See Bailey smith, you can speak normally & not come across as a moron. Be like that more often

would love to see Andy take this out over Daicos

Predictor has Rowell finishing on 40

and Nick on 34

Are we sure we want to get rid of Trac? Polling plenty of votes in a so called down year.

1 minute ago, cookieboc said:

would love to see Andy take this out over Daicos

Same.

1 minute ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Are we sure we want to get rid of Trac? Polling plenty of votes in a so called down year.

Maybe you should ask Trac that question

Not sure we are “getting rid” of anyone

Taranto on 20 votes. The perfect example of Umpires being blinded by midfielders.

On what planet has Taranto had a better year, in a worst team, than Gawn???

Jeremy Cameron 88 goals

12 votes

ridiculous

Just now, Jaded No More said:

Taranto on 20 votes. The perfect example of Umpires being blinded by midfielders.

On what planet has Taranto had a better year, in a worst team, than Gawn???

Taranto has had an outstanding year, playing well in just about every game. Deserves his votes. Maybe Max deserves a few more.

As much as I hate reliving THAT moment...

NWM not polling the three votes is the shock of the night.

Edited September 22, 2025Sep 22 by Demon Jack

Omg NWM with 2. Viney with 3.

You gotta laugh.

Ha viney got the 3 against stkilda.

In saying that I remember he had a great 3 quarters. But even the Melbourne table had a laugh.

Edited September 22, 2025Sep 22 by dees189227

what’s the count on

Just now, dees189227 said:

Ha viney got the 3 against stkilda.

In no way did NWM not deserve 3 votes, but it’s a reminder that we were by far the better side for most of the afternoon.

The fact that NWM didn't get 3 votes for that game proves that the umps should never be trusted to judge what is meant to be the most prestigious award in the game.

The Brownlow voting system drives me crazy. Tradition, my a***. The AFL has changed everything else about the game to make an extra buck, why not change this so that ALL the best players are in the mix!

If ever you needed proof that umpires have NFI that vote proves it.

How does NWM not score 3 in his match winning performance is beyond me.

He was so clearly the best and most influential player on the ground. It’s indisputable!

2 minutes ago, Demon Jack said:

As much as I hate reliving THAT moment...

NWM not polling the three votes is the shock of the night.

If ever there was a reason to take away the voting from the umpires its this game.

[censored] what a howler.

It's official. Umpires are blind and do not understand the game

2 minutes ago, Demon Jack said:

As much as I hate reliving THAT moment...

NWM not polling the three votes is the shock of the night.

Tbh. I don’t.

That was a hammer in the coffin that sealed Goodies fate, and which I loved goody, they needed change.

Plus, the way I see it, they’ll learn a heap from that game and it shouldn’t happen ever again. (Fingers crossed)

While Rowell is on 34 votes, there is only one defender above 5 votes

Time to change the voting panel to a panel of footy experts

Well from the audience reaction it looks like Viney over NWN wins the WTF award for the night.

6 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Maybe you should ask Trac that question

Not sure we are “getting rid” of anyone

This year it sounds like he’s less fussed on leaving (if you believe the media) so why don’t we just keep him?

Talented players like him don’t grow on trees.

3 votes. J.Viney v Saints.

16 tackles. Dominated. Deserved the three.

👏👏👏👏

Is daicos going to be the new bont? Just keeps being the runner up?

Collingwood fans will riot if he's runner up 3rd year in a row

NWM 1000000% definitely deserved the 3, but Viney had 16 tackles in that game, which is huge.

Edited September 22, 2025Sep 22 by JTR