POSTGAME: Rd 01 vs Western Bulldogs

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,877]

27 minutes ago, Cheap Seats said:

WHile i 100% agree with you, i am going to go out on a limb and say from a leadship POV i like what Goody did by rewarding players who displayed the values teh club wants.

Did the players take their opportunities, well taht is debatable, do I think they will make it, again debatable, but i do think it was good leadership.

Yeah, don't get that at all.  I hardly think I've see Laurie play a hard contested manner or with a defensive mindset.  In neither of the practice matches did he show any class and poise handling the ball that is suposely his one wood.  Look good on him if he goes on and proves me wrong, but from all I've seen, he's just not senior AFL standard.

We have plenty of other up and comming players like Wowewodin, Kynan Brown, Throstrup etc that are already ahead of him and don't see why we keep gifting him games or why we extended his contract.  Hope he's only getting paid peanuts.

Billings on the other hand had been great in both our practice matches and I thought it was a huge mistake to play him starting as the sub last week.

[Adam The God 30,407]

1 hour ago, binman said:

Indeed.

Tracc was far and away the best player IMO. 

13 score involvements is nuts.

Indeed, I always underrate Trac because he gets the fumbles unlike Clarry, but Trac is just so explosive that he makes up for it eventually.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,877]

30 minutes ago, Cheap Seats said:

WHile i 100% agree with you, i am going to go out on a limb and say from a leadship POV i like what Goody did by rewarding players who displayed the values teh club wants.

Did the players take their opportunities, well taht is debatable, do I think they will make it, again debatable, but i do think it was good leadership.

Yeah, don't get that at all.  I hardly think I've see Laurie play a hard contested manner or with a defensive mindset.  In neither of the practice matches did he show any class and poise handling the ball that is suposely his one wood.  Look good on him if he goes on and proves me wrong, but from all I've seen, he's just not senior AFL standard.

We have plenty of other up and comming players like Wowewodin, Kynan Brown, Throstrup etc that are already ahead of him and don't see why we keep gifting him games or why we extended his contract.  Hope he's only getting paid peanuts.

Billings on the other hand had been great in both our practice matches and I thought it was a huge mistake to play him starting as the sub last week.

[DeeZee 7,445]

The return of BBB and TMac really straightened us up and the crumbers up forward in ANB , Chandler and Pickett were all on point.

Windsor and Howe continue to impress and Hore was desperate and very solid indeed, which was a very welcome return.

Gawn was huge , especially against a great ruck in English , and Clarry was at his dominant best, so powerful and clean.

Roo performed very well too.

Onwards and upwards!

Edited March 17 by DeeZee

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,408]

What pleased me most about the win was the way we played / tried to play. Although not perfect at times ie wrong option, poor disposal, too slow moving the ball, we played a game style that can take us deep into September.

Not a fan of JVR in the ruck, rucking inside fwd 50 is one thing but not lining up at centre bounces.

Vintage BBB & TMac, Chandler firing again, Oliver getting ready to explode.

Thought we had our smalls in better positions today at times but little things like Kosi flying for a mark then no one at ground level when the ball spills. 
 

Not getting carried away, good win but a few things to work on.

[smiFFy 264]

Great result DEES! Max & Clarry 🤝... Hopefully we are smart with Gawn. He was given longer spells on the bench. Maybe it was just because its hot. But I wouldn't mind seeing us do that throughout the season.

[DubDee 26,117]

17 minutes ago, Spargonicus said:

Here’s a funny post-game comment from one of the Doggies’ forums:

“There comes a time when a great coach realises the team needs a fresh voice. Where beverage is delivering yet another year on the relationship between Confucius - Ancient Teacup making and the Art of the Quilt, other coaches are actually driving the game forward.”

no idea how Bevo is kept on. He refuses to focus on defence and they have missed finals many times

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,877]

32 minutes ago, Cheap Seats said:

WHile i 100% agree with you, i am going to go out on a limb and say from a leadship POV i like what Goody did by rewarding players who displayed the values teh club wants.

Did the players take their opportunities, well taht is debatable, do I think they will make it, again debatable, but i do think it was good leadership.

Yeah, don't get that at all.  I hardly think I've see Laurie play a hard contested manner or with a defensive mindset.  In neither of the practice matches did he show any class and poise handling the ball that is suposely his one wood.  Look good on him if he goes on and proves me wrong, but from all I've seen, he's just not senior AFL standard.

We have plenty of other up and comming players like Wowewodin, Kynan Brown, Throstrup etc that are already ahead of him and don't see why we keep gifting him games or why we extended his contract.  Hope he's only getting paid peanuts.

Billings on the other hand had been great in both our practice matches.  Looks to be a really solid citizen off the field and would think he would have been oozing our club values.   I thought it was a huge mistake to play him starting as the sub last week.

[Dee*ceiving 1,690]

Very good win, played four quarters and improved as the game went on. 

Very pleasantly surprised by the output from Brown and McDonald. 

The captain flexed his muscles and showed he's still the best in the business. 

Good game from JVR, may very well be out best option for 2nd ruck. 

May is the rock of Gibraltar. The astronaut must see him in his nightmares. 

And... welcome back Mr Oliver. Make them all eat crow Clarrie. 

[defuture15 900]

3 minutes ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

Yeah, don't get that at all.  I hardly think I've see Laurie play a hard contested manner or with a defensive mindset.  In neither of the practice matches did he show any class and poise handling the ball that is suposely his one wood.  Look good on him if he goes on and proves me wrong, but from all I've seen, he's just not senior AFL standard.

