INJURY LIST - Round 2

[Arrow 1,257]

Our injury list atmo, for Rnd 2.

Ricky Petterd (leg) - test

James Strauss (concussion) - test

Jake Spencer (knee) - 1 week

Lucas Cook (groin) - 2 weeks

Liam Jurrah (wrist) - 3 weeks

Colin Sylvia (back) - 3 weeks

Jordan Gysberts (ankle) - 4-6 weeks

-----------------------------------------------

Michael Evans (back) - indefinite

Neville Jetta (ankle) - indefinite

Rory Taggert (back) - indefinite

Max Gawn (knee) - season

I wouldn't take Petterd to Subi after a couple of weeks of soreness in the Legs. give him a week @ Casey to settle.

Same with Strauss. Only played one VFL game I think.

So the others have to come from last weeks Casey Team. Sellar, Couch, TMcDonald, Morton, Bennell ?

Frankston, Box Hill and Williamstown that's 3 to me. Week off almost could be a blessing in disguise.

[Satan 2,870]

http://www.injuryupdate.com.au/afl-injury-list.php

see magner

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

http://www.injuryupdate.com.au/afl-injury-list.php

see magner

How reliable has this site been in the past? shattering if true!

[Arrow 1,257]

How reliable has this site been in the past? shattering if true!

It currently has Wells as Indefinite and he played last round. Dont stress too much!

[P-man 13,366]

http://www.injuryupd...injury-list.php

see magner

I'd say that update is purely speculative, plus Gysberts isn't even on the list so taken with a half a grain of salt.

[hardtack 10,520]

I'd say that update is purely speculative, plus Gysberts isn't even on the list so taken with a half a grain of salt.

Possible that they got the Gys and Magner confused, I suppose.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Possible that they got the Gys and Magner confused, I suppose.

Quite easy to do: same style, build, intensity.

In all seriousness though, I will be very surprised if Magner doesn't play this weekend. It looking like one of those injuries that will maybe hurt a bit after you do it and maybe the next day or two, but he's a tough cookie and I'm sure will be able to shake it off.

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

I'd say that update is purely speculative, plus Gysberts isn't even on the list so taken with a half a grain of salt.

Yea they have rutten in there as injured during the preseason back in round 2 but he played last week and they have Rory Thompson from the GC in there twice with two different injuries...not sure I'm taking too much notice of this one...

[old dee 23,782]

Curious.

No Dan Nicholson and no James Magner on the injured list.

Nicholson missed last week but isn't on the injury list although at least on Internet poster has stated that he heard Nicholson say he was likely to miss another couple of games. He was seen a fortnight ago at Casey Field wearing a moonboot (& stating it was a precaution).

Right?

Magner limped off with what appeared to be an ankle injury.

One of these blokes is in line for the this week's Mystery injury of the Week come Thursday night!

How about the MIOTW award Jack?

It might provide I little light relief in what is shaping as a depressing year.

[deanbarber 37]

@AFL: Jordan Gysberts (@MelbourneFC) will miss up to six weeks after hurting his ankle in the VFL last weekend http://t.co/yI7hj1cI

[daisycutter 29,605]

anyone know what 'hurting his ankle' means?

[old dee 23,782]

anyone know what 'hurting his ankle' means?

Sounds to me DC like he hit it with a hammer.

But Juddie's grandmother reckons he did on purpose so he could escape the trip to Perth.

But what would she know!

[east gippsland demon 7]

What about tapscott ? hoping to see him make the trip to wa ...

[olisik 4,060]

I hope none of these players use all these early career injuries as an excuse for poor performances later on in there career (Sylvia).

If it is an acceptable excuse then we should not be drafting players who may be prone to injury.

I would hate to see a 25 yr old Gysberts running around whinging about his poor possession count because he wasn't fully developed yet due to allot of injuries early in his career.

It feels like every year our injury list is quite substantial which then turn into excuses.

[hardtack 10,520]

I hope none of these players use all these early career injuries as an excuse for poor performances later on in there career (Sylvia).

I don't recall Sylvia using early career injury as an excuse... do you have a link to this information?

[dee-luded 2,959]

anyone know what 'hurting his ankle' means?

Theres a video DC of Misson & Burgan, discussing the injuries. Said Gysberts is like Jettas but not as severe. Jettas I assume required a full reco of the Ankle.

Gysberts they said, wasn't as bad & they don't believe it needs surgery. 6 weeks is the outside estimate, hoping towards 4 weeks.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Strauss appears significantly under done given only one game to date after his horrendous injury

I hope so. I get no comfort from his absence from the injury list.

We dont know anything about his injury and his age may have little to do with it if the injury is serious.

