Jump to content

THE TOM SCULLY TO GWS THREAD


DirtyDees DDC

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 1.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hard to indicate anything positive or negative comparing our issue with Geelong's similar issue last season. Geelong are a tough seasoned team who have dominated for the past four seasons. But it still hurt them greatly though not on the ladder. This year will tell what the residue damage might be. We are still in our nappies.

Edited by america de cali
Link to comment
Share on other sites

To answer why any imperative to sooner (much) rather than later:

I read Garry's article. It's very good. Healthy perspective.if only it was that straightforward..

There are a number of ways to look at this. Some will see varying relevance; some possibly none lol.

Today football is big business. Players are the ingredients in a complex recipe. You plan success upon the nurturing and realization of the various 'crops' year to year. Much effort , time and certainly not least, money is invested. The players are the fruit of all this.

One view, ripening fruit for your adversaries can't be looked upon as terribly clever.

Another:

You're an employer. Your staff / team members are your greatest asset. Would you knowingly upsikill someone if you were aware they were to defect to your competition? Be honest here, of course not. You put those resources behind someone who is going to give a return. Win/win

Whilst Garry, Dean , Jimma et all utter the 'good talk' of eyes on the ball and these things work out it's really a front. A front for denial.

Look at Geelong, they went completely off the boil last season. Yes some may attribute a little to two-face Thompson but without doubt it was the uncertainty surrounding Abblett. There team was even more cemented than ours is yet and still it gnawed away. Despite any efforts of club or players the media has it's bone and won't let it alone.

Do you seriously think this will die down just because those involved would like? No chance in he'll.

There's a great big elephant at the MFC and it needs to be addressed and sorted.

Were I a player I'd find it awkward . Does he want to stay or go. I have no issue should he go. It's his life. Take the money; no probs here.

I'm not going to blame him for any predicament he's in as it's the makings really of the AFL scurrilous loopholes.

Abject secrecy, from your team mates, friends, club etc is abhorrent.

Young Tom seems a fellow of outstanding character. I'm but asking him to show it. Show his cards. Play your own game not the leagues conceitful skullduggery .

The only way to truly make it go way is to dispense with it. Nullify it.

Then and only then can all get onwith things without looking over shoulders and second guessing.

I fully acknowledge the intent and sincerity behind the stiff upper chin approach but it's really just putting off today's dealings for tomorrows pain.

We all know what "contract negotiations at seasons end" really translates to.

You need to know where all stand.

Couldn't disagree more - WE the SUPPORTERS want to know now. I am no different - I want it resolved now. The club I am sure would like to know now.

There are several players unsigned at the moment that come out of contract at the end of this year and the reason we are getting up in arms about these others players is because of rumour and innuendo ( which could turn out to be correct) is not surrounding these players

A mature club would not rush head on into giving ultimatums and demanding alternative timetables purely to dispel rumours and make us feel better.

Look at the Watts example last year - there were mild nervous rumblings that he had not signed but certainly not the mass hysteria we are seeing now - why ? because the rumours of him being targeted were not circulating. Why was there not the demands for his contract to be resolved earlier last year ? Again - because we didnt think he was being targeted. Why didnt we call for him to be at Casey until his contract was signed - again - no pressure due to no rumours. In fact with the Davey and Green contract negotiations there were even less rumblings and there were counter offers on the table. We are being ruled by emotion not good business practice. Let negotiations take their natural course. I hope we have learned something from the Thompson handling of the Ablett situation - I think Geelong have and will handle Bartel situation a little differently. ( read the article in Hun earlier this week and Geelongs stance)

Realistically - what is the rush ? It is only that we want this agony to go away. Look that NRL equivalent - they have players that sign up with other clubs before seasons end. If these clubs are making a play for the finals - do they not play these players ? Of course they do and these players go at it just as hard. The notion that we are putting development into a player for someone is more than countered by the argument that the player whilst at our club will help us win games. The only argument that holds some water is that a player leaving is taking a spot of someone else we could be developing. If it is a choice of playing finals this year because Scully has a cracker of a year and will make such a difference as opposed to putting time into another player because Scully is leaving - I vote for finals

I again re-iterate to the club - negotiate as you would normally negotiate - do not be rushed into ultimatums because of media/supporter pressure. "put up or [censored] off" negotiation stances usually end unhappily.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

how then did it hurt them? Please don't tell me they would have won that prelim and then the flag if it wasn't for the Ablett situation

I will counter that they may not have won games last year and may not have made it as far as they did if it wasnt for Ablett.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I will counter that they may not have won games last year and may not have made it as far as they did if it wasnt for Ablett.

