Until Scully improves his kicking give me Trengove any day.

If he's still kicking like he is in a few years time we will be regretting his selection, no matter how good he is going.

and the winner of the "Mr negative award goes to . . . . "

my god man go to bed . . . or have a [censored] . . . . do something please to release some stress because you could get a tumour with an attitude like that

Ask me in 10 years.

Nah! Nah! Nah!

Too Soon!!

Until Scully improves his kicking give me Trengove any day.

If he's still kicking like he is in a few years time we will be regretting his selection, no matter how good he is going.

That statement has to either be a joke or from a very bitter & Twisted Richmond supporter.

I know, it's like choosing between Natalie Portman and Jessica Alba, but go on

I vote for Portman. Where is that option in the poll?

Purely on supercoach form, Trengove.

God I hate the term Sculgove

My brother is keen on Trenscull. Has a certain He-man ring to it.

Tomjack Scullgove will be the best AFL player evah!!!! Too bad we had to give up two picks and tank for two years straight in order to get him.

I know, it's like choosing between Natalie Portman and Jessica Alba, but go on

Jessica Alba for me!

I vote for Portman. Where is that option in the poll?

I was going to make some wisecrack along the lines of "I'd still choose...." then came back to the same predicament - I can't decide between the two.

Don't really want to anyway.

I was going to make some wisecrack along the lines of "I'd still choose...." then came back to the same predicament - I can't decide between the two.

Don't really want to anyway.

Well naturally the club has gone down the best path and chosen both. Really, can anyone deny that Portman and Alba at the same time would be a great thing?

I was going to make some wisecrack along the lines of "I'd still choose...." then came back to the same predicament - I can't decide between the two.

Don't really want to anyway.

I'd say both, but I've already been there.

The pretty ones just lay there.

:D

That statement has to either be a joke or from a very bitter & Twisted Richmond supporter.

No joke at all.

Scully has to improve his kicking, it's not a minor weakness, its a flaw.

If he doesn't improve his kicking then in 5 years time we will all be saying why didn't we take Dustin Martin.

It will be like StKilda supporters formerly fustrated over Luke Ball (well at least Scully can kick 50 I suppose).

I know its harsh, but I don't mind speaking the truth about our younger players. I wish them all the very best but I'm not overly emotionally attached to them, they aren't my babies like some people seem to think of them. And it is the reason I rate Trengove more.

jessica alba all the way for me. Seriously hot..... She is number 1 on my list of allowable alternatives to my wife :-) (thank you Ross from 'friends' forr coming up with the list concept!)

oh and JT goes ok too. Will win many a game off his own boot as he did in last years SANFL prelim last year. Serious man crush there

maybe Jessica could be convinced for a menage a trois...........

Scully's handballing reminds me of Grep Williams, incredibly creative. Trenner's all round high level of skill closer to Buckley.

I hope Trengove becomes more like Voss, Than Buckley!

Tomjack Scullgove will be the best AFL player evah!!!! Too bad we had to give up two picks and tank for two years straight in order to get him.

We didn't tank for 2 years straight.

We didn't tank for 2 years straight.

There's no-one called Tomjack Scullgove either.

There's no-one called Tomjack Scullgove either.

That above picture is just so inspiring to this club. Godamm we have come along way since 2008.

No joke at all.

Scully has to improve his kicking, it's not a minor weakness, its a flaw.

No. It's a minor weakness. His kicking can at times be really, really good. It will never be Sylvia-like... but why does it need to be when you have that engine, those hands, and that ball-winning ability?

Put it this way. Hodge is by far the better kick between he and Judd. But you'd lose nothing by playing one for the other, in terms of quality.

I've seen nothing to make me believe Scully will be marked down because he's only a "good" kick and not an "elite" kick. When he's bigger, fitter, older and has more time he'll look a lot better. Just like every kid we've played over our bottoming out period who looked devoid of skills, then suddenly, magically discovered those skills in 2010.

Actually... it's startling how similar Scully and Judds' delivery is.

One of my highlights from Saturday night was when Scully disposed of the ball near the centre of the ground, and was hit late, I'm not sure by who but he looked to be at least a KPP size, Scully recieved a free and advantage was called as the ball was moving quickly into the forward line

What the TV missed was Trengove come flying in a bump the player then grab him and let him know that if he wanted to go on with it he was happy to sort him out. Again I'm not sure who it was, but he would have been at least 10cm taller and about 15 kilos heavier, but Jack was straight on the front foot.

Jack looks a leader. Every time he came off the field he was absolutely spent. Probably worked the hardest on the ground. I've heard the Buckley/Hird comparisons, but after seeing him on Saturday night I'd say I was looking at a young Todd Viney.

Scully worked hard, but needs to do some serious work on his disposal. Cost a couple of goals.

serious work? you've got to be kidding.

I picked jack, only because tom's got big ears. The best part of the whole thing is we havent even seen tapscott yet. He's the one I'm really excited about. The teams that overlooked luke will be kicking themselves. God i love having so much talent at Melbourne. So much ball winning talent and run. Exciting times ahead at MFC.

serious work? you've got to be kidding.

I picked jack, only because tom's got big ears. The best part of the whole thing is we havent even seen tapscott yet. He's the one I'm really excited about. The teams that overlooked luke will be kicking themselves. God i love having so much talent at Melbourne. So much ball winning talent and run. Exciting times ahead at MFC.

I've got a mate who works with the Crows and watches A LOT of junior footy and he reckoned Tapscott was a steal at 18. He thought he would be a lock for top 10.

I've got a mate who works with the Crows and watches A LOT of junior footy and he reckoned Tapscott was a steal at 18. He thought he would be a lock for top 10.

So we still have 2 more untried GUNS in Tapscott & Gysberts yet to make the senior side???

How awesome the next few months just might be, not to mention the next 20 years. B)

I hope Trengove becomes more like Voss, Than Buckley!

I hope Scully becomes more like Judd & J.T like Voss also.Furthermore, I hope J.V (Jack Viney turns out like Todd Viney.)

Edited May 25, 201015 yr by jayceebee31

So we still have 2 more untried GUNS in Tapscott & Gysberts yet to make the senior side???

How awesome the next few months just might be, not to mention the next 20 years. B)

You might not remember but before the draft I asked a question about a Sth Aussie kid we had spoken to a day or so earlier but I never got an answer. The reason was that my mate was saying that there was a kid that he rated highly and that could be one of the best, but as he worked with the Crows he couldn't tell me his name except to say we had just had talks with him (the kid). Anyway, after the draft I pressed him on it and he replied: "You got him at #18 and you've got an absolute bargain". I think he is pretty dirty he is not on the Crows list.