Split with Casey?

[Mono 455]

.......

If the figure was only $250k they would have their own team as would Hawthorn and a few others.

I'm pretty sure the Box Hill Hawks are in fact a Hawthorn reserve side.

[Red Sox 2]

As I've mentioned previously, growing up and living for the most part in the Sth East, I've seen the effects close up on having Hawthorn so closely aligned with the area.

Playing out of Waverley and having such an involvement in junior clubs around the Sth East is a major reason that they now have such a huge membership list. Being so successful during the period obviously helped further.

MFC can't afford just to walk away from the Casey area. The opportunity to grow the supporter base is there, 30 years is a long time but at 35 years of age it is only the last 5-10 years that Hawthorns supporter base has grown so significantly.

The scorps may have backed MFC into a corner but had a decision to make also for them and their club. That is fair enough and it may force MFC's hand to go alone.

If MFC make this choice they have to stay in Casey, surely?

[beelzebub 23,384]

Money wise Vlad suggests it's around 500000 to field a reserves team . We already fund Casey to 250000. This is where it's suggested that for 250000 ( extra) we'd be able to run our own magoos.

From what I can understand there are quite a few issues the MFC and Scorps differ on,as to Melbournes reasons it seems only the club knows.

Maybe someone can Illuminate ?

[Longsufferingnomore 1,653]

Money wise Vlad suggests it's around 500000 to field a reserves team . We already fund Casey to 250000. This is where it's suggested that for 250000 ( extra) we'd be able to run our own magoos.

From what I can understand there are quite a few issues the MFC and Scorps differ on,as to Melbournes reasons it seems only the club knows.

Maybe someone can Illuminate ?

They were quoted in today's Age as being late payments to staff, disregarding medical advice and MFC concerns re Caseys intention to build a large gaming venue. I thought Cameron's comments were very telling as usually he is very circumspect in his comments to the media so obviously there have been some ongoing issues for some time.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

I think It's a stupid decision, Casey can recruit who they want and it shouldn't affect our relationship with them. If it's because the Melbouren FC now feel pressured to recruit Fevola for 2012, we don't have to. No point paying the 250k or whatever to set up our own independent club in the VFL, if every team is gonna start this then there may as well be the "reserves" again and the VFL will be destroyed.

[old dee 23,908]

They were quoted in today's Age as being late payments to staff, disregarding medical advice and MFC concerns re Caseys intention to build a large gaming venue. I thought Cameron's comments were very telling as usually he is very circumspect in his comments to the media so obviously there have been some ongoing issues for some time.

Well now we are getting a larger part of the story "longsuffering" thank you for that insight.

There may be more to this than I thought.

Is Fev the straw that breaks the camels back?

[beelzebub 23,384]

What is the CONCERN regarding any proposed gaming venue ?

[Guest melbman]

Rather than an annual 250K cash injection to the Scorpions, maybe the Dees could supply the staff that would listen to medical advice, admin staff to distribute the payments on time and try to have more people in the decision making chain i.e. board members and such

[Je Roos Salem 661]

What is the CONCERN regarding any proposed gaming venue ?

The concern is that Fevola will be able to access it!

[old dee 23,908]

The concern is that Fevola will be able to access it!

I am sure you are jesting "steveheals" however Fev will be long gone by the time that gets up!

[wonnabeeri 277]

Fev booted from crown today.

Aleopard doesnt change his spots. What a muppet.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

I am sure you are jesting "steveheals" however Fev will be long gone by the time that gets up!

Yes I was 'Jesting' Old Dee. Or should I say Medieval Dee?

[old dee 23,908]

Yes I was 'Jesting' Old Dee. Or should I say Medieval Dee?

My God I think that is a bit too far

But if it gives you joy!

[Mydee 288]

I agree lets get rid of them. Melbourne means ALL of Melbourne not just some bogan back water on the cities eastern fringe. Anyhow it's to close to Moe.

I can sympathise with your view, but it doesn't work that way. People will tend to follow clubs which are based in their area and demographically Casey is in a growth corridor which augers well for future memberships but it is nice to have a whole of city brand.

[Red Sox 2]

I agree lets get rid of them. Melbourne means ALL of Melbourne not just some bogan back water on the cities eastern fringe. Anyhow it's to close to Moe.

Anyhow it's TOO close to Moe.

Before you generalise about a region, unnecessarily, might want to ensure you are beyond criticism.

You obviously work in marketing, WE ARE MELBOURNE must have been your genius. That bought a whole new generation of supporters to the club.

Not sure why the club didn't continue down that same path.