WHAT? we are discussing whether or not having a gun player 'in limbo' affects the club during the season. Obviously it had NO effect on their ability to win games so what negative effects are there to worry about? 'Off-field issues' ADC please do tell

Link to comment
Share on other sites

WHAT? we are discussing whether or not having a gun player 'in limbo' affects the club during the season. Obviously it had NO effect on their ability to win games so what negative effects are there to worry about? 'Off-field issues' ADC please do tell

Work it out for yourself.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


WHAT? we are discussing whether or not having a gun player 'in limbo' affects the club during the season. Obviously it had NO effect on their ability to win games so what negative effects are there to worry about? 'Off-field issues' ADC please do tell

The only negative effects is my ulcer developing, supporters having apoplexy and the media working themselves into a frenzy. The players dont play any differently and Ablett certainly didnt drop his bundle - the only one who did drop the bottom lip was Mark Thompson - and I think his end season burnout says a lot to his state of mind.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To answer why any imperative to sooner (much) rather than later:

I read Garry's article. It's very good. Healthy perspective.if only it was that straightforward..

There are a number of ways to look at this. Some will see varying relevance; some possibly none lol.

Today football is big business. Players are the ingredients in a complex recipe. You plan success upon the nurturing and realization of the various 'crops' year to year. Much effort , time and certainly not least, money is invested. The players are the fruit of all this.

One view, ripening fruit for your adversaries can't be looked upon as terribly clever.

Another:

You're an employer. Your staff / team members are your greatest asset. Would you knowingly upsikill someone if you were aware they were to defect to your competition? Be honest here, of course not. You put those resources behind someone who is going to give a return. Win/win

Whilst Garry, Dean , Jimma et all utter the 'good talk' of eyes on the ball and these things work out it's really a front. A front for denial.

Look at Geelong, they went completely off the boil last season. Yes some may attribute a little to two-face Thompson but without doubt it was the uncertainty surrounding Abblett. There team was even more cemented than ours is yet and still it gnawed away. Despite any efforts of club or players the media has it's bone and won't let it alone.

Do you seriously think this will die down just because those involved would like? No chance in he'll.

There's a great big elephant at the MFC and it needs to be addressed and sorted.

Were I a player I'd find it awkward . Does he want to stay or go. I have no issue should he go. It's his life. Take the money; no probs here.

I'm not going to blame him for any predicament he's in as it's the makings really of the AFL scurrilous loopholes.

Abject secrecy, from your team mates, friends, club etc is abhorrent.

Young Tom seems a fellow of outstanding character. I'm but asking him to show it. Show his cards. Play your own game not the leagues conceitful skullduggery .

The only way to truly make it go way is to dispense with it. Nullify it.

Then and only then can all get onwith things without looking over shoulders and second guessing.

I fully acknowledge the intent and sincerity behind the stiff upper chin approach but it's really just putting off today's dealings for tomorrows pain.

We all know what "contract negotiations at seasons end" really translates to.

You need to know where all stand.

...so we seek an ultimatum?

I would love to know where we stand, but it isn't our right to know.

Let's be prudent and work through this like a confident club.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With this thread going around and around in ever-diminishing circles, it can only be a matter of time before it disappears up its own fundament.

For all those who are certain one way or the other, remember that wise people are full of doubt and see all shades of grey, while stupid people have no doubts and see things in black and white terms.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's no Grey at Melbourne. Just Red and Blue.

GWS however embraces Grey!!!

Common sense dictates you only build longevity and securely on firm foundations. That comes from knowledge, not uncertainty or guesswork.

Wise men also know for every proverb a balancing one can be found ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For all those who are certain one way or the other, remember that wise people are full of doubt and see all shades of grey, while stupid people have no doubts and see things in black and white terms.

