ManDee

We will know part of the answer on Brownlow night when we look at the votes at round 14. If the vote tally is the same you will have piqued my interest. But I do not think anyone at the AFL would know more than a couple of votes in a couple of games, most would be guesswork as you or I would do. I will put a note in my diary to revisit this September 24th. Any pecuniary win you may donate to the club.

So you mis quote me with.. Please use the whole sentence. What I said was ....."I do not believe for a minute that Weideman is anywhere near the player that Schwartz was but at the same number of games 28 Weideman 0.86 goals per game, Schwartz first 28 games .96 goal per game in an era when more goals were scored generally. It is not a huge difference.".... Now who was that complaining about partial quotes?

Ok you tell me in the year that Schwartz kicked 60 goals (1994) he played 25 games, how old was he when he kicked his 60th goal? Remembering he was born July 24th 1972. Now we are talking a once in a generation player in Schwartz before knee problems. I do not believe for a minute that Weideman is anywhere near the player that Schwartz was but at the same number of games 28 Weideman 0.86 goals per game, Schwartz first 28 games .96 goal per game in an era when more goals were scored generally. It is not a huge difference. You were the one making the point about how good your list of past forwards were compared to Weideman, I am suggesting that we give the kid some time, he could well turn out to be a very good player for us and he is not far behind the stars that you listed. Not clutching straws but living in hope.

https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pc-melbourne-demons--david-schwarz Schwartz born July 24 1972 our season in 1994 ended in September, now by my rough calculation by the time he kicked 60 goals he was 22 and what a superstar he was and could have been.

Sorry but you are wrong. Schwartz kicked 60 goals in 1994 he was born 1972 Can't be bothered going further. Try footywire for stats

Jakovich was 23 for his first game. Schwartz averaged less than a goal a game until he was 22 Lyon averaged 1.1 per game until he was 25 Jurrah first game at 21 career average 2.2 Robertson 1 goal per game until he was 22 and the Wiz was not a tall forward.

I call bulltish!

Go for it. I am pretty sure you won't, I certainly won't.

I hate to admit it but one this occasion I think you are right. There are plenty of examples. Watts first game ( he is the future). Pedersen being left out (he is not the future), Magner being left out (??) Many players get games when there are others showing better form in the VFL. I suppose Lewis will get a game this week, BOG in the VFL or will the FD invest in the future? Preuss has our highest goal per game average and can play in the ruck, Tommy Mac had been in terrible form, who do we play?

Clayton Oliver, come on down!

But alcoholic beer is not.The name says it all

Why would he scare our forwards?

Probably a typo, as you probably meant ----as to why we shouldn't go hard--- But perhaps you can see why people nitpick as it totally changes the context. I think he would be a good pick up.

AFL integrity unit job description: Must wear sunglasses inside.

Much of what you say makes sense, then you go and say something that doesn't. That is why I picked the part that did not make sense. You could attempt to clarify or you could do what you do and obfuscate.

I was sitting on the boundary near the wing for the Collingwood mark, It was magnificent! We fell to bits after the mark & Collingwood ran away, but it was memorable.

There you go again, what a beat up. Many players have the ability to kick 50+ in multiple seasons but not many do. Hogan has never kicked 50+ in a season, Tommy Mac has. We know Hogan has potential, lots of players show potential, not many reach it. Edit: I don't know what this means.---it’s that’s more unlikely than likely.

Being one of the most privileged people in history, white, Australian, middle class, male, born in the 2nd half of the 20th century, healthy and happy. It is very difficult to truly understand what it is to feel the hatred of racism. But what I do know is that racial taunts have no effect on me, why would they. To call me a monkey means nothing, I couldn't care less. That same taunt to an aboriginal is hurtful and racist. I believe that I am immune to racism because I have won the human lottery. Privileged white males in particular struggle to appreciate the plight of those that have not won the human lottery. Adam Goodes has been very privileged in many areas but he carries a burden that I cannot fully understand. He has every right to stand up and call out racism and perform a dance at his workplace. I apologise for the hurt he felt against his heritage it was wrong, but he could be a dirty sniper on the field.

And another thing. A suspended sentence is not a penalty. He has been suspended for 10 weeks not 22. More AFL spin to make it look harsh. Any fool knows that if you recommit you will get a harsher penalty. I do not believe that the list supplied is every bet he has placed on AFL matches. Stephenson runs fast and loose with the truth, for example today he said he does not do any other form of gambling, then almost in panic says" oh other than the odd flutter in the spring carnival"

He was betting on himself, the following is a list of declared bets (may not be a complete list) — Collingwood to win; — Collingwood winning margin; — Stephenson to kick a goal; — Stephenson to kick three or more winning goals; — Collingwood teammate to kick a goal; — Collingwood teammate to kick two or more goals; — Collingwood teammates to have in excess of a number of disposals. He could easily manipulate outcomes in all of the above.

One offence committed multiple times. If I get caught on a speed camera 10 times in a day do I get one fine for speeding or ten? MB 3 for the stomp sounds fair and 1 week for each pinch not to be served concurrently. AFL making it up as they go!

Cricket is a year round sport at the top level , so that means that 2 years is about 100 weeks. Betting on himself in the AFL Stephenson only gets 10 weeks, I say that is light on.

So let me get this straight, if i punch someone in the 1st quarter then again in the 2nd and again in the 3rd and then stomp on a player and then continue to punch someone I get a total of 2 weeks. I say ten pinches 10 weeks, 1 stomp 4 weeks. 14 weeks in total.

Beam me up Scotty!