Audio's here if anyone's interested:

http://www.fiveaa.com.au/audio_josh-mahoney-melbourne-footy-ops-manager-on-vince_107650

Great audio, cheers for that.

I love about how 6 minutes in 5AA try and argue that Bernie Vince and Jarryd Lyons are worth Pick 2. I think they're taking the mickey a little but Mahoney is very adamant that Pick 2 is not involved in any discussions surrounding either player.

Decent stats in a poor year for him. He clearly knows how to get the ball, lay a tackle and is a mid who can kicks goals.

Roos will love him.

Word is Vince to the Dees on a 4 year deal

Word is Vince to the Dees on a 4 year deal

Word is Vince to the Dees on a 4 year deal

Whered u hear that?

Word is Vince to the Dees on a 4 year deal

Where might that 'Word' have come from?

Word is Vince to the Dees on a 4 year deal

What are we giving up?

The herald sun article talks about gws and Vince but was abit dated as it also was talking about Geelong interested in shaw too

With cash going out and experience in shaw coming in ? They are still interested

Word is Vince to the Dees on a 4 year deal

I think people need to be naming their sources, otherwise it just prompts a series of responses asking where it's from. Saying it's from a trusted source inside the club would be enough.

Vince to the Dees, got a text from a mate inside the club.

I just want to hear that 'someone' wants to come to us.

Vince to the Dees, got a text from a mate inside the club.

what for?

I think people need to be naming their sources, otherwise it just prompts a series of responses asking where it's from. Saying it's from a trusted source inside the club would be enough.

The problem with that is if you have a credible and reliable source the last thing you'd want to do is to 'out' them on demonland.

Vince to the Dees, got a text from a mate inside the club.

Was also mentioned on Fox sports that we have offered a 4 yr deal @$400k per yr to Vince but no mention of what we give up.

Edited October 15, 201311 yr by DemonOX

Pretty sure Josh Mahoney has already said no deal has been put yet forward to Vince..

I think people need to be naming their sources, otherwise it just prompts a series of responses asking where it's from. Saying it's from a trusted source inside the club would be enough.

The problem with that is if you have a credible and reliable source the last thing you'd want to do is to 'out' them on demonland.

I think it's usually pretty obvious who is taking the p155 and who isn't.

When it's not, it just makes it more entertaining(/frustrating).

Pretty sure Josh Mahoney has already said no deal has been put yet forward to Vince..

When?

Pretty sure Josh Mahoney has already said no deal has been put yet forward to Vince..

Do you believe that, though?

Anyway, that was as of last night.

Things change quickly.

The problem with that is if you have a credible and reliable source the last thing you'd want to do is to 'out' them on demonland.

but also we don't want to give away info to other clubs necessarily, before we know it can't hurt other deals we have in the fire.

I know these things are hard to keep quiet, but I hope the club has said to staff thats its public knowledge first. I'd hate for us to miss-out on another player in negotiations, because of things getting out too soon.

Do you believe that, though?

Anyway, that was as of last night.

Things change quickly.

I believe him more then half the wits here who make stuff up along the way..

Doubt he would just spruik something on just for the sake of it. Mahoney just got into his new job. Doubt he will wanna play fancy cat around.

but also we don't want to give away info to other clubs necessarily

Now you're taking the pizz! Just think about what you just said and then ask yourself what you'd do if you were a players manager.

I'd have thought in Mahoney's shoes you play a relatively straight bat and don't confirm anything until there's a reason to confirm it.

Now you're taking the pizz! Just think about what you just said and then ask yourself what you'd do if you were a players manager.

don't be stupid bob.

quote the whole thing! in context.

Great audio, cheers for that.

I love about how 6 minutes in 5AA try and argue that Bernie Vince and Jarryd Lyons are worth Pick 2. I think they're taking the mickey a little but Mahoney is very adamant that Pick 2 is not involved in any discussions surrounding either player.

Who the hell was that saying Lyons and Vince for pick 2 was a good deal and we should do it?!

Sounds like an absolute [censored] of the highest order...!

Nothing will really happen until all of the Free Agent compensations are announced. Until then the clubs are not totally sure what picks they have to trade.

Nothing will really happen until all of the Free Agent compensations are announced. Until then the clubs are not totally sure what picks they have to trade.

exactly....half a dozen deals hanging perilously by the arbitrary values placed into these deals. All could go through or all could fold, all for the want of a pick or two.