Judd-stice

[Grand New Flag 3,227]

The decision by Judd to go to Carlton was made well before the mock interview process was ever concocted.

And at that time, it was not just the facilities that put MFC on the nose to the outside observer.

Hi Rhino, I am good friends with Juddy & Bec. What you have said here is not true.

Juddy's first choice was to come to Melbourne, in fact he came out of the interview with Stynes, Lyon etc and told me that the he was going to Melbourne. Unfortunately reality set it. Not only was the MFC a utter mess off the field, Melbourne also had an old list and was just starting its rebuild. Carlton had already been rebuilding for years. Juddy told me that he plays football to win premierships but unfortunately the MFC was at least 2 years behind Carlton in its rebuild. Even if everything went right, Melbourne’s premiership window would not open until he was in his 30s, where as Carlton premiership window would open while he was still at the peak of his career.

Guess what Juddy was right! More importantly we are far better off having not got him. Due to the draft concessions we have received we have an opportunity to become a genuinely dominate team rather than just a finals "also ran" which would likely be the case had Juddy come to the Dees.

Quite frankly I find some comments on this site from people who have never meet him disgusting. Show more class and stop questioning his integrity because this is one thing that can never be questioned. He is a professional player trying to make the most of his career. If the timing was different, if our current administration were running the show well things may have been different, but as its turned out we are better off without him.

Now get over it!

[Sir Why You Little 37,342]

Hi Rino, I am good friends with CJ & Bec. What you have said here is not true.

CJ first choice was to come to Melbourne, in fact he came out of the interview with Stynes, Lyon etc and told me that the he was going to Melbourne. Unfortunately reality set it. Not only was the MFC a utter mess off the field, Melbourne also had an old list and was just starting its rebuild. Carlton had already been rebuilding for years. Juddy told me that he plays football to win premierships but unfortunately the MFC was at least 2 years behind Carlton in its rebuild. Even if everything went right, Melbourne’s premiership window would not open until he was in his 30s, where as Carlton premiership window would open while he was still at the peak of his career.

Guess what Juddy was right! More importantly we are far better off having not got him. Due to the draft concessions we have received we have an opportunity to become a genuinely dominate team rather than just a finals "also ran" which would likely be the case had Juddy come to the Dees.

Quite frankly I find some comments on this site from people who have never meet him disgusting. Show more class and stop questioning his integrity because this is one thing that can never be questioned. He is a professional player trying to make the most of his career. If the timing was different, if our current administration were running the show well things may have been different, but as its turned out we are better off without him.

Now get over it!

Well said, but i still say Juddy's timing is out by one year. He was not to see the Fevola Fiasco coming. For Judd Carlton's window is open now, will the Blues win the Cup this year?? They looked really good yesterday-but so did Melbourne on Saturday night.

I would have loved to see Judd in a demons Jumper, but i am more excited about Scully, Trengove,Jurrah, Mckenzie, Watts, Chip, Warnock.

We are a young side but so are other clubs this year-with luck 2010 could go our way.

If Judd had come to Melbourne we would not have all the Talent we have now.

I still hope Chris plays at melbourne at the end of his career-he was a fanatic supporter (imagine if he retired an MFC Premiership player playing forward pocket/ Bench impact player in 5 years time) How the MCC would be rocking that day)

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Juddy's first choice was to come to Melbourne, in fact he came out of the interview with Stynes, Lyon etc and told me that the he was going to Melbourne. Unfortunately reality set it. Not only was the MFC a utter mess off the field, Melbourne also had an old list and was just starting its rebuild. Carlton had already been rebuilding for years. Juddy told me that he plays football to win premierships but unfortunately the MFC was at least 2 years behind Carlton in its rebuild. Even if everything went right, Melbourne’s premiership window would not open until he was in his 30s, where as Carlton premiership window would open while he was still at the peak of his career.

Thanks for the information. My understanding was that the reality set in very early in the process. The meeting with Stynes might have been genuine but as the process went on the inference from his reactions and that of his manager was that his interest was elsehwere.

I agree we are better off without him given timing and the cost of getting him.

Quite frankly I find some comments on this site from people who have never meet him disgusting. Show more class and stop questioning his integrity because this is one thing that can never be questioned. He is a professional player trying to make the most of his career. If the timing was different, if our current administration were running the show well things may have been different, but as its turned out we are better off without him.

I trust this is a general spray because in no way did I question his integrity. He has every right to eek out every cent he can from the game.He saw better opportunities with Carlton. Fine.

