Bombay Airconditioning

My comments weren’t so much about a comparison between Kosi and Weightman (although the reference to flying for marks was) but more so that small fwds can kick goals as well as apply pressure. I look at other teams small fwds and their output and question whether ours could do more. When ever a poster writes that a small fwd had a quiet game there is then a pile on of posters citing we don’t understand that players role. I would of though in its simplest form it’s when we have the ball to either kick goals or be part of the chain of possessions that ideally leads to a goal or when we don’t have the ball they are to tackle and apply pressure. 9 goals from 4 small fwds in 4 games has to be considered a fail. Yes their tackle numbers were high (except Spargo) but for us to be more dangerous we need greater output from these players. A couple of things to consider, are we playing to the small fwds advantage, are the smalls putting themselves in the right positions (only recently many posters would comment we kick the ball inside 50, two talls fly at the same ball, ball comes to ground and not a small in 10 metres of the contest), and are they doing stupid things like Kosi flying for 2 speccy’s in 60 seconds and not looking like coming close to marking one of them. As others have raised I would like to see Bowey tried as a small fwd for a few weeks. I’d play him in place of Spargo, I like Spargo but if another player makes us 1% better in any role than we go with that player.

Yes it was only against North but 6 goals is still a good effort. From our last 4 weeks including losses to Port and Freo and wins against Carlton and Collingwood. Kosi 4 goals Chandler 1 goal Spargo 2 goals ANB : 2 goals Anyway the point I was trying to make is when our smalls seemingly do little damage on the scoreboard we’re told we don’t understand their roles. 9 goals from 4 small fwds over 4 games isn’t good enough from a team with our experience and numbers of inside 50’s. I would add though their tackle numbers for those 4 games are pretty good. Kosi : 12 Chandler : 18 Spargo : 8 ANB : 26 I can’t see why most players can’t average 4 tackles an game. On a side note many on here have been floating the idea of Bowey for Spargo, going off those numbers i think it’s worth trialing for a couple of weeks. I agree about Picket but honestly can’t see him being dropped. He’s been a bit undisciplined of late though.

Weightman’s now kicked 6, I wonder what his role in team is?

Again, umpiring, the tribunal and the unwarranted need for 20 teams. The games never been in better shape.

Weightman comes across as an arrogant SOB but he can play and makes the most of his opportunities. Small fwds can do more than just apply pressure.

Weightman having a great game, take note Kosi. When to fly for a mark….

Freo are a mess.

2k to fly there from anywhere in Australia is madness.

How many beers have you had? I’m trying to work out how we lost to Brisbane earlier in the year.

Just read Carlton currently has 17 uncontracted players, madness.

Carlton are a mess, they’re not playing as a team, they have no depth. If the Suns were to lose it would be a massive backwards step on the progress they’ve made this season. Harry McKay is a major worry, watching him last week, when he takes a mark 20-30 metres out with little angle he’s seriously at a loss on what to do. I feel as though when he does kick a goal it’s more by fluke than actual skill. He’s almost Travis Cloke all over again.

Who do you have Port losing to? They have Pies and Crows at home and funnily enough play Geelong again in a few weeks.

Our chance to finish top 2 was taken when we lost to them by 4 points. That was every bit an 8 point game. So most likely we’ll finish 3rd and play them week 1, a game I think we can win.

The last of the key signings. Impressive what we’ve done this year.

I had to google what an ornithopter actually was.

I have mate thanks, my wife and I are Redlegs. As special as 2021 was we along with thousands of others would love nothing more than to see us win a Premiership live.

Not sure if it’s just a coincidence but, Rd 3 I flew down and we won. Rd 6 I flew down and we won. Rd 13 I flew down and we won. A pattern is emerging….

? What did I miss?

Wasting our opportunities. Is Kosi playing?

No

[censored] wild.

Where are you sitting?

Surely / hopefully the pre game learnings out way the post game. We know how Collingwood intend to play, what have we learnt? No excuses today, none. If not today, when?

They don’t care. Do we honestly see anything changing with Gil going?

Had to google it as I couldn’t remember. Peter Wright for a future 4th round pick.