Geelong v. Melbourne at Skilled Stadium 17.3.07

[Redleg 40,925]

Great report Fan. Makes me feel like I was there.

[drdrake 3,163]

Ward's disposal yesterday was terrible in the style of game the MFC is trying to play their is no room in the 22 for him, he just turns the footy over a large percentage of the time. The only way I would play him is if we have to due to injury or he gets a job on someone. You just can't have someone in your team that consistantly turns the footy over, this goes for Nathan Brown as well, I'd rather see Bell, CJ and Buckley play than Ward and Brown.

[Jaded No More 68,915]

Im not saying Ward is the same type of player BTW, Im just of the opinion he is a better footballer and his positives outweigh the negatives.

Go Wardy.

Ward is a better footballer than who, Godfrey? Yes. Bell? No.

Bell has two things Ward doesn't, defensive ability and good disposal.

Ward's main redeeming quality is his pace, but he is mainly a 'run and bomb it as far as you can' player.

He makes my side until Bartram is fit.

One thing is certain, I would hate to see more than one of Ward/Brown/Bizzell in the backline at any one time.

[Slartibartfast 17,279]

Franky we've been down this road before. At this point in time I reckon Danners agrees with me (or the other way round ). Let's hope we are right as then everyone will be happy.

BTW, where do you stand on Yze?

[deanbarber 37]

I know who played well and bad at geelong because i went.

i had to sit there for three hours sorrounded by cats so i was watching.

robbo: played well but alot of stupid things kicked a great goal though:

tried alot of chess marks in stead of hand marks but he did play well.

Johnston : "BOG"

C Johnson: he really played well in my book and if he plays like that he'll be in their best 22

Davey : C R A P. played the worst game ever. tried a speckey which cost them a goal, he jumped 2 seconds to early

Moloney : Certainatly played one of the best for Melbourne, made bartel look crap (even though he had a good game)

Ling (geelong) : worst game ever i saw him hit 2 kicks on the chest and they were pretty much both dropped so it made him look him even worse.

Neitz: pretty well just a bit shy , 2 goals

Ward, whelen and N jones all played acceptional

well gota keep an eye on them

GOOO THE DEMONS

[deanox 9,922]

Ward, whelen and N jones all played acceptional

acceptable or exceptional???