WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JACK VINEY

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Off twitter:

Love it, Casey could have done with him haha.. next year

[Whispering_Jack 29,808]

2011 TAC Cup

Gippsland Power   1.0  2.0  3.0  7.2 (44)

Oakleigh Chargers   3.3  9.4  13.8  17.10 (112)

GOALS:

Gippsland Power: Butcher  Willcocks  Wyatt  Marusic  Fusinato  Lange  Williams

Oakleigh Chargers: Hammond 4 Jong 3 VINEY 2 Mascitti 2 Tyson 2 Orval  Wooffindin  Gotch  Murphy

BEST:

Gippsland Power: Butcher Scott Hector Tynan Staley Wyatt

Oakleigh Chargers: Mascitti Tomlinson VINEY Tyson Jong Hammond

Dom Tyson of Oakleigh Chargers who is widely regarded as a possible top ten pick in this year's national draft was reported on a tripping charge.

[Captain Jack Jordan 32]

Its a bit like looking at scans of a baby .Lets stay miserable about the future and be pleasantly surprised later .

[The O 39]

Off twitter:

WJ - not sure about Jack Viney tearing it apart today.

I thought he played a solid game (a fair bit quieter than his last 2 weeks), but think it was rather a good even team performance. Was good to see Lin Jong play well today.

[drdrake 3,162]

From what i have read and the little I have seen of Jack it looks like he plays like Mark Murphy only harder.

[Matt Demon 1,418]

Dandy v Oakleigh at Visy Park, Chargers up by a point at qtr time. Viney being tagged heavily but managed a few touches and kicked a goal. 2nd qtr just underway.

[mdemonski2 403]

Dandy v Oakleigh at Visy Park, Chargers up by a point at qtr time. Viney being tagged heavily but managed a few touches and kicked a goal. 2nd qtr just underway.

Thanks JRiv.

Reports and updates during the game would be brilliant. Cant wait to hear how jack plays today.

[Guest Jack Donaghy]

I thought taggin was heavily discouraged at that level..?

And there is a thread on the "Finding Another Jack Trengove" board.

The FAJT board even has a thread on Billy Stretch and his huge guns...

[Matt Demon 1,418]

Had a decent first half without dominating. Start of the 3rd he's had 5 or 6 touches in 5 min with a handful of tackles. Oakleigh kicked the first 2 of this qtr and Jack has been involved in both goals. I'm loving this

[DeeZee 7,363]

A mate of mine is heavily involved at Oakleigh, and says Viney will be more than an adeqeute replacement for Scully, loves getting in and getting the hard ball and sharing with his teammates. Hardest player he has seen, to a point where he is scary.

100% confident he will tear the competition apart when he starts playin for the Dee's.

[Striker475 696]

A mate of mine is heavily involved at Oakleigh, and says Viney will be more than an adeqeute replacement for Scully, loves getting in and getting the hard ball and sharing with his teammates. Hardest player he has seen, to a point where he is scary.

100% confident he will tear the competition apart when he starts playin for the Dee's.

I'm honestly worried he's going to be MRP'd out of the game

[DeeZee 7,363]

Imagine seeing Viney and Tapscott rippin it up together in a couple of years time!

Felt like [censored] last week ... feelin better now!

[jumbo returns 6,740]

A mate of mine is heavily involved at Oakleigh, and says Viney will be more than an adeqeute replacement for Scully, loves getting in and getting the hard ball and sharing with his teammates. Hardest player he has seen, to a point where he is scary.

100% confident he will tear the competition apart when he starts playin for the Dee's.

I never saw Scully get the 'hard ball' - an outside mid ... I hope Jack lives up to his hype.

[Matt Demon 1,418]

Chargers win by a couple of goals, hopefully the TAC Cup GF is on Fox like last year. Solid game by JV, killed the 3rd qtr. His tackling, pressure & his ability to win the ball in close are his strengths. Also looks dangerous when he goes forward.

[Whispering_Jack 29,808]

Dandenong Stingrays   3.1.19  5.3.33  8.9.57  11.12.78

Oakleigh Chargers   3.2.20  6.6.42  9.8.62 13.9.87

Goals

Dandenong Stingrays O'Hanlon 2 Wright  Wallace  Calvert  Salopek  Benbow  Whitfield  Minchington  Pongracic  Elton 

Oakleigh Chargers Soriano 3 Gotch 3 Mascitti 2 Williams  Pearce  Greene  Viney  Murphy 

Best

Dandenong Stingrays Kelly Minchington Haynes Benbow Whitfield Hill

Oakleigh Chargers Tyson Tomlinson Gotch Jong Mascitti Pearce

[east gippsland demon 7]

2011 TAC Cup

Gippsland Power   1.0  2.0  3.0  7.2 (44)

Oakleigh Chargers   3.3  9.4  13.8  17.10 (112)

GOALS:

Gippsland Power: Butcher  Willcocks  Wyatt  Marusic  Fusinato  Lange  Williams

Oakleigh Chargers: Hammond 4 Jong 3 VINEY 2 Mascitti 2 Tyson 2 Orval  Wooffindin  Gotch  Murphy

BEST:

Gippsland Power: Butcher Scott Hector Tynan Staley Wyatt

Oakleigh Chargers: Mascitti Tomlinson VINEY Tyson Jong Hammond

Dom Tyson of Oakleigh Chargers who is widely regarded as a possible top ten pick in this year's national draft was reported on a tripping charge.

In the best for gippsland is josh scott who is bottom age and really improving . About 6 foot 2 super athletic and still growing . One to watch next year . Also happens to play A grade cricket in my team but i fear we may lose him very soon....