Maybe your insight could share?

Maybe you could come up with something rather than your very average attempt at humour.

Using the Moe card? Bogan is as bogan says.

[Supermercado 2,802]

if every team is gonna start this then there may as well be the "reserves" again and the VFL will be destroyed.

Ok, you've sold me. When can they start?

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Ok, you've sold me. When can they start?

When they dust the cobwebs off

[Sir Why You Little 37,239]

I am not joking we are all getting worked up about things that probably won't happen.

At Sandy and Casey there have always been cases where their team selection took priority over MFC needs.

That is what happens when you have an alliance and not your own team.

Why do Geelong and Collingwood have their own teams?

So they can get their own way all of the time!

We along with most other sides cannot afford one so lets get on with doing the best with what we have.

By its very nature an alliance will always have differences of opinion.

Sometimes that means you have to "suck it up" this is one of those occasions.

Why not add another $10-20 to each membership to pay for a reserve side- i would pay that right now.

Who wants an alliance when they don't work.

You old Dee accept 2nd Best and for me that aint good enough anymore.

We are only a poorer club because we the supporters let it happen.

TIME TO WAKE UP PEOPLES...! B)

[Mono 455]

They were quoted in today's Age as being late payments to staff, disregarding medical advice and MFC concerns re Caseys intention to build a large gaming venue. I thought Cameron's comments were very telling as usually he is very circumspect in his comments to the media so obviously there have been some ongoing issues for some time.

The quote was actually "lack of respect shown to the club's medical team".

I'm betting this relates to virtually no MFC players being made available (for medical reasons) for Casey during the finals over to past 2 years - and Casey were very well placed last year only to get absolutely flogged in each finals game when they came up against a host of AFL players playing for their affiliates (or home teams).

I remember at the time I thought it absurd, and why would Casey want to be involved with us if we treat them like that. Peter German left Casey 2 years ago; presumably for this reason.

[Keyser Söze 0]

The Scorpions can rot for all I care, if they think our players should risk their development and unnecessarily play through injury.

[Sir Why You Little 37,239]

The quote was actually "lack of respect shown to the club's medical team".

I'm betting this relates to virtually no MFC players being made available (for medical reasons) for Casey during the finals over to past 2 years - and Casey were very well placed last year only to get absolutely flogged in each finals game when they came up against a host of AFL players playing for their affiliates (or home teams).

I remember at the time I thought it absurd, and why would Casey want to be involved with us if we treat them like that. Peter German left Casey 2 years ago; presumably for this reason.

But why should we risk our players if they are in need of surgery? That is not part of any deal.

[H_T 3,049]

No they're not, They are trying to help out themselves. Shortsighted, poor decision.

Post #17. Covered.

[Demon 16 214]

If went started our own side, would there be room in the VFL for us?

Or would we be purchasing an existing license and replacing an existing team?

[Deevout 524]

Back in the days that VFL/AFL teams had there reserves sides the purpose was to keep fringe playes fit, get injured players back to match fitness for the firsts, and to blood young players for senior level. If a Premiership was won in the mean time this was a welcome bonus.

Board members of the MFC AND Casey have an obligation to do what is best for the clubs they are elected to represent, here I believe is the route cause of the problems with the affiliations between AFL and VFL clubs. BOTH clubs focus is on there teams winning a Premiership and often this is a problem for the other club. EG: Recuit Fev, must give Casey a greater chance of a flag, the availability of eligable MFC players during Caseys finals games can also be a problem for the Scorpions. On the other hand, Melbourne would be concerned about him influencing our younger players, and as the MFC have stated it may restrict a young MFC players development thus having an effect on the MFC's push for a loooong awaited Flag.

To win an AFL premiership a club must have everything going for it, with a tough of luck thrown in. So is Casey a help or a hinderance to this end. Constructive opinions please.

There are a number of solutions, none of them without alot of pain.

[digby wolf 1]

Anyhow it's TOO close to Moe.

Before you generalise about a region, unnecessarily, might want to ensure you are beyond criticism.

You obviously work in marketing, WE ARE MELBOURNE must have been your genius. That bought a whole new generation of supporters to the club.

Not sure why the club didn't continue down that same path.

Maybe your insight could share?

Maybe you could come up with something rather than your very average attempt at humour.

Using the Moe card? Bogan is as bogan says.

Your sense of humour AND your excellent spelling precede you hill. Private school education ? Lighten up 'old chap', you obviously live in the area and are slightly defensive about it. We can't all live in the inner suburbs so good luck to you.

Edited March 10, 2011 by Sad old Man