Has melbourne unofficially been sanctioned for tanking already?

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Assuming that we were perceived as tanking in 2009 (and I still feel that it will be quite hard to unequivocally demonstrate this to be the case given that we were in front at the final siren) does anyone else wonder whether losing Scully (or Scully being accessable as a potential pouching target for GWS) was an unofficial sanction from the AFL for making it too obvious??

Sounds crazy at first but think about it. No one in their wildest dreams thought that a number 1 draft pick would be available for pouching and that the AFL didnt veto the possibility some how.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,675]

We got two compo picks, the same as Geelong got for Ablett and more then the Dogs got for Ward. I'd say we're ahead.

[Sir Why You Little 35,073]

Assuming that we were perceived as tanking in 2009 (and I still feel that it will be quite hard to unequivocally demonstrate this to be the case given that we were in front at the final siren) does anyone else wonder whether losing Scully (or Scully being accessable as a potential pouching target for GWS) was an unofficial sanction from the AFL for making it too obvious??

Sounds crazy at first but think about it. No one in their wildest dreams thought that a number 1 draft pick would be available for pouching and that the AFL didnt veto the possibility some how.

Hard to say but i doubt it.

I was told after DB's final presser the AFL did not go in to deep into the allegations because of Jimma's health, so this is why i am concerned this time. I don't think the AFL ever want to hear the tanking word ever again.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,078]

Good point on the priority picks. But do they want to stain the memory of someone who received a state funeral?

[Sir Why You Little 35,073]

Good point on the priority picks. But do they want to stain the memory of someone who received a state funeral?

All i was told is that most of the other club presidents were not happy because we made it so public what the position was, but they all loved and respected Jimma...so whether it will be dealt with hard now is the unknown.

[IRW 1,283]

If they prove it in the kangaroo court that is the AFL there will be a very big fine and MFC will loose the Scully prioroty picks at the very least.

Probably more.

The Board will protect Jimmy............. and resign.

Its actually that simple. The only question is how much proof they reckon they need ,not what would stand up in civil courts.

Schwab will never work in AFL again, but possibly will get a gig in League.

[Range Rover 1,935]

If they prove it in the kangaroo court that is the AFL there will be a very big fine and MFC will loose the Scully prioroty picks at the very least.

Probably more.

The Board will protect Jimmy............. and resign.

Its actually that simple. The only question is how much proof they reckon they need ,not what would stand up in civil courts.

Schwab will never work in AFL again, but possibly will get a gig in League.

They'll need written or recorded communications with very specific instructions, not to mention Dean Bailey to commit career suicide.

Won't happen.

Edited August 2, 2012 by Range Rover

[daisycutter 28,704]

If they prove it in the kangaroo court that is the AFL there will be a very big fine and MFC will loose the Scully prioroty picks at the very least.

Probably more.

The Board will protect Jimmy............. and resign.

Its actually that simple. The only question is how much proof they reckon they need ,not what would stand up in civil courts.

Schwab will never work in AFL again, but possibly will get a gig in League.

Geez IRW get your hand off it. The worst that will happen is the AFL will alter the draft rules not because there was any tanking (in their opinion) but just to remove any false perceptions.

And the juggernaut will roll on as before

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

yes and Marilyn Monroe shot JFK from the grassy knoll

[dpositive 1,596]

If they prove it in the kangaroo court that is the AFL there will be a very big fine and MFC will loose the Scully prioroty picks at the very least.

Probably more.

The Board will protect Jimmy............. and resign.

Its actually that simple. The only question is how much proof they reckon they need ,not what would stand up in civil courts.

Schwab will never work in AFL again, but possibly will get a gig in League.

Could be a role in Badminton?????

[The Chazz 4,077]

They'll need written or recorded communications with very specific instructions, not to mention Dean Bailey to commit career suicide.

Won't happen.

The only thing that could bring us unstuck is if the AFL make an immunity deal with DB (and I wouldn't put it past them). They could tell him his job is safe, on the provision that he names names. But then, as the optimists (who probably call themselves realists) will tell us, unless there is written evidence, it's just a case of "he said/she said".

We SHOULD be ok, but I'll be a lot happier(?) when the issue has been dismissed and no further action to be taken. Oh, and when Paul Gardner has taken our advice and f**ked off.