spirit of norm smith

Walter is obviously but he’s already zoned to GCS. I think Morris is the best available key forward. Reminds me a lot of Larkey from his draft year. BTW just an opinion.

Positives 1- biggest improver - Judd Mcvee. Mcvee : Definitely have found a very good player. Special mentions to JVR as a key forward and Trent Rivers who developed into defender and attacking running player 2- Harry Petty. Back … and now a potential key forward. 3- Trac (All Australian) 4- Maxy showed he’s still the number 1 ruck if you have faith in him 5- 70,000 members 6- Best win. Vs Lions. 4 goals in last 9 minutes. 7- 16 wins. 6 losses. 8- heart and effort , contested footy. Disappointments 1- finals exit in two heartbreaking losses 2- the goalkicking and attacking strategy (forward 50) got worse as the year progressed 3- loss by less than a goal v port, blues and giants when we dominated 4- Grundy experiment failed and then was quickly expelled from the team 5- injuries: Clarry injury drama and 7 weeks out. Petty season ending. Melksham season ending. 6- Worst loss. Finals x2 and vs Bombers 7- Gus getting knocked out by Maynard. Careless. Head high. Severe. Yet tribunal manufactured a release for Maynard. Disgraceful.

Picks and points. Sad end to 2023

Lions v Giants in the GF ?? Definitely hope it’s not Blues or Pies

Nate Caddy still definitely an option. Good mark. Good skills. Loves a goal. Would be better for the Dees might look at the Lions forward line and see that everyone is a goalkicker. You can’t 3-4 players each week contributing zero to the goal sheet.

Refresh top 50 1. Harley Reid GC Match 2. Jed Walter (suns academy) 3. Coby Mckercher 4. Zane Duursma 5. Daniel Curtin 6. Ryley Sanders 7. Nick Watson 8. Ethan Read (suns academy), 9. Nate Caddy 10. Connor O’Sullivan 11-20 Darcy Wilson, Jake Rogers (suns academy) , Archer Reid, Mitchell Edwards (Freo nga) , Riley Hardeman, Logan Morris , Caleb Windsor, Jordan Croft (bulldogs f/son) , Nathan Philactides, Ollie Murphy 21-30 Joel Freijah, Will McCabe (hawks F/son) , Will Dawson, Ashton Moir, Koltyn Tholstrup, George Stevens, Charlie Edwards, Harvey Johnston, Archie Roberts, Harry Demattia, 31-40 Caiden Cleary (swans academy) , Clay Hall, Will Graham (Suns academy) , Will Green, Will Lorenz, Kade DelaRue, Angus Hastie, Cooper Simpson, Lance Collard, Michael Rudd. 41-50- Luamon Luai, Will Patton, Jack Delean, Jack Callinan, Koby Shipp, Alex Holt, James Leake, Billy Wilson, Aiden Odriscoll, Harvey Thomas (giants academy). For the Dees, others of interest were: Kynan Brown as a father son (Nathan Brown) would be looked at around pick 60 or as a rookie and would get nominated in my view. He’s a tough skinny scrapper with a huge heart and tenacity. His skills are ok (left foot dominant) but can have some turnovers under pressure. Orlando Turner is from NT under our NGA academy. Whilst he was largely quiet, gf showed glimpses of brilliance and goalkicking smarts to indicate he might be picked to develop as a small forward. Rookie pick likely. Sam Van Rooyen (brother of Jacob) could be rookie pick as well. He’s tall and lean and watching him v Vic metro , had a few “nearly moments” where we spilled marks or juggled attempts. Very nice kick for goal. He has the base physique of a key forward and it would be good if the Dees gave him an opportunity.

And so said the chorus of 70,000 members

Last 3 years . 37 games 60 goals 28 behinds McAdam. Yes from me.

Likely Grundy and pick 33 for 11. Let’s sign it up.

There’s 6-7 elite distributors in the top 30 this year. We need to get 2 at least.

5, (11) 14, 23,33. sure we could help GC with points in the sudoku draft game sure we could upload 4 draft picks to barter for Harley Reid or screw that trade BS 5 picks inside 33. That’s a serious draft refresh.

Agree. Over many years I hate phrases like "the score will take care of itself" “we are working in forward 50 connections” “learnings” it’s all rubbish! Madness. The definition is: Doing the same thing over and over and over again and expecting a different outcome !!! That’s why Goody is captain crazy imv

Both? The bombs inside 50 don’t work. We all know it. A 6 year old knows it. Why do the players do it? Their own bloody mindedness or they are told to. Either way … watch others and fix it!! I’m still angry btw

He did a huge job. Huge. Curnow to zero goals. We love you Maysey. Let down by so many “forward of Centre”

Yes 2017, 2019, 2020 were wasted hope 2018 over enthusiastic optimism. Hope. 2021 pure ecstasy and glory 🏆🏆🏆 2022 and 2023 a great team. Talent. Once in a generation ruckman. But two horrible finals campaigns. 0-4. First time back to back straight set exits. Dominated games. Could not kick goals. Wasted? yes

This would be a huge gamble. High risk. High reward. Remember Jack Darling. Somehow clubs were scared to pick him. A risk? Wow. I’d love to have drafted him all those years ago. Moir is a huge talent. Injury and supposedly work ethic questioned. Hmmm sounds like Darling. Moir has to be still strongly considered. He’s a good mover. A good mark. A proven goalkicker. Left foot. Right foot. Lots of work to do to get to know the kid. Is he really keen on footy? I mean lives it. If not, you’d question talent being enough. Plenty of huge talent don’t have to drive to succeed. Would be a risk but a huge reward if he can combine talent and hard work.

Ummm. That’s bizarre

Agreed. It was a huge risk - reward. It was over hyped imv and not managed at all. Gawn was your All Australian ruck and we somehow thought he needed more time in forward 50 to play 50% in the ruck. WTF. Sure we needed some backup ruck in case Gawn was injured who could be forward/ruck role. Grundy was never that.

Agreed. That’s why it hurts. That’s why close is not good enough. That’s why we don’t understand Goody extended from 2024 to end 2026. Why??

top 4 finish stars still shining home finals but now its… 2023 is over Eventually wasted season Goodwin please explain more goalkicking practice F@$&)d F50 connection no home GF out straight sets Golden era closing Hope gradually fading Cruel cruel end

2024 where are the improvements + Petty JVR + Howes + Woey + AMW + Daniel Turner + McAdam + 4-5 young draft picks and more …

We’ve known we’ve got forward half connection problems for 7 years. I’m sick of learnings. In the normal world, Goodwin would not have had his contract expended. This lack of fixing the problem is now catastrophic after 2022 and 2023. It hurts.

It hurts. Really really hurts. this is how I feel after our 2023 finals campaign It hurts. Really really hurts

Too early. But lots of changes. Too many passengers on field. Goodwin contract extended - Why? Two failures in 22 and 23

I hate Barrett. Because he hates Melbourne. Clearly. He reckons this is what Brayshaw should have done. Ffs. I hate Barrett. Ffs. I hate Barrett.