We have plenty of other up and comming players like Wowewodin, Kynan Brown, Throstrup etc that are already ahead of him and don't see why we keep gifting him games or why we extended his contract.  Hope he's only getting paid peanuts.

Billings on the other hand had been great in both our practice matches and I thought it was a huge mistake to play him starting as the sub last week.

Balls, I think most of the Bill love comes from a game against geelong 2nds in the rain when casey had an incredible win.

It was a BOG for him.

He definately has ability

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,877]

25 minutes ago, Tracca said:

what qtr was this

Last qrt I think.  May was trying to point out something Harmes did to the umpires too, but they were being useless as always.

[Moonshadow 17,677]

3 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

What pleased me most about the win was the way we played / tried to play. Although not perfect at times ie wrong option, poor disposal, too slow moving the ball, we played a game style that can take us deep into September.

Not a fan of JVR in the ruck, rucking inside fwd 50 is one thing but not lining up at centre bounces.

Vintage BBB & TMac, Chandler firing again, Oliver getting ready to explode.

Thought we had our smalls in better positions today at times but little things like Kosi flying for a mark then no one at ground level when the ball spills. 
 

Not getting carried away, good win but a few things to work on.

Agree, not happy with JVR rucking in the centre or around the ground. Will be interesting to see what the FD do when Fullerton is ready for this level

[Chook 15,022]

34 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Langdon might not stand out like his 21-22 seasons but I believe he’s started ok this year. He was clean today.
He’s still running more than everyone, he’s linking up well, just with less fanfare. He’s still very important to us. 

He's still best 22 but the problem for him and us is that he can only play one role that we know of, and he is soft as butter. The wing role in our gameplan needs to make contests, and you can pretty much pen him down for losing 75% of his contests. I still have nightmares of his game against Sidebottom in the finals last year.

I say this as someone who thought he was our most important player in 2021.

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,877]

4 minutes ago, defuture15 said:

Balls, I think most of the Bill love comes from a game against geelong 2nds in the rain when casey had an incredible win.

It was a BOG for him.

He definately has ability

I've heard the lore of all these great VFL games he's played, but I'm sorry every time he plays at AFL level he looks scared and out of his depth.

[Chook 15,022]

29 minutes ago, Flemo56 said:

His rundown tackle was sublime. There’s some familiarities about this kid, just the way he moves. Caleb and Judd Mc are silky smooth with skill and time. ❤️💙

There's a certain #2 he reminds me of as well, not having been there to see it in person admittedly.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,408]

At the end of the day this for a team of our experience is a routine win, let’s enjoy it and move on. Any real judgement of players / gameplan should come against other top 6 aspirants, Collingwood, Carlton, Brisbane, GWS, Sydney & Port. On that ladder we are currently 0 & 1.

 

Edited March 17 by Bombay Airconditioning

[Tracca 853]

6 minutes ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

Last qrt I think.  May was trying to point out something Harmes did to the umpires too, but they were being useless as always.

ill have to try and find it

[seventyfour 1,177]

Half way through the game now.

It's almost like we didn't touch a footy over summer. So many of our players are FUMBLY. It's a bizarre part of the game, but seems like a confidence thing and something that can fix itself?

Honestly think we've cost ourselves 4-5 goals over two weeks by fumbling the ball when we're speeding out of the back half.

[Tracca 853]

9 minutes ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

Last qrt I think.  May was trying to point out something Harmes did to the umpires too, but they were being useless as always.

just saw it, harmes headbutted may. crazy!

[Chook 15,022]

2 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

At the end of the day this for a team of our experience is a routine win, let’s enjoy it and move on. Any real judgement of players / gameplan should come against other top 6 aspirants, Collingwood, Carlton, Brisbane, GWS, Sydney & Port. On that ladder we are currently 0 & 1.

 

I think we can make judgments about 1st-2nd year players at the club but yeah, nothing this year is going to matter a whit to me until we win a final.

[dl4e 5,851]

Impressive win. Tmac and BBB threw some egg on my face but happy to wear it. Oliver was brilliant today and I just want to send a big thanks to Hore who was really impressive of half back. Greay comeback.

[DutchDemons 1,430]

A really solid performance today. Got jumped early, settled down and then dominated for almost the entire match. Can we get some love for ANB's dribble goal reminiscent of Trac in the grand final? What a champ. Having Ben Brown and TMac back made us so much more physically imposing. Barring injury I can't see Thommo or Schache ever playing again. And Oliver and Kozzie picking out targets inside 50, just so good to watch.

[Dee Zephyr 19,268]

8 minutes ago, Chook said:

He's still best 22 but the problem for him and us is that he can only play one role that we know of, and he is soft as butter. The wing role in our gameplan needs to make contests, and you can pretty much pen him down for losing 75% of his contests. I still have nightmares of his game against Sidebottom in the finals last year.

I say this as someone who thought he was our most important player in 2021.

Soft as butter is a bit harsh Chook.

[Chook 15,022]

3 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Soft as butter is a bit harsh Chook.

I'm frustrated at my favourite player from 2021 what can I say? I think the criticism is legitimate, even if he's not literally as soft as butter is (that is very soft, admittedly, in this weather).

[Guest]

37 minutes ago, DubDee said:

pre game it was highlighted by Sarah Jones on Fox. pretty sure i saw @WalkingCivilWar holding up the banner. looked a touch warm!

A touch warm? 🥵 I don’t know how Gussy did it every week, hot or cold. I couldn’t wait to rip that thing off and drop kick it into the nearest bin.