Justin Sherman

[Whispering_Jack 28,023]

This player always seems to get good wraps when he plays from Brisbane.

It seems that he's now on the outer or at least looking for a new home according to the Sunday HUN.

Any opinions?

[No16 1]

Had a very up and down season this year. Not playing anywhere near the way that had him playing in the International Series a couple of years ago where he was one of the next up and coming youngsters to watch out for.

Goes missing in games for long periods.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,282]

My understanding is he has spent alot of time hanging out with TJ since he went up there. Has good line breaking speed but I would steer clear.

[e25 5]

No.

[pitchfork 181]

I would say no but....If Vossy wants him gone, he probably has some value!

In all seriousness, It would be worth considering...112 games, 85 goals, 23 years of age

no real injuries, solid body.

I wouldn't give much up for him, but if he's out the door than why not.

Anyone have much of a scouting report on him?

To me, we have solid bodies and athletic bodies, but not enough solid and athletic guys. Can Sherman run?

[Deeoldfart 7,800]

A line breaker, and I like him for that reason ..... but his price tag is likely to be more than I would be comfortable with.

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

Got run down by PJ a couple of years back.

Hasn't really been able to kick on...is still very young though

[e25 5]

A line-breaker that gets run down by PJ..?

And where would we play him?

I think he believes he is worth a lot more than he actually is.

Would be a good fit with Essendon maybe.

[Deeoldfart 7,800]

A line-breaker that gets run down by PJ..?

And where would we play him?

I think he believes he is worth a lot more than he actually is.

Would be a good fit with Essendon maybe.

Didn't realise that he was the one that PJ caught. I just changed my view of him!

[green_machine 36]

I believe he was coming off a broken leg (or something like that) at the point in time. For 12 months post that sort of injury players tend to be down on their abilities and he was in that category at the time.

Sherman is not a star, stars tend to perform even when injured, but is still good. His season before the leg and last year were impressive. Reminds me a little of pettard. Does not seem that great but gee he can make a difference, he just does good things.

[Grandson of a gun 276]

No.

And No.

[Daz's Dee's 113]

Na there is a reason he is out of favour with Brisbane and thats the reason we don't want him!

[Guest watts04]

I'd trade Jones for Sherman.

Sherman can go forward and back and has good pace

Either way Jones n Warnock are vulnerable as both excess to our needs

[jabberwocky 2,301]

If you believe Alistair Lynch he is a confidence player that performs well when things are going well for him, into that I read front-runner.

Has talent but would given our track record I would be amazed if we gave him a second thought.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

If you believe Alistair Lynch he is a confidence player that performs well when things are going well for him, into that I read front-runner.

Has talent but would given our track record I would be amazed if we gave him a second thought.

Agreed.

Has speed but is liable to poor decision making under pressure.

No thanks.

[Bristling T 11]

yuck, i'm saying no on his sideburns alone

[Adzman 2,085]

I do not watch enough Brissie games to give an accurate assessment of Sherman, but from what I have seen he has failed to impress.

Do we really need to tinker to the point where we are taking on players that may not be a part of our best 22?