Agree. We should have foretold the future and known he would have done his back. Bloody BBP! Here were the comments on his selection at the time. I am sure you felt otherwise but remained silent.

http://demonland.com...b-rory-taggert/

I'd be quite happy to see them take a go slow with Strauss, after such a serious career threatening injury. And it still is...

[olisik 4,060]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/more-news/colin-sylvia-confronts-his-demons/story-e6frf9jf-1225902505679

[hardtack 10,520]

http://www.heraldsun...f-1225902505679

Thanks for the link (to an almost 2 year old article)... after reading that, I would argue that he was NOT using those early injuries as an excuse at all... he was stating facts and was using that time he had lost as an incentive/motivation to improve himself and indeed it was at about that time that he did start make big steps towards improving his game... osteitis pubis early in his career and more recently interruptions in the form of a broken jaw/cheekbone(?) and now a major back injury are hardly fabrications to be used as excuses - for some they would be almost career ending.

[olisik 4,060]

Thanks for the link (to an almost 2 year old article)... after reading that, I would argue that he was NOT using those early injuries as an excuse at all... he was stating facts and was using that time he had lost as an incentive/motivation to improve himself and indeed it was at about that time that he did start make big steps towards improving his game... osteitis pubis early in his career and more recently interruptions in the form of a broken jaw/cheekbone(?) and now a major back injury are hardly fabrications to be used as excuses - for some they would be almost career ending.

End of the day it is a 'reason' for slower development both mentally and physically.

Whether people want to call it an 'excuse' or a 'fact' or watever it is, its still the same thing and i hope that other players dont bring this up later on in there careers, guys like Grimes (who i dont think will as he is already exceptional), Gysberts (Could possibly), Petterd (Dont think he would either), Gawn, Taggart, Jurrah, Tapscott, Blease, Strause, Cook, Bail, Jetta, ect.

How are we constantly having a majority of our recruits off the park for so long when they are still infants in there career.

Only ones off the top of my head who i think have not had these issues are Trengove, Watts, Frawley, Jones, Howe and Bartram and look how far ahead of the pack they look already.

[Bossdog 2,002]

I hope none of these players use all these early career injuries as an excuse for poor performances later on in there career (Sylvia).

If it is an acceptable excuse then we should not be drafting players who may be prone to injury.

I would hate to see a 25 yr old Gysberts running around whinging about his poor possession count because he wasn't fully developed yet due to allot of injuries early in his career.

It feels like every year our injury list is quite substantial which then turn into excuses.

Mate is there one player at our club that you like????? Al I heard from you is [censored] [censored] [censored] He's no good, he should get sacked. If you don't like everthing about this footy club Bugger off.

[hardtack 10,520]

End of the day it is a 'reason' for slower development both mentally and physically.

Of course it was a reason!! Are you telling me that osteitis pubis would not hinder your development? Are you saying he should make no mention of this in an interview where would have been asked about such things? The main thrust of that article was that he was using those setbacks he cited as motivation to improve himself and he is spot on when he said it was time lost that he wished he could have back - it wasn't an excuse, it was a very honest piece of reflection on his part.

As I said, that article is two years old and the past two years have probably seen the biggest improvement in his game - so he was as good as his word. Unfortunately fate has intervened and he has been struck another injury blow... but I suppose you will take the view that he is likely to use that as a reason for any substandard performances he puts in later this year.... sorry, but I really do get sick of all of the unjustified rubbishing that players get on this site.

[olisik 4,060]

Mate is there one player at our club that you like????? Al I heard from you is [censored] [censored] [censored] He's no good, he should get sacked. If you don't like everthing about this footy club Bugger off.

Read and think before posting.

My next post mentioned that i thought Grimes was exceptional.

Not allowed to talk about injuries in an injury thread now? If your going to make attacks without looking into things properly then you bugger off.

Its exactly what a certain fella at the AFL just did and look at the stir he kicked up.

[savoydee 6]

Ricky Petterd (leg) - test

James Strauss (concussion) - test

Jake Spencer (knee) - 1 week

Lucas Cook (groin) - 2 weeks

Liam Jurrah (wrist) - 3 weeks

Colin Sylvia (back) - 3 weeks

Neville Jetta (ankle) - indefinite

Rory Taggert (back) - indefinite

Michael Evans (back) - indefinite

Max Gawn (knee) - season

Thanks for putting them in order of injury time.

[Bossdog 2,002]

Read and think before posting.

My next post mentioned that i thought Grimes was exceptional.

Not allowed to talk about injuries in an injury thread now? If your going to make attacks without looking into things properly then you bugger off.

Its exactly what a certain fella at the AFL just did and look at the stir he kicked up.

You can post what you like, but unlike you, I am a more positive person and don't bag players every week