Golly that's a tough question. Like this one...

Lets suppose thes is one club, the MFC

MFC - short term contract till November.

Which would you take?

But I have a job now in SA

Goes on forever

I hope we get him

I think he is good at his job

and it would stick it to his AFL nemesis

But I have a job now in SA

Goes on forever

I hope we get him

I think he is good at his job

and it would stick it to his AFL nemesis

I heard on BF i think his wife lives in VIC apparently

Correct me if I wrong but I thought we had offered the Pies guy the job and had to wait till his contract with Collingwood expired in October!

We cannot afford to wait until October - we need to get on with 2013 planning right now, and it looks as is we are likely to know quite soon which picks we will have.

I know a little about Matt and he is a nice guy and easy to get along with but most importantly has a track record of good draft selections. We would be remiss not to speak to him, especially considering our current list and the angst over many of our draft selections of the last few drafts.

Definitely need a guy with a proven track record.

Not only Craig, but our "recruitment manager" Todd Viney worked with Rendell for a couple of years too. Maybe he could "consult" to us for this year.

Well they as a team did a bloody good job, so reunite them asap.

"Fail to plan; plan to fail."

It would've been PR poison five minutes after he got the flick. The AFL would've blown a gasket as well. Plenty has happened since then - the guy who killed him commiting credibility suicide being one - and time heals all wounds and all that.

Yes, but that was always the contention.

Not straight away, as time heals, but this year it would be prudent.

And behind closed doors, there's nothing to have stopped us talking to him soon after the "incident."

On 3aw Sports Today, rumour that Rendell is going to be recruiting at collingwood...

Just announced as new head of recruiting at the Filth.

G Walsh to move on, apparently.

Gotta be Quick.

Unless he has at least one indigenous parent ,we shouldn't even consider him.

(Just my private thoughts said hypothetically)

Just announced as new head of recruiting at the Filth.

G Walsh to move on, apparently.

Geoff Walsh is "Director of Football", Derek Hine is "National Recruiting Manager".

Sounds like a big staff change-up or a half-baked rumour.

Rendell did say he was keen to get out of recruiting - he could easily go down the Director of Football path.

But what the hell does Eade do then?

Nothing on Collingwood website either...

Is true??? If so bloody well damn it!

Report in sun saying pies in talks but if they land rendall then he will replace taylor, and pies won't stop him coming to us so win win

Report in sun saying pies in talks but if they land rendall then he will replace taylor, and pies won't stop him coming to us so win win

http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport/afl/collingwood-in-talks-with-matt-rendell/story-e6frepf6-1226373066202

Report in sun saying pies in talks but if they land rendall then he will replace taylor, and pies won't stop him coming to us so win win

Yes, I hope it works like that. That would be advantageous.

And Eddie will try and spin it to make it look like they weren't being bitter little sh!ts at us poaching their staff...

Edited May 30, 201213 yr by rpfc

Rendell did say he was keen to get out of recruiting - he could easily go down the Director of Football path.

But what the hell does Eade do then?

Who???