Kreuzer ACL

[Guest Cougar Magic]

[Deleted]

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

People in glass houses.......

[BAMF 4,299]

I think people who celebrate or cheer injuries should be get a temporary ban from this board.

Hope he gets better soon. Will make Carlton's finals hopes a bit harder though.

[BAMF 4,299]

Turn it up!!

Yeah your right, I can't believe how good I feel now that another young player has got an injury! yipee! Hope there are more to come! It's great for the game!

I also loved it when Jurrah dislocated his shoulder and the Adelaide radio commentators pretty much cheered! what a laugh!

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

The OP has been warned for his comments on Kruezer's injury.

Its hard luck for any player to that and the whole game is lesser for it.

This injury will dent Carlton finals hopes.

However,on 3aw today pre match Walls, Shaw, Caro and Richo were giving Carlton the biggest bake ever for trading pick 11 (Gysberts) for McLean who they also rated as an ordinary footballer that looked good in a bottom side but not in a side hoping for finals. They were also critical of the Warnock decision and said that regardless of Kruzers injury they have to play him given they have spent so much on him.

Walls was venomious about how Carlton had given up Gysberts or pick 11 for McLean and questioned the wisdom of Swan, Ratten and others at Carlton.

Most felt that Carlton were struggling to achieve their 2010 goals set back in 2008. The injury to Kruezer only makes it worse and highlights the other list shortcomings.

[Guest watts04]

Interesting on McLean, for the Blues to justify this they need to win a flag in the next 3 years as after this Brock may be cooked.

After this 3 yer period Gys will make him look silly.

Trav and Mcclean helped build our dynasty as much as McMahon

Agree on deletin the post, injuries are a curse and kruzer is a ripper

[Freak 100]

Interesting on McLean, for the Blues to justify this they need to win a flag in the next 3 years as after this Brock may be cooked.

After this 3 yer period Gys will make him look silly.

Trav and Mcclean helped build our dynasty as much as McMahon

Agree on deletin the post, injuries are a curse and kruzer is a ripper

I'm one of very few that would have actually preferred to keep mclean. i still would. Mclean is currently playing through a bit of an injury. We know he isn't at his best, but at the end of the day, his disposals and leadership will always be better than Gysberts.

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

I'm one of very few that would have actually preferred to keep mclean. i still would. Mclean is currently playing through a bit of an injury. We know he isn't at his best, but at the end of the day, his disposals and leadership will always be better than Gysberts.

I like your dedication to the cause Freak, but surely by now you must realize that you are on sinking ship?

McLean was drafted to our club in 2003, to help us in a Grand Final that was played in 2000. The game has moved on, Mclean hasn't, but perhaps you should.

[BAMF 4,299]

I'm one of very few that would have actually preferred to keep mclean. i still would. Mclean is currently playing through a bit of an injury. We know he isn't at his best, but at the end of the day, his disposals and leadership will always be better than Gysberts.

More like, Has been playing though a bit of an injury for the past 3 years.

[Guest Cougar Magic]

You guys must love carlton. Lets sing the song

[Gorgoroth 12,924]

Hate Carlton. Hate them more than any other club. Wish they would never win a game ever again.

Still do not wish to see a person do a ACL.

Massive difference.

[Sir Why You Little 36,979]

I'm one of very few that would have actually preferred to keep mclean. i still would. Mclean is currently playing through a bit of an injury. We know he isn't at his best, but at the end of the day, his disposals and leadership will always be better than Gysberts.

I hope you are not serious there Freak......Gysberts is a young gun in waiting.

Carlton supporters are fuming, which i love-The Cheats are done for this year. Kruezer was a massive part of their tilt.

I hate those Bastards but i never wish a serious injury to any player.

But i am happy Carlton will have a wasted year.

[ox_5 163]

I'm one of very few that would have actually preferred to keep mclean. i still would. Mclean is currently playing through a bit of an injury. We know he isn't at his best, but at the end of the day, his disposals and leadership will always be better than Gysberts.

Pretty big call at this stage Freak, especially about the leadership comment.

Unless you know something about Gys that we all dont, he may very well develop into a very good leader. I would prefer a straight laced, introverted leader over a burn out producing, bar fight causing clown style leader. Leadership is not just about on field and on the track. Lead by example.