If that is the case then wise people don't post here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Had morning tea at aami park cafe today as I was working there for the day. Saw a few of the boys having something to eat. Scully and Rob Campbell were sitting away from everyone having what looked to be a serious talk. They were chatting for at least a half hour. Would love to be a fly on the wall.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I can see this thread going to 100 pages and 5000 posts.

Impossible. Apologies in advance but.....

If it's 100 pages it will be ~4000 posts or if it is 5000 posts it will be ~125 pages. Either way it's a mammoth thread.

But it's quite feasible on current form that ADC may contribute to nearly half of that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Had morning tea at aami park cafe today as I was working there for the day. Saw a few of the boys having something to eat. Scully and Rob Campbell were sitting away from everyone having what looked to be a serious talk. They were chatting for at least a half hour. Would love to be a fly on the wall.

Thats actually quite interesting. Campbell despite newness to club is seen by club as a wise head, a mentor type for the younger ones.

Fly, wall.. Yes fascinating lol.

I see no need to rush to negotiations per se but what motive is there for the Scully camp not to open them or at least suggest "my intent is to pursue a career at Melbourne. Managent and the club will look at and hopefully agree to mutually beneficial conditions and remunerations as soon as able"

Nothing needs to be rushed into . Slams door on vultures. Everyone gets on with it all.

Or, we have what we have. Totally unecessary unless ulterior motives lurk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Then you must be wise and/or colour blind.

I can be whatever you want.

I just don't think you are interpreting the 'facts' correctly.

And I think that you don't show enough circumspection when discussing what should be done.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats actually quite interesting. Campbell despite newness to club is seen by club as a wise head, a mentor type for the younger ones.

Fly, wall.. Yes fascinating lol.

I see no need to rush to negotiations per se but what motive is there for the Scully camp not to open them or at least suggest "my intent is to pursue a career at Melbourne. Managent and the club will look at and hopefully agree to mutually beneficial conditions and remunerations as soon as able"

Nothing needs to be rushed into . Slams door on vultures. Everyone gets on with it all.

Or, we have what we have. Totally unecessary unless ulterior motives lurk.

That's implied is it not?

He plays for us. He puts the jumper on and runs 25kms a game.

If we don't believe this view is held on all our players at face value, then we are in a terrible place.

If we ask that question then we are saying to our players - we don't believe you're serious about this club because you haven't committed your intent to be apart of our future in the press.

And do you really think that a statement other than a 're-signing' statement will quell the innuendo and pressure?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Scully is much more valuable to us than Moloney or Petterd, for a start.

Arguably already a better player too (definitely in my opinion).

We do NOT have a surplus of elite mids.

We have a surplus of promising talented kids who could potentially play in the midfield.

Scully has in one season shown he belongs there as a general. You undersell him terribly.

We could get 2 x 1st round picks for him, sure.

They could end up being Jarrad Oakley-Nichols and James Sellar.

Or Daniel O'Keefe and Beau Dowler.

Or Marcus Drum and Adam Thomson.

Or John Meesen and Danny Meyer.

All 1st round picks.

Instead of Scully.

The last bolded part is incorrect.

It is irrelevant until the end of the season.

This is only an issue in the minds of frustrated and frenzied supporters.

Get over it.

Chances are we won't know until late in the season, at earliest, no matter how much hand-wringing you engage in.

Hard for me to say -but the above is a true, concise and accurate post..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can be whatever you want.

I just don't think you are interpreting the 'facts' correctly.

And I think that you don't show enough circumspection when discussing what should be done.

You have the novel ability of seeing "facts" as grey.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's implied is it not?

He plays for us. He puts the jumper on and runs 25kms a game.

If we don't believe this view is held on all our players at face value, then we are in a terrible place.

If we ask that question then we are saying to our players - we don't believe you're serious about this club because you haven't committed your intent to be apart of our future in the press.

And do you really think that a statement other than a 're-signing' statement will quell the innuendo and pressure?

