jnrmac

If this is our decision it would be a mistake of the highest order. I understand he can be a bit polarising and he has some limitations but he a bull that needs to be used better. He is in the mould of Selwood but with less polish. If he can add some calmness to his game and be more measured with his decision making he could be one of the outstanding players in the comp These players are not a dime a dozen, they are incredibly rare. And while his shortcomings are well known to us here with better coaching and direction he could explode. Maybe they have already tried that, maybe he doesn't listen but I wouldn't be happy with him leaving until we explored every last avenue to help him become a better player. Eveyr player has limitations and we have to work out how to work with what Viney has, not what he doesn't have. I am of the view the he and Oliver don't work effectively together as they are both 'see ball get ball' players that get in theirs and others way often. I think we have a coaching problem with our midfield and this needs to be fixed asap. We have gone from being #1 in clearances to being an also ran. That to me is all on the coaching panel and the confusion of how we are trying to play.

If only there was a common denominator.....

This is why Goodwin can't coach It was I think 103 to 44 at half time Blindly freaking obvious how Freo were playing yet we did nothing at all about letting them control the football Anyone care to defend that? He's [censored] hopeless so it's our vaunted leadership Get hodge

My overiding thought listening to pert was 'I'm longing for Peter jackson to come back'

Sure but no one's listening. We've heard it before. As you would say, the scoreboard says it all the rest is just fluff from an institutionalised corporate suit

Usual spin. Said nothing

No one gets to AFL without some decent skills. Yes they can fail under pressure but they all start with being able to kick handball and mark

The President's spray was timely but we don't need him commentating every week

Irrelevant and looking for excuses. The ground you play at doesn't disguise the effort last night 203 Uncontested posessions to 98 Our boys don't like to run, chase, cover their man or get back to help the defenders. But gee we're great at guarding grass. Lazy and dumb. getting back from the man on the mark, not being on the goal line when someone is having a shot. Stupid 50m penalties, falling into the back of someone on the ground. 1m handballs to stationary players, 4 players flying for a mark. But its the ground we play at thats the problem. The supporter base should demand more from these pea hearts.

Fritsch is EVERYTHING that is wrong with the MFC Has talent. When he came in at first he was a breath of fresh air. He has now been Melbournised. Played out of position. Refuses to apply pressure or lay tackles. He's monumentally soft. Leads to the deep pockets on the wrong side. Has lost his skills - FFS he kicked the ground last night! - his goal kicking has fallen off the cliff, he's lazy. And to top it off he's dumb. IN a week where the focus was on little things he was dropped for being late for training. Drinks his own bathwater. This is where lack of leadership at the club comes into it. Who is driving standards that would turn a natural footballer like Fritsch into a top line player? If we have to wait 6 years like Trac to hit unleash their talent or 8 yrs like Max is it any wonder we are a pizzpoor footyclub? We need ruthless alright. We need a Voss a Hodge or a Johnno Brown to start kicking freckles.

Neale Daniher said we had to become "ruthless" That's how long we have been trying to become ruthless.

Awww diddums. This is up there with the quote after round 1 that the players played poorly because they might have been "worried about how they were going to get home." That was truly posted. FFS these are professional footballers

Guarding grass or ambling along 25m behind play. Was a lot of that tonight. Lazy as

Good we need to get angry

Gary Pert Glen Bartlett [email protected] Do it now.

It has been obvious since 2017 Goodwin can't coach. we lucked out with 4 good games in 2018 after being soundly beaten by the Swans in Rd 21. Hopefully there'll be many apologies forthcoming now for the bile that was spilled at those who could plainly see how hopeless he was. People laughed at the Camp but the decision of the players to go the AFLPA was a disgrace and showed the lack of leadership at the club. And a real knock on Goodwin. Sadly we didn't take his resignation at that point. And in the crunch games we repeatedly stunk it up with poor efforts and zero footy smarts. Poor scores kciking wi th the wind, trying to play champagne football in the soaking wet like tonight, no one standing on a goal line for a 50m shot on goal. Under 12 stuff. People excused 2019 but it wasn't an abberation. The same old problems and lack of cohesion, game plan, etc were obvious. This year there is simply no excuse. We were the fittest we had ever been, had a full list to choose from, played every team once and just stank it up repeatedly. The players dont buy the game plan. They're confused and have no idea what to do with ball in hand and no idea what to do when they don't have the ball. Its not that hard. We got beaten the same way too many times, Chip kick keepings off, switch play, sit on the outside and pressure the ball carrier and they'll turn it over with handball. Rinse and repeat. We have talent and a good coach would get this team humming. Goodwin aint it.

14 Melbourne players with 7 or less kicks 206 to 98 uncontested possessions to Freo 74 to 32 marks to freo Embarrassing, inept, disgusting, putrid Goodwin's last game

Just waiting for Saty "no one died" "Its only foootball chap"

Luck? Give it a rest. Freo handled it beautifully Half time stats said it all. 103 uncontested posessions to 44

Can I come....

What the [censored] is this front on contact They have paid 5 this match 4 against melbourne all 5 were incorrect. FUUUUUUUCCCCCKKK!

For the 2nd time in 2 weeks we play a bottom 5 side and get comprehensively outcoached outclassed and well beaten. Good job Simon. If you had any integrity you would resign straight after this game. And don't forget 2017 v collingwood who were 14th. We didn't lay a tackle inside the first 20 minutes we anted the win so bad.

I hope not The club will fold. It won't sell any memberships. There's 5 here that are done.

Deservedly