AFL to have two Melb v GWS games next year. Poor commercially for MFC, but perhaps a positive on the scoreboard.

[hardtack 10,758]

Yeah you're a 'real supporter' as opposed to those of us with our eyes actually open.

Keep 'em coming ...

Yawn

[Guest Range.Rover]

Hey Bezelbub ... did you hear, he was just going up for a look around

Edited September 12, 2011 by Range.Rover

[Ouch! 2,268]

Hahaha. Do know that I am laughing at every single post on here with almighty gaffaws.

An entire season I've had to read the 'Scully is Superman' tripe'.

I'll allow myself a couple of light hearted indulgences.

Maybe more than a couple.

Where are the apologies for Schwarz and the journos who nailed it?

Huh? Come Rpfc ... let's hear it!

Damn. You are a sad individual.

OMG RR you were right, you are fantastic! congratulations!!!

Hopefully that fuels your ego for the next 12 months, now go and crawl back into the hole you came out of.

[whelan45 203]

Hahaha. Do know that I am laughing at every single post on here with almighty gaffaws.

An entire season I've had to read the 'Scully is Superman' tripe'.

I'll allow myself a couple of light hearted indulgences.

Maybe more than a couple.

Where are the apologies for Schwarz and the journos who nailed it?

Huh? Come Rpfc ... let's hear it!

Credit for guessing Scully would take a once in a lifetime financial opportunity?

Quoting gut feelings, and confidants that he was 70-30 chance of going deserves praise?

Your response to this news with a BOOYAH is sad. Although you post a lot, you add no value to this forum.

I don't blame Scully for taking the money. Once the story broke early in the year, there was never going to be a good time to announce he was leaving no matter when he actually made his mind up. It's extremely disappointing non the less

[Demonic Ascent 0]

Hey Bezelbub ... did you hear, he was just going up for a look around

Yeah just goin' to have a look around...

EDIT: I can understand RR's response, after most of the regulars on here have bagged him all year for saying what he though and what turned out to be correct. However I also agree we need solidarity at this point and not fracturing of the supporter base over this mercenary who has made the club look foolish all year. Some payback is expected but if I were RR I would put a lid on it after all none of us are pleased at what has gone down, even those of us who may have seen it coming all year.

Just hope America De Cali doesn't remember his password or we may be subjected to pages and pages of ostrich bums (or is this RR's other username?)

Edited September 12, 2011 by Demonic Ascent

[Guest Darren Lamb]

Then he made a decision. Got proof he didn't?

You're gloating based on nothing but more idle supposition.

Such a sad sad little man you are............

[Mac7 309]

Yeah you're a 'real supporter' as opposed to those of us with our eyes actually open.

Keep 'em coming ...

You are not a supporter and I doubt you even go to the games. I think your only on this site because you have no real life mates. Anyone who really does love this club has a hollow feeling today, yet you are happy we lost a gun player just so you can feed your own ego.

You claim to drive a Range Rover but you quite clearly have no class.