Outside the Box and from Left Field

[beelzebub 23,378]

what was the error

[The Chazz 4,077]

what was the error

Sadly, you don't know when you make them B59, and you will always turn agressive when someone pulls you up on something. Have a good day.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Yep, But before the top up players we need to chase Boak and/or Salopek, or other maturely built experienced players.

[beelzebub 23,378]

Sadly, you don't know when you make them B59, and you will always turn agressive when someone pulls you up on something. Have a good day.

Cant answer a simple question can you Billy.. Again Billy..what was the errorr / Its not a hard question..and you raised it.. But now evade.. Well done

I dont pretend Im always right.. educate me

[The Chazz 4,077]

Cant answer a simple question can you Billy.. Again Billy..what was the errorr / Its not a hard question..and you raised it.. But now evade.. Well done

I dont pretend Im always right.. educate me

1. You shot down a poster in this thread giving you a list of names that were under your age requirement, then a different poster mentioned the name of a 22 year old, which you agreed met your criteria. Then when you were pulled up on it, the best you had was that next year he would be 23. Trying to use anything you can to make yourself look like the smart ass (as per normal).

2. Your initial posts on the Petter thread were totally incorrect. While this is an opinion thing to some degree, your constant ranting about Political Correctness is totally incorrect. Telling someone you are going to take their mother somewhere and rape them, doing this on 2 occasions, it in far from politically incorrect. What it is is out right disrespectful and has know place in society in general, let alone on a football field (which you seem to think is fair game).

3. Your constant opinion, an you're not on your own here, is regarding Mr Scully. You are certain that he is going to GWS, with absolutely no facts to back you up. In 6 weeks you may be right, but in the mean time, anything you say is complete rubbish (like most things on the Scully threads). When I asked you to come out with a simple Yes or No regarding him staying, you, which is typical, sat on the fence, trying to protect yourself just in case he stays.

[beelzebub 23,378]

1. You shot down a poster in this thread giving you a list of names that were under your age requirement, then a different poster mentioned the name of a 22 year old, which you agreed met your criteria. Then when you were pulled up on it, the best you had was that next year he would be 23. Trying to use anything you can to make yourself look like the smart ass (as per normal).

2. Your initial posts on the Petter thread were totally incorrect. While this is an opinion thing to some degree, your constant ranting about Political Correctness is totally incorrect. Telling someone you are going to take their mother somewhere and rape them, doing this on 2 occasions, it in far from politically incorrect. What it is is out right disrespectful and has know place in society in general, let alone on a football field (which you seem to think is fair game).

3. Your constant opinion, an you're not on your own here, is regarding Mr Scully. You are certain that he is going to GWS, with absolutely no facts to back you up. In 6 weeks you may be right, but in the mean time, anything you say is complete rubbish (like most things on the Scully threads). When I asked you to come out with a simple Yes or No regarding him staying, you, which is typical, sat on the fence, trying to protect yourself just in case he stays.

1) My OP to this tthread commented upon the more mature or thereabouyts.. The names proffered except for one were under the age. That was the context. Do you get that ?? probably not. Mohr whilst curently 22 will actuall be 23 at or around the time of any drafting this year. So fall entirely within thecontext of the OP. That was entirely the premise of this thread, that maybe the club looked to a matured player, as he is.The others inth emain were players already at this club when younger..theres actuiallyu a point of difference. Probably a big hard for you to grasp.

2)You have your opinion aboutth Petterd incident.. others have a differing one. At no time did I suggest it was laudable only that there was no vilification of the type the mass hysteria ( you included bought into. There was however a nasty comment made and that is one which I would imagine McGinnity would be most sheepish about. You like many dont get subtle differences. Sledging is sledgiing. Possibly distasteful but he did not walk up to Petterd's mum and vilify her.

3) dont like my thoughts on Scully or such..well suck it up princess.. What many of us here have shown is that all is not quite as many would have it appear. When shown differing situations and comments that dont sit well with the "Boy said this..etc " brigade you and many get all shirty, invoking some yet unknown constraint that nothing but abject purity must emit from those put on pedastals. Others like to construct from overview.

enjoyed your lilttel rant Billy Boy ?

care to return to the subject of the thread?

if not..PM me.. PM who the %4# you like..

[rpfc 28,478]

You know what we should do?

Look at the state leagues! Get some ready made players in their prime.

Oh, rpfc, you've done it again!

[Guest Thomo]

You know what we should do?

Look at the state leagues! Get some ready made players in their prime.

Oh, rpfc, you've done it again!

What a brilliant idea!! No club has ever thought of that. You should start a new thread on it.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

2)You have your opinion aboutth Petterd incident.. others have a differing one. At no time did I suggest it was laudable only that there was no vilification of the type the mass hysteria ( you included bought into. There was however a nasty comment made and that is one which I would imagine McGinnity would be most sheepish about. You like many dont get subtle differences. Sledging is sledgiing. Possibly distasteful but he did not walk up to Petterd's mum and vilify her.

You dont understand the issue. *Cringe*

[Hobbits's 17]

you know what ? I reckon there must be some untapped mature players out there in the SANFL, VFL & WAFL that have missed the drafts. we should check the QAFL, NSWAFL and NT while we are at it. Rookie them and bring them on...oh wait a second..

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Tim Mohr - Casey Scorps

Age 22 195cm 98kgs Tall KP Defender. On the radar for GWS? and other Clubs. Very strong and had a very good year. Gotch rates him as the most improved player on the list.

I saw Mohr playing for Casey a couple of years ago and he looked pretty good, I wondered at the time why he wasn't on some club's list. IIRC he was playing in the ruck at the time and was a hard at it type.