Round 12 Injury List

[Eth 4]

MELBOURNE

James Frawley (back) test

Nathan Jones (hamstring) test

James McDonald (hamstring) test

Sam Blease (leg) 2 weeks

Liam Jurrah (shoulder) 3 weeks

Jake Spencer (knee) 3 weeks

Rohan Bail (cheekbone) 3-4 weeks

Luke Tapscott (hip) 4 weeks

Max Gawn (knee) 5 weeks

John Meesen (ankle) indefinite

Ricky Petterd (shoulder) season

Hope that Frawley, Jones and McDonald will be right for Queen's Birthday. Good to see Blease down to 2 weeks away and Fitzpatrick not on there anymore :D

Edited June 9, 2010 by eth38

[titan_uranus 24,919]

Blease at 2 weeks, Jurrah at 3 and Tapscott at 4 are nice signs.

[45HG 1,539]

Sylvia?

[Eth 4]

Sylvia?

He'd be a test.

[4jacks 0]

Jurrah 3 weeks is exciting... Bail broken cheekbone is not. Is that new, or did it happen last week?

[Its Miller time 6]

Bail 3-4. Surely this is the last of his bad luck. Only really gives him 8 or 9 games to come back and prove something this year. Hope he can do it.

[armstrong35 262]

fitzpatrick got a corky but is right to go this weekend

[H_T 3,042]

He'd be a test.

Heard Connolly on Fox Sports News re: Sylvia, said he could be out as of Thursday, don't do the main session until Friday, don't play until Monday, "we'll make a decision later in the week"...so they will see what transpires.

[The Chazz 4,077]

While it is great to see Jurrah and Tapscott with 3 and 4 next to their name, do we really think they will be playing senior footy this year? You would think it would take LJ at least 2 in the reserves to get back in to it, Tappy may need 3 or 4, plus they have to perform at this level also.

Excited about seeing Gawn being 5 weeks away. Will be great to start reading reports about his progress through the Casey 2's for a start. Highly unlikely to get a MFC call up this year, but will be good to see if he can work his way in to the Casey 1's team before seasons end.

[H_T 3,042]

While it is great to see Jurrah and Tapscott with 3 and 4 next to their name, do we really think they will be playing senior footy this year? You would think it would take LJ at least 2 in the reserves to get back in to it, Tappy may need 3 or 4, plus they have to perform at this level also.

I think they will be given every chance billy. I recall in 2008, apart from yours truly (there may have been one other poster), no one gave Grimes a chance to get a taste before seasons end. Six weeks out from seasons end I said if JG gets a few games under his belt at Sandy seniors and is fit and he's form holds, why not play him in Rd 21 or 22 just for a taste before getting stuck into a pre-season a month later. Had no admirers at the time, but the rest is history, he debuted in Rd 22.

Of course, different set of circumstances now where Tapscott & Jurrah will more than likely have more weeks up their sleeve at Casey first and foremost. The FD will make absolutely sure they will be right to go, then it will depend upon form. They will be eased in, in terms of game time and then it will be ramped up, much like Watts' preparation. Then it will come down to earning a call up. I think they are both most capable of doing so this year. Let us see.

[Red Sox 2]

Could it be possible that Jurrah has a better conditioning level due to the nature of his injury?? Maybe wishful thinking on my part?!

Can't wait to see Jurrah again as well as Tapscott.....his highlights on You Tube are exciting enough, it really is like watching a Paul Chapman clone...if he can convert that to AFL level, we have a ripper on our hands!!

More excitement to come in the 2nd half of the year.

[flog 20]

Blease at 2 weeks, Jurrah at 3 and Tapscott at 4 are nice signs.

Blease has been stuck on 2 weeks for a number of weeks now. Worrying signs that he just cant get it right. Fingers crossed he gets a good run during the second half of the year.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Given the amount of football Blease has missed and the potential lack of fitness, he will only be playing at Casey in round 14 and may have to build his fitness with a couple of 2 quarter matches. He would really have to perform at Casey to be AFL ready by Round 22.

[old dee 23,558]

ARGH, TYPO IN THE TITLE ): MOD PLEASE EDIT

MELBOURNE

James Frawley (back) test

Nathan Jones (hamstring) test

James McDonald (hamstring) test

Sam Blease (leg) 2 weeks

Liam Jurrah (shoulder) 3 weeks

Jake Spencer (knee) 3 weeks

Rohan Bail (cheekbone) 3-4 weeks

Luke Tapscott (hip) 4 weeks

Max Gawn (knee) 5 weeks

John Meesen (ankle) indefinite

Ricky Petterd (shoulder) season

Hope that Frawley, Jones and McDonald will be right for Queen's Birthday. Good to see Blease down to 2 weeks away and Fitzpatrick not on there anymore :D

Guys what is the situation with Meeson?

He has been "indefinite" for close to a year now!

What is his ankle injury? did his foot fall off?

1 year out and still no sign of him getting back seems strange.

[Inner Demon 1]

While it is great to see Jurrah and Tapscott with 3 and 4 next to their name, do we really think they will be playing senior footy this year? You would think it would take LJ at least 2 in the reserves to get back in to it, Tappy may need 3 or 4, plus they have to perform at this level also.

Those numbers all sound very reasonable. But that would see Jurrah particularly, who has senior experience, ready for a call up around Round 17-18. Tapscott having not played would be more of a Jack Grimes potential situation where we give him a look Round 21-22. That would give him 2 weeks in Casey 2s and 4 weeks in Casey 1s.

[Inner Demon 1]

Guys what is the situation with Meeson?

He has been "indefinite" for close to a year now!

What is his ankle injury? did his foot fall off?

1 year out and still no sign of him getting back seems strange.

Put it this way, if John Meesen was a horse, they'd have pulled out the screen and 12-gauge long ago.

His career is over.

[Demon Head 266]

As at the morning of the QB game this is the scenario:

James Frawley (back) test selected MFC

Nathan Jones (hamstring) test selected MFC

James McDonald (hamstring) test - out

Sam Blease (leg) 2 weeks - out

Liam Jurrah (shoulder) 3 weeks - out

Jake Spencer (knee) 3 weeks - out

Rohan Bail (cheekbone) 3-4 weeks - out

Luke Tapscott (hip) 4 weeks - out

Max Gawn (knee) 5 weeks - out

John Meesen (ankle) indefinite - out

Ricky Petterd (shoulder) season - out

Not on injury list but out

Colin Sylvia - out

Michael Newton - out

Stefan Martin - out

Rhys Healey - out

My question is - who puts together the club's injury list and why?

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,918]

Given the amount of football Blease has missed and the potential lack of fitness, he will only be playing at Casey in round 14 and may have to build his fitness with a couple of 2 quarter matches. He would really have to perform at Casey to be AFL ready by Round 22.

If we as expected are not in finals contention come round 22 and Blease has had some Casey time I would not be suprised to see him given a taste similar to Grimes in 2008.

[Felix 92]

My question is - who puts together the club's injury list and why? 

Injury list as at 8 June 2010

[Nasher 33,607]

Put it this way, if John Meesen was a horse, they'd have pulled out the screen and 12-gauge long ago.

His career is over.

Yep. One of Meesen's friends posted last year when he first got injured saying that John thought his career was over because of this injury. I thought it may have just been hysteria at the time, but it appears to be on the money now.