buck_nekkid

Considering our skills, I think we rarely get the chance to use them with our current ‘rush at all costs’ philosophy. Right now, we rush TOO MUCH. We hit opposition players, kick to the non-advantage side of contests and miss moving targets. The rush at all costs mantra looks great when we pull it off, but most of the time we could use the 1/2 a second more to improve our outcome without negative consequences. Salem is #1 in skills for mine. I think Lever is also very good, and down forward TMAC has been good as a set shot, and Fritsch has shown some serious quality. If they were told to slow it down a bit more, we might get a different perspective on some of these guys.

Some thoughts: Play TMAC back, put Frost on the wing, and bring in Weids to partner smith in the 50. TMac out if he cant run (looked like he really struggled against the giants) Trac and Brayshaw to play High HF roles, to deliver inside 50. Mids of Max, Viney Oliver Harmes and Jones (as relief/burst rotating with Brayshaw). Harmes to run with as needed. I would have said Lewis back in, but he is rubbed out. We could use Lever in this role to cut his teeth back in the seniors until he is ready to become the focal defender. Would be a good balance with Hore and Lever intercept marking, and TMAC and OMac locking down. Salem straight back in. Garlett under the pump. Gotta stop the cute kicks, and just do the basics well (drop punts). Hunt and maybe ANB close to goal. Petty and probably spargo straight out. Stretch - either play on fast, or go back to Casey. You are killing is by slowing the game every time you get the ball.

Maybe he was ‘sticking up for Max’ or something similar. Now you bag him for it????

So true. It felt like we really regressed, and I bet our numbers will show this. We were poor by hand and foot, struggled to take a contested mark, and showed no defensive system that connected to anything forward of the ball. Complete turn around from the Eagles game. Without Max in the first half, and Viney willing himself to every contest in the second and third, we would have been smashed - worse than we were. Nothing learned, nothing executed.

Thanks for running that, Rusty. At 3 quarter time, version A was on the money. We were nowhere good enough for version B, but it showed the influence of the blues game.

Sheesh! The kid hasn’t even pulled on a jumper for a photo and you guys are all over him like STD on a flight attendant. He does something that we haven’t done this year - kick goals from 50 and hit up inside 50 targets to advantage. Slow? Says who? Give the kid a break.

I heard we had 5 players with less than 15 games on the park.

When is this wonderous event happening?

The three nuftis were in the bar surrounded by police officers at 3qtr time, getting details taken etc.

We were so poor, it was not funny. In the first half, Max Gawn almost alone carried the team. He was best on at half time. In the second quarter and the third, Viney willed himself into every contest. I sometimes feel he is a one trick pony, but you could see the effort he was making to change things up. After this, the overall performance was poor. Skills were atrocious. We cannot take an uncontested mark, and for us a contested mark (apart from Max) is like a mythical unicorn. Hore tried hard. Our ability to hit a target was simply second rate. Stretch loves to stop and go back to take his kick. Every time. There were fast options on, and he ignored them and allowed the Giants time to set up defensively. We were smashed in the midfield. With Max offering silver service, we were simply poor around every contest. The umpires only hate Mumford more than us, which means Mummy gave up frees, and apart from this we went unrewarded all day. However, we didnt deserve any charity. The defensive unit was on a hiding to nothing. The spread and coverage upfield meant these guys we always out of position and running second. We applied so little pressure, and they ran around us, all damned day. It was a mix of lack of effort and lack of talent. Why cant we perform inside 50? In 9 weeks, we still have no idea how to find a forward or kick a goal. What is going on, when you clear all of the BS and ‘connection’ messages from Goody, what else is going so wrong, that we simply cannot perform up to any standard forward of the ball? There are massive problems here. On the plus side, Baker showed something, and could be our small forward. Garlett tried hard, but has been taking kicking lessons from Petracca. We were flattered by the final score line today. Pathetic.

Goodie watched it, he was there.

each to their own, but his interviews at the end of games are not even up to Ling or Richo level. His comments add nothing (in fact, tonight he simply repeated what the main commentators said about the ball dropping short in the wet.) Zero added value or insight.

McAdam is a hopeless boundary rider commentator.

Be interesting to compare them from the week before (exclude the blues game as an anomaly) and see how we compare up.

For those of you crying out for Preuss, what specifically did you like about his game at Casey? Which parts of his second half inspired you? Honestly, when he puts together 4 quarters, does not give away lazy frees late in the game, and does more around the ground, then he will easily push for a spot. If it also going to be freezing and raining, then our gamestyle will be chaos ball into 50. If anything, we will flood back (AKA Hawks) and deny them room and possession, and win it in the contest. Expect overlap run and over the back goals, or slogs from contested ball.

Happy with this. None of those guys were playing well enough to come straight back into the ones from injury. Make them prove themselves at Casey. Wagner had a good game last week, so that is a fair call to replace ANB. Some discussion may be around Preuss, but at Casey last week he started strong, but after half time was a liability. He gave away 3 goals from stupid frees, and was unsighted around the ground. Could not promote him on this effort.

Our 80 point loss and inability to kick a score are costing us

Good pickup. Being managed? Anyone hear anything from training today?

Better would be chains to inside 50.

If Salem does not get up, then we need a clean ball user to replace him. Lever might be the best of what we have in the tin, and push Frittata forward. Prefer him at Casey, though, to get his game awareness back to where it needs to be

Your first problem is to believe that the business called ‘football’ has to be fair. This would preclude maximising profit.

Terrible thread. Mumford might be a (unpleasant person as often described crudely as female genitalia). However some of you are sounding like that Hawforn mentally retarded supporter on the hawks TV segment. You really want to ‘fix up’ a player? Imagine if this happened to one of our players - in fact some of you think it may happen to Max. It is a game. Suggesting that we act like common thugs (Matthews, Bruns, etc) is poor form. Go watch MMA ffs. I want the team that I support to play better football, and start winning more games because they are better. We know Mummy has ‘form’, but we should all be better than that.

Disagree. Smith going off had a massive structural effect - it freed up an intercept marker for them in our D50. We were also down 2 rotations (soon to be 3). The AFL have confirmed the free kick was a wrong decision. We actually needed to focus on the roles, and cover back across in defence. We didn’t do this, and looked to run out of legs. We tactically failed to deliver it clear into 50 away from their (now free) intercept markers. A bit of a ‘sugar high’ from some faux aggression was way less important that proper attention to the gameplan. It is a game, and encouraging violence for the sake of ‘being a tough guy’ is a bit silly, especially when one punch acts and stuff like the fights in the crowd are a serious topic at the moment. Play the game fairly but strongly is fine, encouraging violence to intimidate or interfere with another’s capability to play is pretty [censored] weak.

I look forward to 2020. Haven’t given up on ‘19 yet ( we are still a mathematical chance!!!!). Suspect it could all be aligning for 2020 - experience and list, better draw, hopefully not 17 surgeries and delayed preseasons. Oh, and maybe no rule changes to bung our systems.

Arrogant tosses can sing what they like. 6 goals to 1 in the final term give them bragging rights. Best response is to beat them on the park. They are the reigning premiers and still a capable footy side. We are neither ATM.