The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

[Striker475 696]

The Good

The First Quarter

Juice

Maric

Martin in the Ruck

Jurrah

The Bad

Surrendering a 5-goal lead to lose eventually by 7

Brad Green

Bennell

3rd quarter goalkicking

Wonna not having the ability to run out 3 quarters

The Ugly

Injuries to Bail and Garland

Bailey forced to leave Garland on because he knew Bennell wasn't hard enough

Lynden Dunn - thank god you're getting suspended because that was terrible

The umpiring

[Adzman 2,154]

I would rather sit through a Miley Cyrus concert than watch our club play like that again.

If it wasn't for that first quarter then that would be one of the worst losses in the past few years. We got flogged by a bunch of talentless nobodies.

[Striker475 696]

oh to add to the ugly the fact that you could see it coming 5mins into the second quarter and knew nothing would change

[Wiseblood 24,637]

The Good:

Martin and Newton giving a real contest up against a quality ruckman in Goldstein

Davey and Sylvia had a crack

The first quarter

The Bad:

The last three quarters

Our forward line struggled - Petterd, Wona, Watts etc couldn't get there hands on it enough

Moloney struggling with a hard tag

Jetta, Maric and Bennell when he came on not giving us enough when it counted.

The Ugly:

The injuries

The umpiring

The way we roll over way too easily.

[titan_uranus 24,979]

As bad as the West Coast game.

Good

Frawley

Tapscott

Bad

Everything after quarter time

Newton being put in the ruck

Newton when in the ruck

Jetta

Bennell

Ugly

Dunn (doesn't deserve another game this year)

The injuries

Going from 31 points up to 41 points down

[Geddy Lee 582]

oh to add to the ugly the fact that you could see it coming 5mins into the second quarter and knew nothing would change

This.

I was sitting in the Kangaroos cheer squad and it was painfully obvious.

Bitterly cold and disappointed.

[ucanchoose 1,816]

Can someone tell me what Dunn did. Was sitting top level Coventry end and can't remember anything bad he did

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

G

the first half of the first quarter

the second half of the first quarter

Newton in the first quarter

Jurrah

B

Newton in the ruck

Watts in the backline(but played well)

Dunn on the ground

General fitness(even given the injuries)

The injuries

Ugg

7 goals in the first quarter, 5 for the rest of the match

The rest of the match

Etihad

MRP

[Striker475 696]

Can someone tell me what Dunn did. Was sitting top level Coventry end and can't remember anything bad he did

Early report, 2 FA, 8 disp - had a SC score of 19 which meant they were all ineffective basically.

[jayceebee31 759]

The worse thing that came to life today was the pathetic leadership and in particular Brad Green.Sometimes he looks timid.

[titan_uranus 24,979]

Can someone tell me what Dunn did. Was sitting top level Coventry end and can't remember anything bad he did

Hopefully you're joking. Either that or where you were sitting was so far from the ground you honestly couldn't see him.

He was woeful.

Deserves 5 weeks for a crude bump on Pratt early on. Then proceeded to give free kicks away left right and centre, soft (again) in marking contests, didn't get involved in the play, and generally looked like a VFL reserves player.

Didn't deserve a game last week. Didn't deserve a game this week. Doesn't deserve a game next week (and won't get one), nor for a long time.

[ucanchoose 1,816]

Hopefully you're joking. Either that or where you were sitting was so far from the ground you honestly couldn't see him.

He was woeful.

Deserves 5 weeks for a crude bump on Pratt early on. Then proceeded to give free kicks away left right and centre, soft (again) in marking contests, didn't get involved in the play, and generally looked like a VFL reserves player.

Didn't deserve a game last week. Didn't deserve a game this week. Doesn't deserve a game next week (and won't get one), nor for a long time.

I just asked what he got reported for. Geez. Maybe I was tending to child at the time, I just didn't see it. I did see the rest of his game which was appalling.

Edited May 14, 2011 by ucanchoose

[titan_uranus 24,979]

I just asked what he got reported for. Geez. Maybe I was tending to child at the time, I just didn't see it. I did see the rest of his game which was appalling.

Oh right. I wasn't having a go at you btw.

He ran past the ball, and chose to bump Pratt, which was uncessary given he was on the ground without the ball. He hit him in the head. I can't imagine what he was trying to do other than bump him either.

[Nasher 33,607]

Dunn will be rubbed out for that I think and I for one won't be mourning. FFS, man.

[Supermercado 2,797]

Even though he did bugger all for the first three quarters I loved Maric's crumb goals at the end. Junktime or not they were beautifully taken.

[titan_uranus 24,979]

Even though he did bugger all for the first three quarters I loved Maric's crumb goals at the end. Junktime or not they were beautifully taken.

Would have been nice for him to get involved in the first half, but I agree, he did some nice things late in the game.

[dee-luded 2,959]

The worse thing that came to life today was the pathetic leadership and in particular Brad Green.Sometimes he looks timid.

He's gone backwards JCB, this year. Like he's lost his commitment? He's gone back to where he was 3 or 4 Years back. Whats happened to his putting the head over the ball stuff, & lead by example?

Edit. PS: Is Green out of contract this year?

Edited May 14, 2011 by dee-luded

[QueenC 74]

Edit. PS: Is Green out of contract this year?

How quickly we forget.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

THE GOOD

Pie was perfect temperature and the Carlton Draught surprisingly good (normally horrible at ES)

I have nothing else to add.