Demonland Player of the Year - Rd 15

[spirit of norm smith 16,680]

[titan_uranus 25,255]

6 - Langdon
5 - Gawn
4 - Tomlinson

If I have to go further:

3 - Oliver
2 - May
1 - Brayshaw?!?!

Can't give a vote to Petracca - did he hit a target all night?

[rolling fog 1,208]

6. Langdon

5. Gawn

4. May

3. Tomlinson

2. Oliver

1. Pass

[RalphiusMaximus 6,112]

I'm surprised at the love for Langdon.  His man got away from him in their 50 repeatedly and in return he missed his chances in attack for us. 

[rjay 25,427]

3 minutes ago, RalphiusMaximus said:

I'm surprised at the love for Langdon.  His man got away from him in their 50 repeatedly and in return he missed his chances in attack for us. 

He worked his a... off all night covering for his teammates who didn't show.

The 3rd Q it looked like the Swans v Langdon, the kid tried to get us back in the game but had to carry way too many.

 

[RalphiusMaximus 6,112]

6 minutes ago, rjay said:

He worked his a... off all night covering for his teammates who didn't show.

The 3rd Q it looked like the Swans v Langdon, the kid tried to get us back in the game but had to carry way too many.

 

He worked hard, he got lots of ball and lots of ground, but in terms of the scoreboard, his contribution is basically the winning margin for the Swans.  His man kicked two goals (from uncontested marks) and set up two others.  Langdon missed two set shots, one of which resulted in a goal to the swans, and had no assists.  He's not alone in that by any means.  Jones cost us two goals and plenty of other people missed easy shots, but I do factor it into my assessment of his game.

[Sydney Pennski 309]

6. Ed Langdon
5. Clayton Oliver
4. Steven May
3. Christian Petracca
2. Adam Tomlinson
1. Max Gawn

[spirit of norm smith 16,680]

 

I’m still too angry to vote. Weakest bunch of ?

[Dee Dee 1,145]

41 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

 

I’m still too angry to vote. Weakest bunch of ?

May I join you in your anger. I also feel too angry to vote! What a shame it’s come to this!

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,137]

6. Langdon

5. Gawn

4. May

3. Neal-Bullen

2. Oliver

1. Tomlinson

Harmes' last quarter was very good and nearly got him the final vote

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,137]

I should add I feel dirty giving Langdon and Gawn votes of the same value as given to May and Petracca last week.

I'm sure it's been discussed before, but maybe the Demonland POTY could adopt a different voting methodology next year? My suggestion would be to keep the concept of top 6 players, but instead of an automatic, unweighted 6/5/4/3/2/1, change to a score out of 10 for each of those players. For example, last week I might have given May 10 and Petracca 9 (and the other four players probably scores between 5 and 7). For last night's game, I would have given Langdon 6, Gawn 4, May 4, Neal-Bullen 3, Oliver 3, and Tomlinson 2.  

[Pennant St Dee 13,459]

6. Langdon

5. Tomo

4. Gawn

3. May

2. Trac

1. Clarrie 

[spirit of norm smith 16,680]

 

24 hours on 

 

I’m still  ######## (self-censored) angry 

[Swooper1987 3,322]

And the coaches agree with Demonland.  Only Langdon and Gawn polled in the AFLCA votes.  3 to Ed and 1 to Max.  6 Swans players scored votes which is no surprise at all.

[Demonland 74,465]

Christian Petracca has a good lead.

Progressive Totals

139. Christian Petracca  
116. Steven May 
114. Clayton Oliver
97. Max Gawn 
93. Jack Viney 
67. Ed Langdon
52. Jake Lever 
36. Michael Hibberd
31. Angus Brayshaw 
23. Christian Salem
15. Jay Lockhart
13. Oscar McDonald Adam Tomlinson
12. Trent Rivers
10. Jake Melksham Sam Weideman
8. Kysaiah Pickett
7. James Harmes Luke Jackson
6. Mitch Hannan
4. Tom McDonald Charlie Spargo
3. Jayden Hunt
1. Braydon Preuss