NON-MFC: Rd 02 2023

[Sir Why You Little 36,328]

1 minute ago, DubDee said:

hawks aren’t tanking. they just traded their best mids so they will clearly finish last. Mitchell being a club champ will get him 2+ years to prove himself so he can finish last. then win 8 games next year and media will congratulate them. much smarter than winning 6-8 games this year and then finals would be expected 

You make it sound so easy. 
They are Tanking by choice and should be called out for it 

[dees189227 11,934]

Wonder if West coast can hold on to this half time lead

[dees189227 11,934]

You know what's horrible about Essendon winning. The arrogant fans are gloating, brad Scott is smiling & they're sitting 3rd on the ladder 

[Wodjathefirst 2,624]

55 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

It’s the war on Rugby League 

Tasmania have nothing to do with it. 
They already watch the game

My understanding is that the AFL wanted two teams in the Rugby states so that each weekend there is an actual game that takes place in the cities  (taking the assumption that Gold Coast is almost a suburb of Brisbane) Same logic can also apply to SA and WA. 
I used to wonder why GWS was say not established / relocated to Canberra.  (which I still think would make sense to me).
But on the other hand if / when a team is established in Tasmania, this would be in conflict with strategy of ‘a game every week’!
In other words, I have no idea🙃

Edited March 26, 2023 by Wodjathefirst

[Demonland 69,741]

8 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

You know what's horrible about Essendon winning. The arrogant fans are gloating, brad Scott is smiling & they're sitting 3rd on the ladder 

They’ve beaten Hawthorn and Gold Coast. Wait until they play some opposition. 

[daisycutter 29,094]

looking like we'll hold our spot in the 8

[rpfc 27,863]

19 minutes ago, DubDee said:

hawks aren’t tanking. they just traded their best mids so they will clearly finish last. Mitchell being a club champ will get him 2+ years to prove himself so he can finish last. then win 8 games next year and media will congratulate them. much smarter than winning 6-8 games this year and then finals would be expected 

What the hell do you think tanking is?

They have deliberately made their team awful to get draft picks.

They are tanking harder than they did in 03/04. 

[Demonland 69,741]

Just now, daisycutter said:

looking like we'll hold our spot in the 8

Not if West Coast win by too much. They will overtake us. 

[rpfc 27,863]

1 minute ago, daisycutter said:

looking like we'll hold our spot in the 8

Just lost it…

[Demonland 69,741]

They’ve already overtaken us. 

[layzie 32,386]

I'm uncomfortable with undefeated teams. Especially Essendon if they go 3-0 next week.

[Sir Why You Little 36,328]

15 minutes ago, Wodjathefirst said:

My understanding is that the AFL wanted two teams in the Rugby states so that each weekend there is an actual game that takes place in the cities  (taking the assumption that Gold Coast is almost a suburb of Brisbane) Same logic can also apply to SA and WA. 
I used to wonder why GWS was say not established / relocated to Canberra.  (which I still think would make sense to me).
But on the other hand if / when a team is established in Tasmania, this would be in conflict with strategy of ‘a game every week’!
In other words, I have no idea🙃

That is exactly what it is

Games are on the East Coast of the Country every weekend = Advertising Revenue 

They are making a lot of money…

[layzie 32,386]

We're playing the long game.

[Demonland 69,741]

Perth crowds love to boo

[Demonland 69,741]

That point out us back in the 8

[Diamond_Jim 12,303]

GWS starting to go into a downward spiral. 12-16 is probably the best they can hope for.

You wonder if the AFL will give them assistance in the draft etc. I assume they have access to NSW players on the same basis as the Swans

[Demonland 69,741]

And that point knocked us out of the 8 😛

[Demonland 69,741]

Getting 2017 WA game percentage watch vibes

[Demonland 69,741]

Giants getting no reward for effort this quarter. 

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

38 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

You know what's horrible about Essendon winning. The arrogant fans are gloating, brad Scott is smiling & they're sitting 3rd on the ladder 

Aesop wrote, "Pride cometh before a schadenfreude"

[YearOfTheDees 3,223]

26 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

looking like we'll hold our spot in the 8

Weagles are close to having other ideas about that,

[DubDee 23,944]

44 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

You make it sound so easy. 
They are Tanking by choice and should be called out for it 

it is easy. you don’t need to educate players to lose or change players into weird positions 

trade out good senior players and teach the kids to win. not tanking. i wish we did it the right way but we move on 

[bobby1554 1,215]

20 minutes ago, layzie said:

I'm uncomfortable with undefeated teams. Especially Essendon if they go 3-0 next week.

They will quite possibly be 4 zip when we play them in Adelaide. Teams like Essendon, when they get on a roll, will be hard to stop. 

[DubDee 23,944]

27 minutes ago, rpfc said:

What the hell do you think tanking is?

They have deliberately made their team awful to get draft picks.

They are tanking harder than they did in 03/04. 

pretty simple. it’s deliberately playing to lose. or coaching making moves to throw the game. 

trading out senior guys for draft picks is not tanking. or do you think it is?

[Jaded No More 66,373]

I really have to repeat my earlier question but pose it to GWS. Why are we sticking with this experiment?