[Dinosaur Rover 197]

Well said, but i still say Juddy's timing is out by one year. He was not to see the Fevola Fiasco coming. For Judd Carlton's window is open now, will the Blues win the Cup this year?? They looked really good yesterday-but so did Melbourne on Saturday night.

I would have loved to see Judd in a demons Jumper, but i am more excited about Scully, Trengove,Jurrah, Mckenzie, Watts, Chip, Warnock.

We are a young side but so are other clubs this year-with luck 2010 could go our way.

If Judd had come to Melbourne we would not have all the Talent we have now.

I still hope Chris plays at melbourne at the end of his career-he was a fanatic supporter (imagine if he retired an MFC Premiership player playing forward pocket/ Bench impact player in 5 years time) How the MCC would be rocking that day)

One one dimension Carlton are maybe two years ahead of us in the development of their star picks. They have 3 no 1 draft picks plus Judd and all have had much more game experience than our more recent arrivals. They have a couple of handy defenders a limited but zippy forward line and a lot of self belief. On the other hand I dont see the quality in their more mature players +50 games to compare with Maloney, Jones, Sylvia, Davey and more.

I thought what was really interesting yesterday was how Carlton matched Geelong for tackling pressure and had the legs and speed to outrun them. I find it very interesting to see that St Kilda and Geelong are not the invulnerable, collossi that we imagined them. If there are enough strong bodies and talented smaller players then they can be beaten. I am rethinking the magic 50 games mark for some of our players - for Trengove and McKenzie for example that mark may be way too conservative.

I wouldnt show that we care what decisions Judd made. I respect him as a great player and I will be happy if we keep him sub 30 possessions when we play.

[Grand New Flag 3,227]

Thanks for the information. My understanding was that the reality set in very early in the process. The meeting with Stynes might have been genuine but as the process went on the inference from his reactions and that of his manager was that his interest was elsehwere.

I agree we are better off without him given timing and the cost of getting him.

I trust this is a general spray because in no way did I question his integrity. He has every right to eek out every cent he can from the game.He saw better opportunities with Carlton. Fine.

It was a general spay Rhino and certainly not directed at you. I always enjoy your comments as a knowledgeable high quality poster.

[Eth 4]

We have a Judd in our team though, he goes by the name of Tom Scully.

[Jaded No More 68,976]

Juddy's first choice was to come to Melbourne, in fact he came out of the interview with Stynes, Lyon etc and told me that the he was going to Melbourne. Unfortunately reality set it. Not only was the MFC a utter mess off the field, Melbourne also had an old list and was just starting its rebuild. Carlton had already been rebuilding for years. Juddy told me that he plays football to win premierships but unfortunately the MFC was at least 2 years behind Carlton in its rebuild. Even if everything went right, Melbourne’s premiership window would not open until he was in his 30s, where as Carlton premiership window would open while he was still at the peak of his career.

We are better off without him, and because he didn't come to us we are now probably on par with Carlton given they have lost Fev and that their backline is nowhere near as good as ours (and we have arguably gained players who are as good if not better than Gibbs, Murphy and Kruezer).

I don't doubt that you know him, or that your story is true, but if Judd wanted a flag above all else, he would have gone to Collingwood because they were the most advanced in the premiership race and probably still are. The addition of Judd would have almost certainly helped them win a flag, whereas I think the loss of Kennedy has seriously damaged Carlton's chances, especially in light of Fev's departure.

Either way, the universe was working for us with the Judd situation. We lost nothing and won plenty, so he can enjoy playing for scum of the earth and I'll enjoy our rapid development.

[Grand New Flag 3,227]

We are better off without him, and because he didn't come to us we are now probably on par with Carlton given they have lost Fev and that their backline is nowhere near as good as ours (and we have arguably gained players who are as good if not better than Gibbs, Murphy and Kruezer).

I don't doubt that you know him, or that your story is true, but if Judd wanted a flag above all else, he would have gone to Collingwood because they were the most advanced in the premiership race and probably still are. The addition of Judd would have almost certainly helped them win a flag, whereas I think the loss of Kennedy has seriously damaged Carlton's chances, especially in light of Fev's departure.

Either way, the universe was working for us with the Judd situation. We lost nothing and won plenty, so he can enjoy playing for scum of the earth and I'll enjoy our rapid development.

Very true Jaded, Collingwood would have been the place to go for a flag. However, there were other influences. Firstly Collingwood was unable or unwilling to satisfy West Coasts demands of 2 very young top ten draft picks. Secondly, West Coast simply refused to negotiate with the woods. Finally Richard Pratt connected with Juddy in a way that Eddy could not. In fact the late Pratt turned into a close mentor of Juddy.