This whole issue really is " a disturbing conundrum" ( for the future, abbreviated to "ADC" )

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Demonland Forums  

  • Match Previews, Reports & Articles  

    2024 Player Reviews: #19 Josh Schache

    Date of Birth: 21 August 1997 Height: 199cm   Games MFC 2024: 1 Career Total: 76   Goals MFC 2024: 0 Career Total: 75     Games CDFC 2024: 12 Goals CDFC 2024: 14   Originally selected to join the Brisbane Lions with the second pick in the 2015 AFL National Draft, Schache moved on to the Western Bulldogs and played in their 2021 defeat to Melbourne where he featured in a handful of games over the past two seasons. Was unable to command a

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons

    2024 Player Reviews: #21 Matthew Jefferson

    Date of Birth: 8 March 2004 Height: 195cm   Games CDFC 2024: 17 Goals CDFC 2024: 29 The rangy young key forward was a first round pick two years ago is undergoing a long period of training for senior football. There were some promising developments during his season at Casey where he was their top goal kicker and finished third in its best & fairest.

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 9

    2024 Player Reviews: #23 Shane McAdam

    Date of Birth: 28 May 1995 Height: 186cm Games MFC 2024: 3 Career Total: 53 Goals MFC 2024: 1 Career Total:  73 Games CDFC 2024: 11 Goals CDFC 2024: 21 Injuries meant a delayed start to his season and, although he showed his athleticism and his speed at times, he was unable to put it all together consistently. Needs to show much more in 2025 and a key will be his fitness.

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 14

    2024 Player Reviews: #43 Kyah Farris-White

    Date of Birth: 2 January 2004 Height: 206cm   Games CDFC 2024: 4 Goals CDFC 2024:  1   Farris-White was recruited from basketball as a Category B rookie in the hope of turning him into an AFL quality ruckman but, after two seasons, the experiment failed to bear fruit.  

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 1

    2024 Player Reviews: #44 Luker Kentfield

    Date of Birth: 10 September 2005 Height: 194cm   Games CDFC 2024: 9 Goals CDFC 2024: 5   Drafted from WAFL club Subiaco in this year’s mid season draft, Kentfield was injured when he came to the club and needs a full season to prepare for the rigors of AFL football.  

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons

    REDLEG PRIDE by Meggs

    Hump day mid-week footy at the Redlegs home ground is a great opportunity to build on our recent improved competitiveness playing in the red and blue.   The jumper has a few other colours this week with the rainbow Pride flag flying this round to celebrate people from all walks of life coming together, being accepted. AFLW has been a benchmark when it comes to inclusivity and a safe workplace.  The team will run out in a specially designed guernsey for this game and also the following week

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    AFLW Melbourne Demons

    REDEEMING by Meggs

    It was such a balmy spring evening for this mid-week BNCA Pink Lady match at our favourite venue Ikon Park between two teams that had not won a game since round one.   After last week’s insipid bombing, the DeeArmy banner correctly deemanded that our players ‘go in hard, go in strong, go in fighting’, and girl they sure did!   The first quarter goals by Alyssa Bannan and Alyssia Pisano were simply stunning, and it was 4 goals to nil by half-time.   Kudos to Mick Stinear.

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    AFLW Melbourne Demons

    REDEEM by Meggs

    How will Mick Stinear and his dwindling list of fit and available Demons respond to last week’s 65-point capitulation to the Bombers, the team’s biggest loss in history?   As a minimum he will expect genuine effort from all of his players when Melbourne takes on the GWS Giants at Ikon Park this Thursday.  Happily, the ground remains a favourite Melbourne venue of players and spectators alike and will provide an opportunity for the Demons to redeem themselves. Injuries to star play

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    AFLW Melbourne Demons

    EASYBEATS by Meggs

    A beautiful sunny Friday afternoon, with a light breeze and a strong Windy Hill crowd set the scene, inviting one team to seize the day and take the important four points on offer. For the Demons it was not a good Friday, easily beaten by an all-time largest losing margin of 65 points.   Essendon threw themselves into action today, winning most of the contests and had three early goals with Daria Bannister on fire.  In contrast the Demons were dropping marks, hesitant in close and comm

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    AFLW Melbourne Demons 9
  • Tell a friend

    Love Demonland? Tell a friend!

×
×
  • Create New...