demon3165

If you have a need to be right to prove something, go ahead and think that, I myself look at have a different view on how I value players, obviously watching isn't one of your strong points (I don't mean to be mean), it is factual !!!

Gee , old school jumps up quick and no, I don't deal with emotion, maybe you should learn what football is about, learning and watching instead of thinking about evidence and stats, but then again you are the defending your point of view...........goes to show you were wrong !!

Gee to all those people that said Newton was not ready, has not got his head together, has to spend the rest of the year at Sandy, will not be ready until next year, goes to show what you know about football, (Jack Shicht), every other club can fast track players but us. Newton will have his bad days but he will become a better player with the remaining games of the season than trying to blood him next year.

How do you compare a clash of heads which happened with whelans play if you watched it you will see him move him body around at the time of impact and Lloyd's hit from come from behind hit the same.......oh as for fev what he did was not the same as Lloyd's so don't compare that one, what Lloyd did was stupid whether he should get rubbed out is another thing (I would give him 8 weeks well maybe not)

Oh, the prez should have said nothing, but it's ok for neitz to come out and open his mouth, damm you have double standards.

Well, goes to show what you know about football, jack [censored].

What a load of crap this thread is and goes to show why we are rated a soft club in the eyes of the football world, take the emotion of out of it. Oh and people seem to forget that ND had a clause in his contract (he had it put in) that he had to have some sought of indication by July 31st if he was to get the job next year(please correct me if I am wrong) and he could have walked at the end of the year, what would you have said then? I am glad tha PG is conducting the review now and not later and goes to show that he has the balls to make hard decisions regarding the football department.

players should stick to doing what they are paid for and let the Board do there job, it is important that we don't bring emotions to the table with this one.

1st point yes, 2nd point don't be silly I don't mind paying within reason but I like a choice within reason and if you want more people to come you have to provide for them, and really how many people do you think where there?

I am sorry to say this but I will not go again, this club is second class when we do this, NSW beer was served out of cans, no spirits at all and white and red wine at 150ml for $6.50, if they want people to come then they will have to raise the bar.

Oh is that right, can you tell us which group of players said that, or is that you saying that?

I might be a bit slow on reading the news but where did it say that he was guilty of taking cocaine or any other drug for that matter by the AFL drug testers? and he did not admit it either, all he said it was a substance abuse, "we might think we know and might be right" but it also could be booze, painkillers etc.......but in the end show me the facts that it was cocaine please.

rotflmfao........think about it !!!!, oh for the young

says it all !!!!

Yep, seems I do with your comments about it, so what has this issue got to do if I think Pickett has played well, nothing at all !!

JJC, what it does show that you know nothing about football with that comment, for god's sake he did intend to hurt cornes but do what every player is told to do and tackle hard how he fall is in the lap of the gods, this game should now be played in dresses and high heals. This game along with the media has become so sanitised that it borders on a joke, next they will have to wear pads all over their body and no one is to touch each other!!!!

As a supporter of PG he has lost me on this issue, should keep his mouth shut, stop being holy than thou on the issue, always bites your ass, stick to melbourne FC and the problems we have there not everyones eles's.

What part of NOT GUILTY, do you moral people not understand, there is no case to answer, so give it up, oh if you think 10,15,50 years from now people will remember this, you are deluded!!!

Some of you people are a joke and goes to show how emotions overcome brain power to make some of the comments in relation to this, DO YOU KNOW ALL THE FACTS YET or are you judging Selwood by what is in the papers and TV, I myself will wait for the facts to come out before I judge him. If it is not proved I all hope you are ready to say sorry for jumping to conclusions, but if he is guilty then a penelty will be handed out, I myself will wait before I judge him!!!!

John, I also knew your father and brother and I think you where there as well (memory going through old age), when they worked in east bentleigh, how are they going and hope all is well............