old dee

I have been saying for some time that they are Both average players. If you cannot play reasonably at this level we need to replace them. They are not the future.

Depends who bolts at years end. We are desperate for a goal kicker. Yes!

You need to stop talking sense Waltham.

He doesn’t seem to be in any rush to get started NC. I just wonder if his heart is really in the idea?

You know what Bluey I think he is too old for the job. Being envolved at the top of an AFL club is not easy. It is the job for younger person. He quit the MCC to live a quieter lifestyle.

I find it difficult to see a win, a change of players and a plan that our skill level can implement would be good.

Some might have pull out in the last month. Would you want to take on a basket case?

Yes 100% along with 5 others.

Could not agree more. I have been saying similar for most of 2024. He is an average KPF. It's time some statements were made. He and Fritz need to be dropped. Play however for the next 2 weeks. If Goodwin cannot do a large player change this week then it is time to go. I have not called for his head before but after last week's selection disasters he has lost me. I keep saying this but when you have been without kpf's for 3 years and a player who you bring to the club for that exact purpose kicks 5 goals at Casey then doesn't get selected! Why? You have one last chance Simon. Big changes this week or on your bike.

Get them back?

Hard to disagree bb.

We are zero and 5 . Easily the worst team in the comp. I honestly don’t know what the brains trust are thinking. For three years we have had no kpf’s , we struggle to reach double figure goals. We recruit a player at the end of 2022, he kicks 5 goals that could have been 8 in the reserves last week does he get a game last night. No we go with a bunch of short average players. We continue to play players who have been poor for weeks and in the case of Fritz for two years. Why is Spargo playing he was poor in 2023, played one quarter in 2024 and continues his form of 2023. He is a big average player doesn JVR think he can turn in [censored] for weeks on end and all is well. Wheels haven't fallen off we don’t have any. Sorry Simon is time to go. Give some of the reserves a chance. If Jefferson is fit play him next week, play Fullerton. Fritz and JVR to Casey plus Spargo. We need 5-6 changes next week. We need a coach with new ideas and a plan that our players can execute.

That makes 3 of us. The game plan is rubbish. We no key forwards, we have a guy who kicks 5 in the reserves but cannot get a game. But we keep playing guys who have been poor for over a season. It's time to go Goodwin. Let's get someone any one who can get the group to look like they want to be out there.

Just very sad.

Whatever they are doing ain't working. Six goals for the game last week and 1 in the second half. A KPF kicks 5 in the reserves but cannot get a game.

Covered it well demoncat. It beggars belief.

Yes give him a couple of weeks off for paternity leave. He won't be missed and it might actually improve him.

Spot on DJ. I am similar I have zero desire for this stupid [censored] in Adelaide. However we are back to the old days of the season over in April. Very familiar territory. As a fellow demon supporter said to me this morning the only left is picking the size of the loss.

Or milkshake without a game anywhere for months. Cannot be worse than a number who have played the last month.

I was saying it in February and getting criticism. We simply don’t have the forward line talent to kick a winning score. It’s primarily a lack of skill.

Could not agree more Brownie, the seniors forward line may well be the worst in the competition. Could he do less than JVR?

A couple of weeks at Casey might achieve more.

If he doesn't then we need a new coaching panel. In the last half the seniors kicked one goal. How can he possibly contribute less?

Surely Fullerton gets a game in the senior side next week.

It's a better looking side but still no KPFs. Cats by 7 goals.