20 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Cause he played last night for Casey. We seriously have some part-timers on this site

Not everyone pays full time attention to Casey. Just sayin'

That, and possibly not the context of his question..

I'm also surprised that Tmac isn't on the standby list. He's by far and away a better player than many currently trotting around. Seems to matter little.

More selection curiosities 🤔🤷

6 minutes ago, old dee said:

PF I don't think you can play Jefferson and JVR together. Neither is good defensively and if they don't mark they contribute very little.

Agree especially in the wet

2 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

I understand van rooyens selection. I just hope he clunks his marks, but Howes & koltyn selection is a head scratcher.

I love koltyns enthusiasm but he hasn't been the player I thought he'd would have been.

Howes well just do something.

I can be enthusiastic but I wouldn't get a kick, the kolt always seems to get low statts and very few goals.

1 minute ago, dazzledavey36 said:

As much as I don't mind the selections I shudder to think if Lever gets into one on one against either Mihocek or McStay. Hes a real liability down back and i feel we've dropped the ball on this one with McDonald not in.

JVR was always going to get the nod purely on being able to ruck. Let's get him back into form now!

Tholstrup just needs more exposed form and experience. If he is going to be an important part of our talent moving forward then let's get games into him.

Howes has actually been dominating at Casey. Reward for form. Collingwoods forward line is elite. He could take either Elliot or Hill.

Would have loved to have found a spot for Jefferson but who do you take out in return?

Yep. I get we want a fit and firing Lever in our backline but he's a fair way off at present. Needs to really lift tomorrow.

2 hours ago, binman said:

I find it so weird - presumably people who post on thiscsite support the dees. Yet some just do nothing but knock tbe club.

It makes it impossible to take anything they write seriously.

You mean like this below, one thing you can count on every week at selection

32 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Howes instead of Jefferson paaAAAARK ME ! How to wreck a career! And Ace sharpshooter Petty still gets a game!!? livid ! 🤮🤮🤮

8 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

As much as I don't mind the selections I shudder to think if Lever gets into one on one against either Mihocek or McStay. Hes a real liability down back and i feel we've dropped the ball on this one with McDonald not in.

JVR was always going to get the nod purely on being able to ruck. Let's get him back into form now!

Tholstrup just needs more exposed form and experience. If he is going to be an important part of our talent moving forward then let's get games into him.

Howes has actually been dominating at Casey. Reward for form. Collingwoods forward line is elite. He could take either Elliot or Hill.

Would have loved to have found a spot for Jefferson but who do you take out in return?

Petty!

24 minutes ago, Demonsone said:

I know that, my question is why has he been dropped the last few games

T Mac certainly stiff. I reckon his distribution is the issue. He turns it over and has continued to do this at VFL level

Turnovers equals goals in todays footy

The other factor is Turner being great down back

14 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

As much as I don't mind the selections I shudder to think if Lever gets into one on one against either Mihocek or McStay. Hes a real liability down back and i feel we've dropped the ball on this one with McDonald not in.

JVR was always going to get the nod purely on being able to ruck. Let's get him back into form now!

Tholstrup just needs more exposed form and experience. If he is going to be an important part of our talent moving forward then let's get games into him.

Howes has actually been dominating at Casey. Reward for form. Collingwoods forward line is elite. He could take either Elliot or Hill.

Would have loved to have found a spot for Jefferson but who do you take out in return?

It's also likely to be wet it's dangerous to go into tomorrow's game with 2 tall forwards who's only contribution is marking.

About time Sharp got cut

JVR over Jeffo is an easy decision. One has shown something at AFL level, the other nothing

14 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Good to see JVR back in

Jeffo has not earned it yet after his pathetic performance last AFL game

Howes is an interesting one

T Mac played vfl so not a surprise

Only semi Devils advocate.. what exactly has JVR done to set the world on fire ?

Seems to me he's sqeaking in on thin merit.

Well Roo, over to you. Might not be the best day to try pack crashing marks 😉

may and lever still in 😑😑

33 minutes ago, dondemon said:

  7 hours ago, ghost who walks said:

well its not mi

The great thing about Demonland is the ability to put people on Ignore!! Bye Bye! lightweight!!

2 hours ago, john delosa said:

Who TF is badloss?

Goodwin? Not according to his record.

5 hours ago, At the break of Gawn said:

I'm actually happy that Cox played VFL and not an inclusion. Cox has played some blinders against us and he always goes in hard against Gawn almost with an intent to injure.

McStay will be severely underdone and I hope they select him.

Back it in, McStay will play well.

3 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Only semi Devils advocate.. what exactly has JVR done to set the world on fire ?

Seems to me he's sqeaking in on thin merit.

Well Roo, over to you. Might not be the best day to try pack crashing marks 😉

That he seldom holds. Still living on the promise of 2023.

15 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Petty!

Petty is the big bodied experience up forward that we need regardless of what others may think he adds as a forward.

Take him out and Jefferson or JVR get a Darcy Moore. Jefferson is years away from taking the number 1 defender on and JVR struggles as being the number one key forward.

Petty is important for our forward structure.

3 hours ago, Queanbeyan Demon said:

I used to love Peter Woss Edwoods of the Wiberal Nationwool Party to.

Also a Demon supporter!

2 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Petty is the big bodied experience up forward that we need regardless of what others may think he adds as a forward.

Take him out and Jefferson or JVR get a Darcy Moore. Jefferson is years away from taking the number 1 defender on and JVR struggles as being the number one key forward.

Petty is important for our forward structure.

Ok Dazz! but still needs to KICK SOME BLOODY GOALS!

9 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Only semi Devils advocate.. what exactly has JVR done to set the world on fire ?

Seems to me he's sqeaking in on thin merit.

Well Roo, over to you. Might not be the best day to try pack crashing marks 😉

Agree. But he is by far the best option we have

he has proven himself at AFL level

A huge test for the kid

We have no depth. It's just the truth. We'll question changes every week because the cupboard is bare, even with an incredibly fit list.

11 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Well Roo, over to you. Might not be the best day to try pack crashing marks

Roo, lead out to space, anywhere, surprise us all.

23 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Petty!

Petty has proven himself at this level 100 times over Jefferson, and gives us the flexibility to send him down back if one of their talls gets off the leash, or we want to swap him and Turner around.

Unfortunately Jefferson has no versatility. He can’t ruck or defend, which is unfortunate, because on form the last two weeks he deserves a game.

28 minutes ago, Previously known as LITD. said:

Yep. I get we want a fit and firing Lever in our backline but he's a fair way off at present. Needs to really lift tomorrow.

Agree. If he plays. Anyway Howes is clearly there for cover. Glad he is in. Was unlucky to be dropped in the first place and has been outstanding in the VFL...REALLY good, as the Casey coach would say (he uses the word ad nauseam).

14 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Only semi Devils advocate.. what exactly has JVR done to set the world on fire ?

Seems to me he's sqeaking in on thin merit.

Well Roo, over to you. Might not be the best day to try pack crashing marks 😉

That he seldom holds.

15 minutes ago, jaydenh10 said:

may and lever still in 😑😑

If you reckon May should be dropped watch last weeks game again

Lever was poor but has enough runs on the board to keep his spot imo