Sibling Rivalry

[Guest]

I'm a new poster to this forum but have been an avid reader for many years. I admire everybody's passion for our beloved Dees.

I notice on Demonology there is a post regarding our propensity for picking the "wrong" brother when recruiting. I guess there has been a lot of instances to support that view. However I think their have been some notable exceptions but as usual with Melbourne, there was a sting in the tail. We picked Alan Jakovich who made a lasting impact on our club in what was brief career. Glen was a legend at WCE and played in two premierships. I guess his longevity brought him out in front.

We also drafted Darren Jarman, clearly the best of those brothers but the "sting" was that he wouldn't come to the club.

I think it is too early to say that we drafted the wrong Grimes. We certainly thought we got the best one but Grimes the younger has come on this year big time.

I'm sure our recruiters try their best but it is about time we drafted a legitimate star that ignites this club and it's long suffering members.

I can only be thankful that the draft wasn't around in the early seventies otherwise I fear we may have drafted Tom instead of Robbie!!

[olisik 4,060]

Got the wrong Jetta

[robbo24 66]

Whether they're brothers or not I don't know but.. Ottens, Jetta, Bennell, Davey, Cockatoo-Collins

[Ouch! 2,258]

Isn't our Jetta a cousin?

and for the record I don't think any of us would have traded A Jakovich for his brother. Sure Glen was a great servant and won 2 premierships. But no-one would have missed being a part of the ride that Allan provided

[Guest José Mourinho]

Gaspar.

Jakovich.

Warnock.

Bennell (cousin).

Edited May 15, 2012 by José Mourinho

[DemonWA 3,929]

Whether they're brothers or not I don't know but.. Ottens, Jetta, Bennell, Davey, Cockatoo-Collins

Davey?!!

Aaron's career is 100x better than Alwyns

[Sir Why You Little 36,963]

We got the right Smith (Norm) but originally wanted to sign Len....phew!!

[old dee 23,778]

Davey?!!

Aaron's career is 100x better than Alwyns

Not sure that will be the case in two years time

[Guest]

Got the wrong Jetta

Even worse olisik. There are two Jettas better than ours (at this stage!)

I'd forgotten about Ottens and Gaspar. What were we thinking?

[Go the Biff 3,414]

Even worse olisik. There are two Jettas better than ours (at this stage!)

Might be worth hanging onto Nev for a while then as it took Leroy five years to get a kick.

[PaulRB 6,342]

My brothers picked Essendon (my Mum's team), I picked Melbourne (my Dad's team).

Never recovered from that decision.

Yet.

[Dr. Mubutu 830]

However I think their have been some notable exceptions but as usual with Melbourne, there was a sting in the tail. We picked Alan Jakovich who made a lasting impact on our club in what was brief career. Glen was a legend at WCE and played in two premierships. I guess his longevity brought him out in front.

No way. Wouldn't trade Jako's quick burn career for the other Jakovich ever.

Surely Allen Jakovich is a legend of MFC?

[Outside fifty 967]

Nice first post Demonism. The Bennell's are I believe cousins as are the Jetta's. As for Allen Jackovich he is without doubt one of my all-time favourite MFC players. Cocky, brash, flawed and insanely talented.

[Dr. Mubutu 830]

We got the right Smith (Norm) but originally wanted to sign Len....phew!!

Yep, glad we got the one with the right attitude who flogged all of Len's ideas!

[Sir Why You Little 36,963]

Allen Jakovich was a legend. Such a pity he did not play finals on the 'G.

[Sir Why You Little 36,963]

Yep, glad we got the one with the right attitude who flogged all of Len's ideas!

They were very close those two.

[Rogue 585]

No one else rated Richmond's Grimes that highly, right?

[Moonshadow 17,675]

Should we have drafted Jess Trengove instead???

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,589]

The whole Grimes family go for the Demons and I believe there are two or three more brothers to come, some of the family associated with north eastern melb local footy.

[deeko 952]

No one else rated Richmond's Grimes that highly, right?

I hope we rated him as he has been playing some really good games of late. He went in the rookie draft in which I think we obviously rated Joel MacDonald higher

[General 35]

Should we have drafted Jess Trengove instead???

Pretty sure she could have made a better fist of kicking for goal on Friday night too.

[Geddy Lee 582]

My brothers picked Essendon (my Mum's team), I picked Melbourne (my Dad's team).

Never recovered from that decision.

Yet.

Same here Paul!

[Rogue 585]

I hope we rated him as he has been playing some really good games of late. He went in the rookie draft

I rest my case.

[Guest]

While we are on it - what about the success or otherwise of our father/sons? Barassi was the best but then David Cordner certainly wasn't.

[Tim 3,413]

James McDonald the best of that clan.