Mitch Clark kicked 5 goals last week. Ben Hudson is dropped this week. Do people still regard Matthew's opinion too highly?

Assume Matthews doesn't do twitter but if he did it would be an avenue.

Gary Lyon bringing up that Hudson was dropped, then points out that he was meant to be a better recruit than Clark according to Leigh Mathews hahahaha

nice work Gaz

-asked it as a question to, without really making the big deal about it, just with a soft tone in his voice......made me quite happy

"wasnt he meant to be a better recruit than Mitch Clark?"

Edited April 12, 201213 yr by Jordie_tackles

They mentioned Leigh Matthews' comments on League Teams too.

Brereton says Clark has all the skills to be a good key forward. He knows a thing or two.

Matthews is an old man now and has always been a Melbourne hater!

I think most of us lost some respect for Matthews when he had a go at Jack Watts after his second game. Having a crack at an 18yr old in his 2nd game when he kicks a couple of goals and takes some handy marks.

Now he is saying that Clark will not be as good a recruit as Hudson is just ridiculous. Hudson will be lucky to play 10 games for the lions before he retires for a second time and Mitch will be with us for the next 6-8 years.

Sometimes these old commentators make stupid comments to seem relivent...you can say the same thing about Malthouse.

Matthews is an old man now and has always been a Melbourne hater!

John kennedy taught all of Hawthorn to hate us. Tiger Ridley stoked an old fire 35 years later. They still hate us now.

Wasn't Matthews a mentor to Dean Bailey during his tenure? Or am I getting confused...

Wasn't Matthews a mentor to Dean Bailey during his tenure? Or am I getting confused...

He was indeed.

Wasn't Matthews a mentor to Dean Bailey during his tenure? Or am I getting confused...

Now we know who to blame for our woes last year!

Brereton says Clark has all the skills to be a good key forward. He knows a thing or two.

I think he would know and more I think Leigh was just making controversy.

Matthews is an old man now and has always been a Melbourne hater!

A bit off topic, and I may be wrong... but I think I heard/read somewhere that he actually was a Melbourne supporter as a kid.

A bit off topic, and I may be wrong... but I think I heard/read somewhere that he actually was a Melbourne supporter as a kid.

well if that's true it just proves he's senile

How could you hate the Dees?