McLean is long long past his best, due to his body letting him down. He has not been at his best for many years, and I doubt we will see him at his highest level again. No pace, very poor kicking. Being cut from a Carlton outfit short of inside midfielders would suggest we made a pretty good deal.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Pretty big call at this stage Freak, especially about the leadership comment.

Unless you know something about Gys that we all dont, he may very well develop into a very good leader. I would prefer a straight laced, introverted leader over a burn out producing, bar fight causing clown style leader. Leadership is not just about on field and on the track. Lead by example.

McLean is long long past his best, due to his body letting him down. He has not been at his best for many years, and I doubt we will see him at his highest level again. No pace, very poor kicking. Being cut from a Carlton outfit short of inside midfielders would suggest we made a pretty good deal.

Spot on ox, I reckon from what we've seen Gys will be a 10 year player with us and I doubt McLean will be offered another contract at Carlton. He's just not quick enough in mind or body anymore, if in fact he ever was.

It was unfortunate but I reckon he probably extended his AFL career by a couple of years crossing to Carlton. Who would you drop for him out of our current squad of midfielders?

Edited June 20, 2010 by RobbieF

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I'm one of very few that would have actually preferred to keep mclean. i still would. Mclean is currently playing through a bit of an injury. We know he isn't at his best, but at the end of the day, his disposals and leadership will always be better than Gysberts.

Says it all doesn't it!

If ever there was an endorsement of Club's decision......

[ox_5 163]

It was unfortunate but I reckon he probably extended his AFL career by a couple of years crossing to Carlton. Who would you drop for him out of our current squad of midfielders?

None. Pretty simple really, hey Robbie. Great move, up there with the TJ trade. To get pick 11 was a compete steal.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,024]

I am very sad to see Kreuzer go down. As much as I despise Carlton, he is great to watch. He's developing into a really good player and probably all-Australian in the next few years. About what you'd expect from the player two clubs were fighting over. It would of course be even better if he walked out on them and came over to us in the PSD, but that's not going to happen.

Best of luck to him on his recovery, and may he come to his senses and ditch Carlton for a decent side while he's young enough to enjoy it.

[e25 5]

Says it all doesn't it!

If ever there was an endorsement of Club's decision......

Considering Brock was one of those rare non-192cm players, the decision may still come back to haunt us...

[jnrmac 20,055]

Maybe the Giz can learn to do burnouts (when he gets his licence......tee hee...

[mauriesy 7,261]

Given the way Carazzo tagged Davey, I love this: Blues cry foul over tag tactics.

[Grandson of a gun 276]

Considering Brock was one of those rare non-192cm players, the decision may still come back to haunt us...

You can't judge the trade on half a season. It may take two or three.

I think that at the very least, Gys has the potential to offer as much as Mclean if not go past him.

Don't get me wrong, i loved Brock when he was at MFC, he was tough, hard and uncompromising. His pace and disposals were what let him down. I told this to Carlton supporters and at the moment they are bleeding. I still think if/when Mclean gets fit he will be ok for Carlton.

Kudos to Melbourne's list management team though.

We missed out on Kruezer in that famed Kruezer cup match but since then they have done everything right. Draft picks have been pretty good and trades likewise.

The two big one's were TJ for Pick 14- Grimes.

LJ in PSD.

Also at this stage, Brock for Pick 11- Gysberts.

The original comments at the start of this thread indicate it was some form of gloating over Kruezer's ACL. If so, you are a fool.

I would not wish a knee on anyone in the AFL, MFC or otherwise. Were you cheering when the Ox went down, or the young kid Gawn had his done?

I would rather come up against a full strength Carlton and test ourselves than to cheer when they suffer injuries to young guns.

Hopefully he has a speedy recovery.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

You can't judge the trade on half a season. It may take two or three.

I think that at the very least, Gys has the potential to offer as much as Mclean if not go past him.

Don't get me wrong, i loved Brock when he was at MFC, he was tough, hard and uncompromising. His pace and disposals were what let him down. I told this to Carlton supporters and at the moment they are bleeding. I still think if/when Mclean gets fit he will be ok for Carlton.

Kudos to Melbourne's list management team though.

