I read somewhere that its his missus that's kept him in check.

Lets offer to pay for her studies aswell.

Should we be looking at Jurrah as a rookie?

Should we be looking at Jurrah as a rookie?

No

We should forget about Jurrah unless he shows some serious signs of being ready to dedicate himself to AFL again and strings together some very good form in the VFL. Otherwise, no chance.

I think Roos wants players who can run & spread with a hint of pace.

so I reckon Adams sounds like he'd fit that bill, & Nathan Freeman, Dominic Sheed, all sound like good run & spread with strong characters.

I suspect these guys will be on our radar. as well as the Docherty's, etc. players with a couple of Pre seasons into their bodies already.

I'm open to trade anyone to get who we need as quickly as possible, as I'm sure the commission would be as well.

I'm interested in which of our players Demonlanders wouldn't trade, to get the ones we need?

# do any One of these make sense?

some trade possibilities to ponder? who to keep, & who to trade, to build from our strengths.

??? Frawley + Blease ~ GWS (P1 + Adams) = Boyd + Adams

??? or ~ (pass on Boyd) for Aish & Adams & (Saints P21 + DelSanto & Fisher?)

??? or ontrade P1 & P20 to Carlton for Lachie Henderson + P10 & Tom Bell/Chris Yarran?

??? or ontrade P1 to Saints for P3 & P21 & Del Santo?

..................................

??? Gawn > Lions for (Billy Longer)?,,,, or > GWS for Taylor Adams?

or Gawn & Blease to Hawks for Xavier Ellis & Brad Sewell?

..........................................

??? Howe > GWS Taylor Adams + P9? or > GCS for Swallow?

..........................................

??? Lyndon Dunn to Carlton for Chris Yarran?

..........................................

?Tapscott ~ late 2nd/Rnd'r ?

?Blease ~ late 2nd/Rnd'r ?

?Spencer ~ 3rd/Rnd'r ?

?Bail ~ 3rd/Rnd'r ?

Should we be looking at Jurrah as a rookie?

Look but don't touch.

Yeah, that's him.

Let's take a punt. I don't put him in the Martin category.

Can we at least get the kid some neck tatts or a sleeve?

Can we at least get the kid some neck tatts or a sleeve?

Kid reminds me of Chris Brown for some reason

# none of these trades seem reasonable or realistic

# none of these trades seem reasonable or realistic

It's the same everywhere though. If you read opposition forums they do the same - flipping average players off for second rounders or landing a big fish without having to give up a great deal. Part of the reason why people get so upset when a trade goes through and it's not what they wanted, so it looks like a bad deal. Happens every year, as regular as clockwork.

# none of these trades seem reasonable or realistic

bit like using hash tags on a forum...

bit like using hash tags on a forum...

#unforgivable

Yes....but.

Wasn't this the bloke who was overlooked last year? Poor attitude? Winnie Blue and VB in hand?

If we're talking about culture, not sure this bloke fits the bill.

This is the very attitude that has prevented us from success. Martin Pike was traded out and went on 2 win I think 4 premierships with North & Bris. I have faith that someone like Flash & Roos can turn Dale Garlett from a rough diamond in2 a gem of a crumbing forward/midfield option. Hopefully we get him at 19 or later if there's no interest.

Should we be looking at Jurrah as a rookie?

Yes. Make it happen.

Yes. Make it happen.

No way. That we should've picked Rockliff instead is not worthy of debate.

Gartlett would be ok for mine.

I'd sooner good players with issues than spuds with none.

We need to use trade bait. Whicj mfc players are OOC still? Which ones can we trade for mids

Jeremy Howe.

# do any One of these make sense?

some trade possibilities to ponder? who to keep, & who to trade, to build from our strengths.

??? Frawley + Blease ~ GWS (P1 + Adams) = Boyd + Adams

??? or ~ (pass on Boyd) for Aish & Adams & (Saints P21 + DelSanto & Fisher?)

??? or ontrade P1 & P20 to Carlton for Lachie Henderson + P10 & Tom Bell/Chris Yarran?

??? or ontrade P1 to Saints for P3 & P21 & Del Santo?

..................................

??? Gawn > Lions for (Billy Longer)?,,,, or > GWS for Taylor Adams?

or Gawn & Blease to Hawks for Xavier Ellis & Brad Sewell?

..........................................

??? Howe > GWS Taylor Adams + P9? or > GCS for Swallow?

..........................................

??? Lyndon Dunn to Carlton for Chris Yarran?

..........................................

?Tapscott ~ late 2nd/Rnd'r ?

?Blease ~ late 2nd/Rnd'r ?

?Spencer ~ 3rd/Rnd'r ?

?Bail ~ 3rd/Rnd'r ?

Every year this happens.

Why would you want to trade a proven player for one that only has potential?

Would have to be the worst potential trade posts I have ever read. No logic, no thought just grab a few names and get another post up.

You are truly deluded Deeluded.

bit like using hash tags on a forum...

Agreed! If you re-read the thread you'll see dee-luded did it first and my post was a tongue in cheek comment.

Jeremy Howe.

Could be anything under Roos. I see what you're saying but I'd rather offload a Tapscott or Strauss (who have less currency, I'm aware of that) than let go of Howe now.

no way Roos will trade out Jeremy Howe

Why would you give away the best mark in the game? Roos will find a way to utilize his strengths and he will be an absolute weapon for us

Every year this happens.

Why would you want to trade a proven player for one that only has potential?

Would have to be the worst potential trade posts I have ever read. No logic, no thought just grab a few names and get another post up.

You are truly deluded Deeluded.

I take it your talkling about Frawley out of that list,,, & none are hardened wishes of mine, but an open look at what we have as assets, & what if anything we could do with those assets.

I lead with Frawls because he has the biggest worth we have, and had made it known at one stage he was seeking out. he's got one year before he can walk.

we don't have much of hard value at present that we could achieve any multiplied results from.

so as an open discussion, I wondered what open minded supporters would be willing to do to get as many options to our club,,, to use in varying trade scenarios.

this could help to get us some mature players & also some young talents as well.

... & we all know we have some on the list who are clogs.

so, back to the question. I think these players are all tradable re the right circumstances.

Gawn

Blease

Howe

Dunn

Tapscott

Blease

Spencer

Bail

& Frawley is the most in demand from others, who have players we want.

we have a lot of work to do to build the list to a top 6 list.

to me, its a question of how quickly we can turn it around, & with who. a mixture of young and old, for quick & longer lasting effect.

no way Roos will trade out Jeremy Howe

Why would you give away the best mark in the game? Roos will find a way to utilize his strengths and he will be an absolute weapon for us

Because he has worth above his current ability.

In GWS he'd be worth a lot more because of this. (at GWS he may be worth Adams + their 2ndRnd Pick)? that pick may pickup Nat KJonses brother?

at the Suns he may be worth Swallow, who wants to come to Melbourne to live?

we need mids more than marks.

Edited September 25, 201311 yr by dee-luded