Match day thread

[dreamin' man 0]

Thanks Western. I'm following on the AFL website. Driving me crazy!!

[Western Demon 0]

CARLTON 12-8 (Judd)

MELB 8-6

Commentators call it 'the sealer'.

[Western Demon 0]

If not...Houlihan's goal...seals it.

CARLTON 13-8

MELB 8-6

[Western Demon 0]

CARLTON 13-10

MELB 8-6

[Western Demon 0]

CARLTON 15-10 (Betts x 2)

MELB 8-6

46 points diff. Melbourne has not scored this quarter.

5 minutes remaining.

[Western Demon 0]

CARLTON 15-11

MELB 9-6 (Maloney)

[dreamin' man 0]

Pretty disgraceful all round.

[timmy 29]

Channel Ten is so Sh*&^t!! No mention at all of Jones' injury!

[Western Demon 0]

FINAL:

CARLTON 15-11

MELB 9-6

In effect, a percentage booster for Blues. As disappointing as the losses against West Coast and North Melbourne.

Scum, bye, Crows (AAMI) and St Kilda to come...we won't win any of those.

[Jaded No More 59,878]

Absolutely pathetic display with no excuse whatsoever.

If ever you were going to come out and play well, do it against our scumbag rivals in front of a big crowd. They played the men like the dirty [censored] that they are, and we let them.

On a bright note, if Grimes is not our best player he's in the top 3. Absolute gun.

[Spaghetti 264]

Not a great effort by any means. But in all honesty we shouldn't be beating the blues. If the tables were reversed, we would expect to put them away comfortably, which is what they did.

People need to lower their expectations. Sure we had a good start to the year with a couple of narrow defeats, but we should not be disgusted by a 50pt loss to a team with a good chance at a top 4 finish.

[Western Demon 0]

Not a great effort by any means. But in all honesty we shouldn't be beating the blues. If the tables were reversed, we would expect to put them away comfortably, which is what they did.

People need to lower their expectations. Sure we had a good start to the year with a couple of narrow defeats, but we should not be disgusted by a 50pt loss to a team with a good chance at a top 4 finish.

Carlton will be in the final 8, but I doubt top 4. But you're right - all supporters, regardless of team, tend to see the "best" games as our benchmark, and that's unfair. The smooth, confident, accuracy vs Brisbane (say) may not be seen again this year.

In a sense, finishing the year with 6 to 8 wins will already be an over-achievement. Next year, however, we should be salivating for a top 8, and in 2012...well...who knows ?

[Akum 2,660]

Not a great effort by any means. But in all honesty we shouldn't be beating the blues. If the tables were reversed, we would expect to put them away comfortably, which is what they did.

People need to lower their expectations. Sure we had a good start to the year with a couple of narrow defeats, but we should not be disgusted by a 50pt loss to a team with a good chance at a top 4 finish.

But the thing is, take out the first half of the first quarter and the last half of the last quarter, we had their measure. And Frawley would have been invaluable today. Most Demonlanders would reckon that Carltank is a team we could take ... in 2010.

Edited June 5, 2010 by Akum

[Chook 14,647]

But the thing is, take out the first half of the first quarter and the last half of the last quarter, we had their measure. And Frawley would have been invaluable today. Most Demonlanders would reckon that Carltank is a team we could take.

And Carlton supporters could say take out the second half of the first quarter and the firs half of the last quarter and we would have absolutely smashed Melbourne. You've got to take the good with the bad, and today, our bad far outweighed our good.

[1858 265]

A lot of things that went wrong for us today we can work on but there are a couple of things that we do that no amount of development will fix. Playing on at all costs simply is killing us and there are still too many senior players who play how they want to instead of how they have to.

The ease at which Carlton brought the ball out of defence in the first half was mindboggling. Our lack of consistent forward setup and system is hanging our mids out to dry although having said that today they struggled on their own turf at the bounces.

In any case, a loss to Carlton was not unexpected. Gysberts was great again and we are getting important games into our youngsters but that is about it atm. Looking forward to seeing more players debut later in the year.

[Brettmcg 24]

Am I the only one who thought a number of players simply looked as if they were not concentrating? I can vividly remember an incident in the 1st quarter where we after a Carlton goal Miller had not been quick enough back to the center. The midfielders had no idea what to do and Sylvia ended up contesting, but Miller continued to move into the square (lucky no free kick was paid!). Sitting right in front of the coaches' box you could hear Bailey screaming for them to get out and get set up! Scott West and Mark Williams just looked on in dismay as their structures came crumbling down.

I was on the verge of being absolutely embarrassed by that performance today - not anywhere near membership cutting-up lunacy, but all my hopes and expectations have been well and truly dashed after today.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,000]

On the bright side.

Gysberts!

How good was he today! He even has a hitout to his name.

[Tricky 340]

Not a great effort by any means. But in all honesty we shouldn't be beating the blues. If the tables were reversed, we would expect to put them away comfortably, which is what they did.

People need to lower their expectations. Sure we had a good start to the year with a couple of narrow defeats, but we should not be disgusted by a 50pt loss to a team with a good chance at a top 4 finish.

Agree wholeheartedly.

Pluses: Grimes & Gysberts. Green great & Morton starting to show some form.

Oh and Syliva was awesome in the ruck.... again.

[heartbeatstrue 57]

Something wrong when a second-gamer is our best player, and a number of experienced players who should be playing for their lives and careers put in very lacklustre performances.

I was filthy on Bate a) dropping that easy mark in the 1st, which resulted in a Carlton goal; then B) missing that goal in the 2nd after a 50m put him less than 10m out.

The latter after Waite got reported. The obnoxious Carlton trio behind were loudly proclaiming Waite's innocence and bagging Melb supporters as soft for complaining, and at least a goal by Bate would have given me some ammunition back. Alas, he missed and all I could do was hang the head even further.

[DemonDave 1,078]

Am I the only one who thought a number of players simply looked as if they were not concentrating? I can vividly remember an incident in the 1st quarter where we after a Carlton goal Miller had not been quick enough back to the center. The midfielders had no idea what to do and Sylvia ended up contesting, but Miller continued to move into the square (lucky no free kick was paid!). Sitting right in front of the coaches' box you could hear Bailey screaming for them to get out and get set up! Scott West and Mark Williams just looked on in dismay as their structures came crumbling down.

Ugh, this episode directly cost us a goal. Miller was more worried about jostling with some of the Carlton defenders, oblivious to the fact Jamar was standing ten metres behind him having a rest at FF in what was clearly a scheduled move. By the time he realised and tried to charge into the square it was too late and luckily he pulled up before the line. But the damage was done, Sylvia vainly tried to win the tap only to see Kreuzer scoop the ball off the ground and dish to a midfielder who hit a carlscum forward lace out for a goal. Damage well and truly done. Pathetic lack of concentration for a veteran player.

[armstrong35 262]

melbourne fans where i was sitting were really p#@$@ed off today, they even had a punch on with a carlton fan who was saying bates was a girl and to get back up blah blah blah

then one of the carlton players fell and was "hurt" didnt hear him then

i hate carlton and some of their fans!!!