We missed out on Kruezer in that famed Kruezer cup match but since then they have done everything right. Draft picks have been pretty good and trades likewise.

The two big one's were TJ for Pick 14- Grimes.

LJ in PSD.

Also at this stage, Brock for Pick 11- Gysberts.

Brock had three injury plagued ordinary years at MFC. He finished 11th in our B&F last year. They had recast a new contract at MFC for him on a lower wage based on performance but where he stood as part of MFC's future. I am not sure there was room for Beamer, McLean and Jones in the one team. He did not like it and wanted out. As you pointed out MFC were quick to act and got pick 11 for McLean from Carlton.

Already the deal is a winner for MFC. An injury plagued middle rung midfielder in a bottom side and we got pick 11. The options were that we pay more than we wanted for player of middling importance to us or we could have let him go to the PSD.

What we do with it is the extra bonus. Gysberts to date seems a great use of the pick. And should get better. And with Scully and Trengove, the emergence of Bail and McKenzie and the improvement in Jamar and Beamer, I am struggling to see how we are missing McLean.

McLean may ulitimately pay dividends at Carlton. But he hasn't to date. And their trading of pick 11 for a ready to go midfielder is looking a bit sick. He is in their VFL side and the player most likely keeping Hadley is being pillaged in the press as being too slow.

Some good bullets you pointed out. They are the major ones. I reckon the others we dodged or bits of fortune we had are:

1. Sacking Carroll

2. CJ walking out or getting the encouragement too

3. We did not bid too high for R. Warnock

4. Avoided ooverspending on Prismall.

5. Chasing Bradshaw.

6. Ball choosing to go to the Pies.

7. Bail and McKenzie from high picks or rookie

8. We did not run on sentiment in regard to retiring senior players

[Guest Rojik of the Arctic]

He grew up barracking for Collingwood, he plays for Carlton, and yet still I can feel nothing but sympathy for any young player copping an injury like that.

For Kreuzer yes. For Carlton no. I hope all of their lowlife supporters are crying into their pillows.

[Adzman 2,154]

Kruez is a monster loss for them. They will make finals, and be booted out first week of the finals. He is huge for them.

[Grandson of a gun 276]

Brock had three injury plagued ordinary years at MFC. He finished 11th in our B&F last year. They had recast a new contract at MFC for him on a lower wage based on performance but where he stood as part of MFC's future. I am not sure there was room for Beamer, McLean and Jones in the one team. He did not like it and wanted out. As you pointed out MFC were quick to act and got pick 11 for McLean from Carlton.

Already the deal is a winner for MFC. An injury plagued middle rung midfielder in a bottom side and we got pick 11. The options were that we pay more than we wanted for player of middling importance to us or we could have let him go to the PSD.

What we do with it is the extra bonus. Gysberts to date seems a great use of the pick. And should get better. And with Scully and Trengove, the emergence of Bail and McKenzie and the improvement in Jamar and Beamer, I am struggling to see how we are missing McLean.

McLean may ulitimately pay dividends at Carlton. But he hasn't to date. And their trading of pick 11 for a ready to go midfielder is looking a bit sick. He is in their VFL side and the player most likely keeping Hadley is being pillaged in the press as being too slow.

Some good bullets you pointed out. They are the major ones. I reckon the others we dodged or bits of fortune we had are:

1. Sacking Carroll

2. CJ walking out or getting the encouragement too

3. We did not bid too high for R. Warnock

4. Avoided ooverspending on Prismall.

5. Chasing Bradshaw.

6. Ball choosing to go to the Pies.

7. Bail and McKenzie from high picks or rookie

8. We did not run on sentiment in regard to retiring senior players

Pretty much agree with you rhino. In fact spot on with all 8 points. Mclean was just one of those blokes i loved and i wish him all the best at Carlton, i don't believe in slagging him off as he did give good service to the demons (injuries aside)- but i am rapt with what the footy department were able to do, especially considering that Brock was out of contract and could have gone for nothing via PSD- i think that is what really stings Carlton, not that they paid too much, but that they paid anything at all!!!!!

Point 7 of yours is also good. Mckenzie has shown his worth and i believe that Bail will be a good player once he gets over his injuries. There is something about him.....