58er

If it's that simple why aren't we doing it now? Your plan sounds simple and straightforward UB but it seems To ignore that there are opposition players out there as well.

And who would you replace him with AF ? Brown ??? We are short of key position players that's why we need Brown as well. And Petty to play!

Still haven't answered my question PF What is the bite going to be ? Tell us all Why are you predicting doom because of this ONE decision that if not completed NOW would have set our future 5 years Back irreparably and the momentum gained in 2021 ( more than many are finding in their reviews ) especially with our IMO elite draftees Riv Dogga and Kossie, and youth eg Lockhart Fritsch plus Sparrow etc. Our development of players is far more a worry than you classifying one of our true legends resigning fir 5 years a disaster !!! Mark my words this will be a filip fir all if you really look at the counter side of Jack not recommitting. But prey tell WHY it will be so Biting for us??? PF

Now is not the time to Be weak in trade dealings We need to be creative as our list needs Polec and Brown so we may have to give something up For both.$

Clearly he does what the Coaches want and we don't see it DJ We need a 25% lift from Jack Gus and Harmesy and Swallow given some extra opportunities to blend in fir our midfield to reach its capacity and flag potential ability.

It's not logic it's just lazy approach No mid needs to go to from Melb We just need better coaches with our players to utilise our talents .

So you are saying this time next year we will all be wanting Jack to leave PF? Only your opinion but I admit we have to sort out his style of play and our mids link with and take proper advantage of Maxy's ruck work. Need new midfield coach to bring fresh approach.

No one needs to leave We need 6 or 7 good mids not 4 or 5!!

Great work Dees well done Jack fir life!! appArently you are Turning into a right foot kick just to conFuse tacklers. Make it a great 5 years wth some flags to bootJack.

Sorry SF don't share your misplaced cynicism about Charlie. Who FWIW has improved This seasonand I expect Further more and rapid standard in 2021 and beyond. Charlie is a very clever player with good/great disposal skills Yes he could get more use of the ball some times but I have faith in him (and the Coaches) That he is in a linear path in form and development. The boy is Nearly a Man and watch out in future. Definitely deserves a contract fir 2021 and maybe 2022.

Well we have Max Trac Clarry May snd a very stubborn coach !!!

Why take risk if Brown is available

If he isn't an outside runner I haven't seen one . Brilliant and breaks lines and is a lovely kick or pass. Different runner to Ed who goes more around corners some times but Jarrad is full bore fir the goals or a pass to a firward. Great get just his attitude may need a little reshaping That's why players change Clubs yo improve in a different environment. Saw him years ago when played for Lions snd still has that lethal run and left foot plus a good mark fir his size. Absolute no brainer fir Jarrad forget Isaac Smith as he has 5/6 years still not 2!

Spargo deserves the time as he is a clever footballer who uses the ball and generally tackles well. Does need to be more consistent but I believe his upside is good enough in his 4 th year to give him this year to improve further. 10 disposals from him are more useful than the same fir Hannan AVB ANB ( different style of player admittedly ) and Bedford ( at this stage). Kossie is of course the pick of the smalls.

Demons need to sit down with Clarry like they did with Trac and sort this out. Tjis would be almost like Barassi switching Clubs and the draft does not Warrant the Abandoning of 5 years of recruiting. Cripps would be the only player I would trade fir Clarry if this was to eventuate. Club has to stand up and see what Clarry has to say and solve. Mahoney ( this season) and Goodwin ( at end of season) won't survive this If it happens. It will rip the heart out of the Club. Clarry has to realise that he is part of a team and not just an individual playing his game.

Why ????

It's in the head not technique and Bayley could slo bulk up etc and msybe smile and enjoy his footy rather than look as though the world depends upon him. Future A grader if we develop properly!!

Club can't win Bingers give them 4/5 years like Tommy and Harmesy and all D/L come down in FD. I am happy Trac only did a 2 but you can resign ( as fir Goody !!!!) early like Tivers if pressure is coming to retain etc.

Disagree Cheesy he can be ragged a bit but still has some good skills fir his physique in marking etc. BUT tackling needs more bulk to hold ball in and Bailey can get bigger and I believe even fitter like say Trac who must be the benchmark NOW.

Agree W what about a future 2nd rounder and Oscar.

Absolutely DD it's all in the head! BUT greater bulk for marking Fuels and tackling AND smarter leading down field not to the pockets Will give Fritta a big season 45/50 goals even.

Anyone as good as Clarry???? Not Merrett or anyone else I can think of. Clarry eill get better mark my words when we get decent coaches. So would Angus!!

Underrated and solid as at Giants And will prob never get acclaim as a defender We will get good service out of Tommo in defence assisting ruck and occasionally up forward IF Goody is game to make Changes during matches! Hsppy with 3rd tall in defence for last half of season no doubt Petty would be better but we need him up forward. Tommo is your original team man. Is he an improvement on Oscar ? Dies he fit iinto our defence ? Yes and Yes.

Or the other Hawks were totally hopeless

Not disposal kick or handpass in though