[jayceebee31 759]

I was there yesterday and thought Jack played a sold game without starring. Kicking needs more depth at times.But guts & determination - he doesn't lack.

[Matt Demon 1,418]

Please don't take this the wrong but people that are saying he's our replacement for Scully or comparing him with Marc Murphy need to calm down a bit. I think we're all getting caught up In the romance of getting a decent father son to the club. I've seen JV play a number of times just like I saw Scully play TAC cup a number of times and Scully stood out far more than what JV does at the same age, same with Murphy. JV Is as tough as nails and shows a lot of promise and If It wasn't for father son would more than likely be a first round pick but no way he would be taken with the number 1 pick In next years draft. I do like the kid I just don't want people building him up like he's going to come In and be the greatest thing ever.

[jayceebee31 759]

Please don't take this the wrong but people that are saying he's our replacement for Scully or comparing him with Marc Murphy need to calm down a bit. I think we're all getting caught up In the romance of getting a decent father son to the club. I've seen JV play a number of times just like I saw Scully play TAC cup a number of times and Scully stood out far more than what JV does at the same age, same with Murphy. JV Is as tough as nails and shows a lot of promise and If It wasn't for father son would more than likely be a first round pick but no way he would be taken with the number 1 pick In next years draft. I do like the kid I just don't want people building him up like he's going to come In and be the greatest thing ever.

Glad we all dffer on quality of players,whilst, I understand and agree somewhat what has been stated above, Scully is a flashy player whilst Viney is a hard nose get in get it footballer.I feel he will prove to be a better footballer than Scully and definitely the type who will blend in with the new coach and blend in with Trengove and Tapscott. We have others that Viney suits with Gysberts, Evans, Blease the run off types.

He'll make the likes of Scully look like [censored].

[Webber 10,454]

Glad we all dffer on quality of players,whilst, I understand and agree somewhat what has been stated above, Scully is a flashy player whilst Viney is a hard nose get in get it footballer.I feel he will prove to be a better footballer than Scully and definitely the type who will blend in with the new coach and blend in with Trengove and Tapscott. We have others that Viney suits with Gysberts, Evans, Blease the run off types.

He'll make the likes of Scully look like [censored].

Interesting you put Jordan Gysberts in that group. Every time I have seen him, I'm constantly surprised by the fact that he doesn't play like he looks. He is in and under, not afraid of taking a hit, and as he gets bigger, is going to surprise more people. He is far from a 'run off' type. I'd almost go so far as saying he has the biggest upside of our entire midfield list.

[DeeZee 7,363]

Interesting you put Jordan Gysberts in that group. Every time I have seen him, I'm constantly surprised by the fact that he doesn't play like he looks. He is in and under, not afraid of taking a hit, and as he gets bigger, is going to surprise more people. He is far from a 'run off' type. I'd almost go so far as saying he has the biggest upside of our entire midfield list.

Totally agree...i think Gysberts and Blease have alot of upside and will be integral parts of our midfield

[Freak 100]

Glad we all dffer on quality of players,whilst, I understand and agree somewhat what has been stated above, Scully is a flashy player whilst Viney is a hard nose get in get it footballer.I feel he will prove to be a better footballer than Scully and definitely the type who will blend in with the new coach and blend in with Trengove and Tapscott. We have others that Viney suits with Gysberts, Evans, Blease the run off types.

He'll make the likes of Scully look like [censored].

embarrassingly sour about the scully departure. Scully was as hard as nails. just because he is gone now people try and pay him out

[... 11]

I was at a wedding over the weekend and Bohdan Babijczuk was there. Naturally I spent the night harassing the poor bloke about all things Demons, and in particular I asked his opinion of Jack Viney. He said he will be a great player but he is in the process of changing the way he runs. Apparently his running style was leading to severe groin and other soft tissue related injuries. Bohdan told me that Todd specifically asked him to watch Jack in his games this year and his first comment was, "he will never last in AFL football unless he works very hard on changing his running style". I've never heard of this before but apparently it is very common in young players.

Anyway, he went on to explain that his performances may be up and down this year and not as good as we expected from his early assessments. But its great news to hear that they identified this early because the Demons are recruiting him regardless of his Vic Metro form as they know that he is working on this.

PS: I could start a new thread titled "my hazy recollections from annoying the hell out of Bohdan Babijczuk on Saturday night".

I am really surprised that Bohdan, with his track & field background, has made an issue of someone's running style. Did you ask him abut anyone else in the team? (I'm not having a go at you - just realised I might come across that way - sorry). If I were at the MFC with a track & field background, I'd be pushing the old "got to fix his running" chestnut as well.

I would imagine - Cale Morton (just corrected a typo that left the 'T' out - funny actually) - only gets knee lift to appropriate levels when being chased by a large opponent.

Edited September 18, 2011 by Barry Dawson

[Trisul 664]

Scully was as hard as nails.

Champagne.

[jayceebee31 759]

embarrassingly sour about the scully departure. Scully was as hard as nails. just because he is gone now people try and pay him out

I can asure you I am not.Scully was on my profile as one of my favourite players.However I watch a lot of Under age football and feel that Scully was a very good footballer. But I definately think Viney is better. He still qualifies as an under 18 next year. He was the Australian Under 16 captain whom has just come on even further. He has mixed it very well with the Under 18's this year continuosly in the best for chargers. I feel he is definately more hard nosed than Scully and also a better kick. He may not get 40 odd disposals a game but what he does and is prepared to do for the team is almighty.