$cully

[Guest lambtotheslaughter]

I despise the way $cully went about it

I hate the fact that he was right in doing it

dollars and sense

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I despise the way $cully went about it

I hate the fact that he was right in doing it

dollars and sense

The way hes playing he did us a favour.

[hardtack 10,626]

The way hes playing he did us a favour.

True RF, but the problem is, he would still probably run rings around most of our players the way we are performing at the moment.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

True RF, but the problem is, he would still probably run rings around most of our players the way we are performing at the moment.

But do we need another player that skirts the pack and waits for his team mates to get the ball to him?

Give me Jack Viney, he will get his own ball and crush Scully on the way through.

[hardtack 10,626]

But do we need another player that skirts the pack and waits for his team mates to get the ball to him?

Give me Jack Viney, he will get his own ball and crush Scully on the way through.

Can't argue with that... I'm just dreading the thought of seeing him have a blinder against us later this year.

[old dee 23,872]

Can't argue with that... I'm just dreading the thought of seeing him have a blinder against us later this year.

That makes two of us

[DemonWA 3,936]

I despise the way $cully went about it

I hate the fact that he was right in doing it

dollars and sense

Scully looks to have made the right choice for him. I take solace from the fact that GWS head hunted the wrong man!

[Neeld Help 7]

Sadly, it gets back to the administration again.

The Scully drama should never have been allowed to drag on like it did. A simple and reasonable time line needed to be set by MFC for him to commit for 2012 and beyond. It's not really that complicated. The same could go for the likes of Moloney now. Make him an offer soon if we wish to keep him. If he hasn't agreed by, say, Round 18 then it's no more games for him.

[robbo24 66]

We could do with Tom Scully on our list for the next 15 years. This is fact. We should be ashamed he felt it necessary to leave and we must get ourselves into a position that no player ever wants to leave us again...

[Samsara 65]

Yep, surely cannot blame him for his decision now. Perhaps the way he went about it, but he took a significant pay rise to play for a club that is showing a lot more promise than us at the moment.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Scully never bought in to the club or its history. The rumour was that he wasnt impressed with our lack of professionalism and training effort. its sad that we have in some ways proven his concerns right.

The whole scenario was a joke that made him look like a mercenary. But this is old territory.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

He got bucket loads of cash and went to a club that has actually won a game.

It's sad to say he made the right choice.

[Guest gidon]

Who cares. Is he about to win a premiership and when they are strong, will he get a game?

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Scully never bought in to the club or its history. The rumour was that he wasnt impressed with our lack of professionalism and training effort. its sad that we have in some ways proven his concerns right.

The whole scenario was a joke that made him look like a mercenary. But this is old territory.

That's true - but WYL and I are still [censored] at him!!

[jacey 333]

True RF, but the problem is, he would still probably run rings around most of our players the way we are performing at the moment.

Like it or not, he is a loss.

He has flaws in his football but he is the sort of player that we need.

Unfortunately Scully personality isn't the usual footballer.

Gary Lyon said None of the MFC people really know Tom and in GWS, non of them really know Tom. He's a bit of a loner. That's his personality.

He sees football as a job and works hard at it for the right price. MFC Recruiters must look deeper.

[bush demon 2,062]

Like it or not, he is a loss.

He has flaws in his football but he is the sort of player that we need.

Unfortunately Scully personality isn't the usual footballer.

Gary Lyon said None of the MFC people really know Tom and in GWS, non of them really know Tom. He's a bit of a loner. That's his personality.

He sees football as a job and works hard at it for the right price. MFC Recruiters must look deeper.

Good on the guy for setting himself up for life and I don't begrudge him any success with the GWS but we certainly benefited from his departure in terms of $$$ and recruiting options.

HIs loner mentality probably explains why he never fixed up his kicking

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Good on the guy for setting himself up for life and I don't begrudge him any success with the GWS but we certainly benefited from his departure in terms of $$$ and recruiting options.

HIs loner mentality probably explains why he never fixed up his kicking

I believe Sheedy said he just doesn't interact with the other players and that they thought we just hadn't handled him well, leading them to believe they could round him off and get the great footballer they required; guess what I don't think they do now.

[old dee 23,872]

I believe Sheedy said he just doesn't interact with the other players and that they thought we just hadn't handled him well, leading them to believe they could round him off and get the great footballer they required; guess what I don't think they do now.

Aint life wonderful.

If it does not work they will be have a long time to regret it.

another five years is a long time at $1miilion PA

[Red Demon 67]

He did nothing Mitch Clark didn't do.

[Supermercado 2,802]

Don't let this distract you from the cavalcade of abuse he richly deserves in Round 13.

[diesel 420]

Don't let this distract you from the cavalcade of abuse he richly deserves in Round 13.

Will always be a stain on the MFC's history.

He did nothing Mitch Clark didn't do.

Did Mitch Clarke state a desire to stay at Brisbane whilst his dad held a job offer in the top draw to become Melbournes newest recruiter? I can't remember any of that, remind me?

Edited May 21, 2012 by diesel

[Red Demon 67]

Did Mitch Clarke state a desire to stay at Brisbane whilst his dad held a job offer in the top draw to become Melbournes newest recruiter? I can't remember any of that, remind me?

Clark did state a desire to remain in Brisbane right up until he had to sign on the dotted line.

Don't kid yourself. Tom Scully is no different to Mitch Clark. Players come and go. Money talks.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,293]

Really?

Really?

REALLY???

Can we just put this crap behind us please.

[pantaloons 2,019]

Don't let this distract you from the cavalcade of abuse he richly deserves in Round 13.

This is the only thing I'm looking forward to for the rest of the season. It may be disgraceful, unbecoming, and hopefully the TV cameras are pointed to another section of fans, but he is going to bear the brunt of a season of frustration from yours truly. Let's not hate ourselves enough that we would bend over and give any credit to that weasel.

[bush demon 2,062]

Is anyone watching how he has gone? I rarely see any write-ups on his game performance, saw he was getting a few good stats recently but not really getting in best. Would be interested to hear from anyone who has watched the Greater Western Boys...