Best and Fairest '11 (PICK TOP THREE)

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Excellent response RR.

I guess you need some some variety and surprise in the Bluey. Having said that if our 4 most talented players- Sylvia, Davey, Green and Jurrah all play 20 plus games, then we'll likely win 11 + games.

That means another 5 games from Col and 12 games from Jurrah will give 3 more wins then I will buy that!

However it might require something more.

[Disco Demons 92]

this years favorite for b&f is davey. hands down.

you have to base it on a player who could walk into any team in the league. Jamar and Frawley could do this but davey has been a consistent performer for so long now. rarely plays a bad game. Plus when melb has been getting flogged he has always put in a strong performance.

davey is vice captain. this is proof he is more than just a good player!

slyvia, grimes, etc...all have massive potential. and could win the b&f...but davey deserves to be favorite.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Best_and_Fairest

[45HG 1,539]

That means another 5 games from Col and 12 games from Jurrah will give 3 more wins then I will buy that!

However it might require something more.

IMO, it'd be difficult to argue that 5 more games from Col and 12 more from LJ wouldn't have produced 3 more wins for the team overall.

[Daz's Dee's 113]

1. Sylvia if he stays fit and plays all h&a games will be almost impossible to beat I think

2. Green, can't see him going backwards and will go back to back if Sylvia has any setbacks

3. Garland is the real smokey IMO, was sensational last season. A full pre season this year and like Sylvia if he can play out the season without injury could make the aa list.

Apologies to: James frawley, Tom scully, mark jamar, jack grimmes and jack trengove.

[pringle 42]

1. Sylvia - easily if he plays all 22 games.

2. Green - so consistent.

3. Scully - will be a prolific possession gatherer.

Apology - Davey (could pip either of Scully or Green).

Unlucky - Frawley (recovery period so will miss games and needs time to work back into things).

[Eth 4]

...davey has been a consistent performer for so long now. rarely plays a bad game. Plus when melb has been getting flogged he has always put in a strong performance.

Disagree.

It seems like when Davey gets tagged and only racks up 5-10 touches, we get flogged. It shows his value to the team, but we need him to shrug the tag and be consistent.

He'll win the Bluey the year he does that.

[DeeZee 6,943]

Grimes - Will show again he is our most consistent player

Sylvia - Will get most of the ball in the middle

Green - Never far away from the action, inspirational leader

[Red Sox 2]

If Grimes doesn't get injured he will walk in the B&F.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Grimes, Sylvia, Davey in any order.

[deeflog 679]

Grimes

Green

Jurrah

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

This is a pretty difficult one to pick... I want to have Green in there, but I think, barring injury, all these players should be higher than him:

Grimes

Davey

Sylvia

[Supermercado 2,682]

Sylvia

Jamar

Grimes