Was the Jack Trengove hearing fair?

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

Edit: PS, Watch the game @ Leighoak or Bentleigh, then attend, The Storm NRL game enmass in protest.

No Support the Boys live, they need the Energy, BUT DO NOT BUY FOOD OR DRINKS>

[daisycutter 29,800]

Edit: PS, Watch the game @ Leighoak or Bentleigh, then attend, The Storm NRL game enmass in protest.

Being an away game its very tempting dee-luded but I think the boys will need all our support. Lets lift the roof off and wear black arm bands.

[jacey 333]

Edit: PS, Watch the game @ Leighoak or Bentleigh, then attend, The Storm NRL game enmass in protest.

Support the boys.

U may think it's turning ur back on the AFL but ur also turning ur back on the Melbourne boys too.

[deestar 159]

Is there a area of etihad where we can all sit ??? I hate etihad and nth supporters even more !!

[Trisul 666]

Eh. Turn your back to your opponent and elbow them to the head or back kick the gonads. JUST DONT TACKLE.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Support the boys.

U may think it's turning ur back on the AFL but ur also turning ur back on the Melbourne boys too.

Level 3, Western side,,,up in a lowly lit area and everone get a pair of Red Horns, and bring your signs, and drape them over the ballustrade.

[Nasher 33,617]

Support the boys.

U may think it's turning ur back on the AFL but ur also turning ur back on the Melbourne boys too.

+1. The boys will have additional fire in their belly after this - give them even more fuel by being there and being noisy. I'd be there in an instant if I could.

[Rocknroll 1,005]

Feeling very hollow about the AFL and this decision.

I know it is sad but I have been wondering what the result would be like if this was a collingwood player or a suns player. Or even a player with a chance of a charlie....

Sorry thats was petty.

But the whole thing stinks.

Stick it to the AFL this week demons and rip those kangas apart

[Mydee 288]

Is there a area of etihad where we can all sit ??? I hate etihad and nth supporters even more !!

What all two of them

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

The crowd will be screaming extra loud at every tackle.....cant wait to vent my anger.

[AzzKikA 2,371]

Just watched one after the other. The impact of milburn's tackle seemed greater. And trengrove got up straight away and laid another tackle. There was nothing malicious in it. My opinion is that it was a straight forward tackle of a player who knew he was going to be tackled but chose to kick instead of hand passing therefore leaving himself on one leg as he is tackled thus resulting in putting himself off balance and easily thrown during said tackle. But that's just me.

and http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/players-now-tackle-at-their-peril-after-jack-trengove-verdict/story-e6frf9jf-1226054891332

Edited May 12, 2011 by AzzKikA

[Suzanna 72]

Being an away game its very tempting dee-luded but I think the boys will need all our support. Lets lift the roof off and wear black arm bands.

I really like this idea! But for the black arm bands to be effective, you would need people to know what they are for - anyone got any media contacts? I will bring the black duct tape!

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

Just watched one after the other. The impact of milburn's tackle seemed greater. And trengrove got up straight away and laid another tackle. There was nothing malicious in it. My opinion is that it was a straight forward tackle of a player who knew he was going to be tackled but chose to kick instead of hand passing therefore leaving himself on one leg as he is tackled thus resulting in putting himself off balance and easily thrown during said tackle. But that's just me.

What's done is done, let's move on & help the Boys beat North. That will help us beat St.kilda....do it for jack T.

[AzzKikA 2,371]

What's done is done, let's move on & help the Boys beat North. That will help us beat St.kilda....do it for jack T.

Yeaah i know and will be there screaming my head off as normal, just sucks digs balls.

[daisycutter 29,800]

Feeling very hollow about the AFL and this decision.

I know it is sad but I have been wondering what the result would be like if this was a collingwood player or a suns player. Or even a player with a chance of a charlie....

Sorry thats was petty.

But the whole thing stinks.

Stick it to the AFL this week demons and rip those kangas apart

Once upon a time there was a handsome prince who played for Carlton. One day he gauged the face of an opponent drawing blood. He got charged and because he was the afl poster prince he got let off. A few weeks later he won the Charlie whilst his victim looked on. True story

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

Yeaah i know and will be there screaming my head off as normal, just sucks digs balls.

Oh it sucks balls alright, but winning is now very important so the AFL will continue to hear our rage.

Welcome the New Melbourne Football Club.

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

Once upon a time there was a handsome prince who played for Carlton. One day he gauged the face of an opponent drawing blood. He got charged and because he was the afl poster prince he got let off. A few weeks later he won the Charlie whilst his victim looked on. True story

Yes...we should never forget that one.

[Suzanna 72]

Who is going to the game on Saturday? Who will put on a black arm band with me? I have just been informed that the HS news desk is aware of this (I reposted it on the Free Demon Jack page), so hopefully we will get some coverage. Who is game for a grass roots demonstration of our disquiet with this decision?

[Redleg 41,759]

Does this also effect Jack in the future? If he gets another incident, is he now looked at as having a bad record?

Yes.

[Redleg 41,759]

Message to the MFC

Much harder to appeal than to get it right the first time !!!

Why didnt you get Galbally in the first f-ing place ?? he got Richards off..gets many off.. but we tried to do it by ourselves.

Hope weve all learnt a valuable lesson here....besides the AFL being a bunch of pricks that is !!

We had an experienced advocate at the Tribunal and Galbally would have done no better. The word "preordained" just springs to mind.

[bjDee 1,249]

Who is going to the game on Saturday? Who will put on a black arm band with me? I have just been informed that the HS news desk is aware of this (I reposted it on the Free Demon Jack page), so hopefully we will get some coverage. Who is game for a grass roots demonstration of our disquiet with this decision?

Count me in. Jack is our very own Rueben Carter.

[Suzanna 72]

Count me in. Jack is our very own Rueben Carter.

WOO HOO! That makes at least two of us! I guess a trip to Bunnings is on the cards for me tomorrow!

[beelzebub 23,388]

look familiar ???? ( in a fashion )

[daisycutter 29,800]

I wonder how long it will be before the AFL becomes the ANCFL ?

(NC=non contact)

[Suzanna 72]

I wonder how long it will be before the AFL becomes the ANCFL ?

(NC=non contact)

How about our 18 players and their 18 players have a fingerpainting contest? Wait - those papercuts can hurt!