6. Jetta

5. Hogan

4. Gawn -57 hitouts wowee

3. Brayshaw

2. Clarrie 

1. Jones . Happy 250 th 

12 hours ago, DaisyDeeciple said:

It is not only Clarry, I also think Jones suffers for votes being taken for granted, his composure around the ball, I swear my back gets a bit straighter when he picks it up but haven't put him in votes for ages.

Your right - Jones is the reason Others are doing so well - standing  up in the first possession for advantage this guy is a serious grunt player who can do It all . I had him best on last week for his influence around the stoppage. 

10 hours ago, DubDee said:

Anyone else find it hard to know where to rate Gawns performances? He is so consistently outstanding now it just seems like an average game from him. 20 touches, 4 contested marks, 5 tackles, 2 assists, dominates the hit outs. 

His hit outs weren’t to advantage (clearances) and his kicking lets him down, another shocker at goal today, already cost us one game, please don’t let it be a final

6 Jetta

5 Hogan

4 Oliver 

3 Brayshaw 

2 T Mac

1 Fritsch 

6 Jetta

5 Oliver

4 Hogan

3 TMac

2 Fritsch

1 Brayshaw

Better late than never...

 

6: Jetta - by a mile, what a game

5: Oliver - can't take him for granted

4: Brayshaw - in amazing form at the moment, love his ability to kick either side of his body

3: Hogan - having a ripper year and in the hunt for the coleman

2: TMac - we are a much better team with him in it

1: Gawn - could have been higher if not for his kicking, particularly that one at goal 

 

Fritsch unlucky

Salem and Lewis were both effective off half back

Melksham did well to battle on despite injury

19 hours ago, Demonland said:

Can we please have your votes folks  ... 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1

Jetta 6  easily

oliver

salem

hibberd 

fritsch

Brayshaw

Ignore my earlier votes, I watched the replay and I would have Jetta as BOG.

That was a masterclass by him.  You would show that game to a young kid on how to play the game.

19 hours ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

6. Jetta

5. TMac

4 Salem

3 Brayshaw 

2 Hogan 

1 Gawn 

Adjusted post replay. 

6. Jetta

5. TMac

4. Oliver 

3. Brayshaw 

2. Salem 

1. Hogan 

1 minute ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

Adjusted post replay. 

6. Jetta

5. TMac

4. Oliver 

3. Brayshaw 

2. Salem 

1. Hogan 

It's rally hard to see what Oliver does at the ground but on replay and tv you see these amazing little touches, gathers, knocks, gives, that win us the ball but also lots of little defensive efforts through body position, tackling, ball control on the ground and a bit of close checking that make it hard for the opposition to get the contested possession and clearance as well.  So subtle and underrated. 

A bit like trying to decipher a rugby union scrum: lots of by play between the props and there is alway a reason one side is dominating the scrum but it isn't obvious to the outsider/ viewer. 

3 hours ago, SFebey said:

His hit outs weren’t to advantage (clearances) and his kicking lets him down, another shocker at goal today, already cost us one game, please don’t let it be a final

Doggies set up to shark Gawn today our mids will learn from it but again Gawn thrashed his openent 

1 minute ago, deanox said:

It's rally hard to see what Oliver does at the ground but on replay and tv you see these amazing little touches, gathers, knocks, gives, that win us the ball but also lots of little defensive efforts through body position, tackling, ball control on the ground and a bit of close checking that make it hard for the opposition to get the contested possession and clearance as well.  So subtle and underrated. 

A bit like trying to decipher a rugby union scrum: lots of by play between the props and there is alway a reason one side is dominating the scrum but it isn't obvious to the outsider/ viewer. 

Agree. I thought he’d been well held. His work in traffic was lightening and clean. He plays the game at a speed few find possible. 

19 hours ago, SFebey said:

-899,767,438. R Chamberlain 

That's very generous.

6: jetta

5: Oliver

4: T.Mc Donald

3: Hogan

2: Salem

1: Gawn

4 hours ago, SFebey said:

His [Gawn] hit outs weren’t to advantage (clearances) and his kicking lets him down, another shocker at goal today, already cost us one game, please don’t let it be a final

SF - maybe you are suggesting a few weeks at Casey (a) as punishment and (b) for development.  Pity the development league isn't there any more.  :-(

4 minutes ago, monoccular said:

SF - maybe you are suggesting a few weeks at Casey (a) as punishment and (b) for development.  Pity the development league isn't there any more.  ?

Now now, don’t be silly mono!

6. Jetta

5.  Brayshaw

4. Oliver

3. TMc

2. Hogan

1. Gawn

Maxy still leads the pack ...

Progressive

106. Max Gawn
89. Jesse Hogan
86. Clayton OIiver
67. Nathan Jones
48. Angus Brayshaw
35. Christian Salem
31. Jake Melksham 
29. Jake Lever Oscar McDonald
26. Tom McDonald Christian Petracca 
23. Michael Hibberd Neville Jetta
16. Jeff Garlett James Harmes
14. Jordan Lewis
12. Bayley Fritsch
6. Tom Bugg  
4. Alex Neal-Bullen 
3. Jack Viney
2. Dean Kent
1. Bernie Vince Josh Wagner

I haven't seen the game so I won't give votes, but I did listen to the 3AW call and I'm pleased that they raved over Jetta's game and consistently said he should be the All-Australian small defender.

17 hours ago, Demonland said:

Maxy still leads the pack ...

Progressive...

deleted to save space.

6. Tom Bugg  
4. Alex Neal-Bullen 
3. Jack Viney
2. Dean Kent
1. Bernie Vince Josh Wagner

In what world does Tom Bugg have double the points as Jack Viney? Both played 3 games. It probably shows how well the team has played since Viney's return.

Edited June 4, 20187 yr by ManDee

37 minutes ago, ManDee said:

In what world does Tom Bugg have double the points as Jack Viney? Both played 3 games. It probably shows how well the team has played since Viney's return.

Bugg received those votes in the North Melbourne game when he kicked 4 goals 1.

		PLAYER	VOTES
1		Max Gawn	106
2		Jesse Hogan	89
3		Clayton Oliver	86
4		Nathan Jones	67
5		Angus Brayshaw	48
6		Christian Salem	35
7		Jake Melksham	31
8		Jake Lever	29
8		Oscar McDoanld	29
10		Tom McDoanld	26
10		Christian Petracca	26
12		Michael Hibberd	23
12		Neville Jetta	23
14		Jeff Garlett	16
14		James Harmes	16
16		Jordan Lewis	14
17		Bayley Fritsch	12
18		Tomas Bugg	6
19		Alex Neal-Bullen	4
20		Jack Viney	3
21		Dean Kent	2
22		Bernie Vince	1
22		Josh Wagner	1