Should we try and recruit Sam reid to the club? He is a great swingman, but due to our growing concerns we would play him down back.i I think he COULD fit nicely down back, only concern is would be capable of playing as a 2nd key defender, because when sydney play him in the backline its generally as a third tall or 'loose' man. Altohugh we have a lot of young and promising forwards we could play him up forward and he could be our second ruckman (where i personally believe he plays his best footy) but due to our stock of forwards I don't think it would be worth recruiting him as a forward. 

 

2 minutes ago, Woodyy said:

Should we try and recruit Sam reid to the club? He is a great swingman, but due to our growing concerns we would play him down back.i I think he COULD fit nicely down back, only concern is would be capable of playing as a 2nd key defender, because when sydney play him in the backline its generally as a third tall or 'loose' man. Altohugh we have a lot of young and promising forwards we could play him up forward and he could be our second ruckman (where i personally believe he plays his best footy) but due to our stock of forwards I don't think it would be worth recruiting him as a forward. 

 

Isn't he always injured? 

 

8 minutes ago, Earl Hood said:

Isn't he always injured? 

 

well not necessarily as every year he has played 20+ games other then his debut year and 2013. Another good thing is i think we would be able to get him without giving up to much.

welcome to demonland Woodyy

 

Whilst I disagree with your idea I defend your right to put it forward. There are lots of vultures on here just waiting to swoop on the unsuspecting with their vicious, mean spirited invective. Don't let it bother you. There are all sorts of tools - some useful, some just made for hacking things apart.

I think Sam Reid is one of those guys who never really took the next step. Consistent, but consistently average. You wonder if he would have developed more at a lower club or whether him being at the Swans makes him look better than he actually is.

He isn't someone I would be rushing to sign.

Just an older Sam Frost.

no thanks. Let's see what Frosty turns into first 

Frosty kind of reminds me of this guy. He's so lucky to have a premiership medallion.

In all seriousness, this isn't such a bad idea!!

Drinks, lollies, chocooolates and potato chips!!

44 minutes ago, Woodyy said:

Should we try and recruit Sam reid to the club? He is a great swingman, but due to our growing concerns we would play him down back.i I think he COULD fit nicely down back, only concern is would be capable of playing as a 2nd key defender, because when sydney play him in the backline its generally as a third tall or 'loose' man. Altohugh we have a lot of young and promising forwards we could play him up forward and he could be our second ruckman (where i personally believe he plays his best footy) but due to our stock of forwards I don't think it would be worth recruiting him as a forward. 

 

Woodyy I think his just always injured and I don't think we should take the  risk

Edited May 17, 20169 yr by Spargss

only as a free agent in 2018

10 minutes ago, The Song Formerly Known As said:

Just an older Sam Frost.

no thanks. Let's see what Frosty turns into first 

Let's hope the coaches give Frosty a block of games down back to prove his worth.

2 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

only as a free agent in 2018

I agree but Woodyy it's not a bad idea. Does anyone know why his not playing now 

21 minutes ago, The Song Formerly Known As said:

Just an older Sam Frost.

no thanks. Let's see what Frosty turns into first 

fair enough, just a thought

8 minutes ago, Woodyy said:

fair enough, just a thought

Don't have to justify it dude, it's good to have some different thoughts on here. A break from the same old crew scratching and moaning at each other.

11 hours ago, Spargss said:

I agree but Woodyy it's not a bad idea. Does anyone know why his not playing now 

Reid's been injured all year.

I seriously doubt Sydney would entertain the option of trading him.

Sam Reid....Hmmmm

Sam  Reid ..... hmmmmmm

Is it April again ? guy cant get on the park !!

Nah.....pass

15 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Sam Reid....Hmmmm

Sam  Reid ..... hmmmmmm

Is it April again ? guy cant get on the park !!

Nah.....pass

We can replace Dawes with him next season bb!!! 

It would be great to recruit the grandson of our terrific, tough full-back of the 1950's, Keith Carroll.

But I know I'm too much of a sentimentalist.