Demonland Draft: Closest to pin

[Old Man Rivers 326]

[Hobbits's 17]

Trengove Scully Vardy Bastinac Taylor Thorp psd - McDonald

[Bruce Almighty 0]

Scully

Trengove

Bastinac or Tapscott

Vardy

Thorp

Gawn

PSD = McDonald

[markc 975]

thought I have ago at this ,

1or 2 Scully , Trengove

11 ...

18. Ball LOCK IT in ( if he hasnt already been picked )

PSD : Joel MacDonald - deal has been done and will be a Dee .

Edited November 19, 2009 by markc

[Viney Vidi Vici 145]

Scully

Trengove

Bastinac or Tapscott

Vardy

Thorp

Gawn

PSD = McDonald

I could see that happening. Though maybe not Gawn... but still, worser things have happened.

[Dee tention 616]

1 & 2. Scully & Trengove

11. Black

18. Carlisle or Bastinac

34. Patrick

50. Grimes, Daw or best available in that order

The Demons could have traded for another top 20 pick off loading a 2 players to achieve this. That would get us a top 20 pick and the opportunity to use Pick 66 or another pick in the PSD. Bastinac will be a great player! Drafting him aswell as not missing out on 2 KP in the top 20 would have been super.

[Adam286 0]

I'll have a crack too!

1. Tom Scully

2. Jack Trengove

11. Aaron Black

18. Jordan Gysberts

34. Max Gawn

50. Mitch Thorpe

PSD1. Joel Macdonald

Not too much different to most of you guys I know, but I would be most pleased if something like this transpired.

[Range Rover 1,935]

Hi All ... this is my first post on the boards. I thought I'd give nearest the pin a crack ...

1. Scully

2. Trengove

11. Talia

18. Melksham

34. Gawn

50. Thorp

Picks 1 and 2 are sorted so it's really 11 and 18 that will be most interesting. I went the U/18 carnival to watch a lot of these kids and Talia was a real standout from where I sat. Classy tall with great decision making and poise. Can play both CHB and CHF and will develop into a quality AFL player. I hope we don't pick Ball when it comes to the crunch at 18. He doesn't want to play for us and I believe there should still be an excellent prospect available who will become a long term gun player for the Dees. I like Jake Melksham if he's available - the guy is a Dal Santo clone with equally sublime skills. At 34 I think we should take a punt on a young ruckman and of those available I like the look of Gawn. Could become the next Sandliands tapping the ball down to Scully, Moloney and co. Lastly at pick 50, I reckon we give Mitch Thorp a second life at AFL as I think he's a genuine talent and would work well in a Watts-Thorpe-Jurrah forward line if he can get himself fully fit. He's only 23 and by all reports is training with hunger at passion down at the junction.

That's it then from me. Only 4 days to go!!

[Salems Lot 2,493]

1 Trengove

2 Scully

11 Black

18 Ball

34 Gawn

50 Thorpe

Nothing outrageous here, just the way it will be!

[Rosso 59]

1 Scully

2 Trengove

11 Ball

18 Moore

34 Patrick

50 Thorpe

PSD Joel MacDonald

[waynewussell 5,336]

1 Scully

2 Trengove

11 Black

18 Tahlia/Griffiths

34 Ball/Patrick

50 Temel

[jayceebee31 759]

Sorry for lateness due to suspension, I think will be picked and not my picks however-I have been suspended to now

1-Scully

2- Trengove

11-Talia

18- Gawn

34- Griffiths

50- Thorp or Patrick

66- pass/PSD1- Joel McDonald.

Edited November 26, 2009 by jayceebee31

[hillie 41]

1 Trengove

2 Scully

11 Black

18 Ball

34 Gawn

50 Thorpe

Nothing outrageous here, just the way it will be!

although i dont want ball i guess i could live with trengove scully black ball gawn/patrick patrick/temel

[MikeyJ 60]

1. Tom Scully

2. Jack Trengove

11. Aaron Black

18. Andrew Moore

34. James Craig

50. Dylan Grimes

PSD1. Joel Macdonald

[Melb2012 0]

changing mine a tad

1.Scully

2.Trengove

11.Tapscott

18. Gawn/Fitzpatrick

34. Taylor

50.Casboult

PSD Mcdonald

[Paul Gardner 6]

P1 - Scully

P2 - Trengove

P3 - Talia

P4 - J Craig

P5 - D Grimes

P6 - M Daw

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I've changed mine too because it appears that we will not take Thorp in the PSD and I'm not sure about Patrick any more.

1 Sculley

2 Trengove

11 Tapscott/Jetta/Lucas

18 Panos

34 Grimes

50 Temel/Daw

PSD McDonald

I just have a feeling we won't take Ball, may be wrong but I reckon it's to flush out another club.

[Dr. Mubutu 831]

May as well add my 2c:

1. Scully

2. Trengove

11. Tapscott

18. Vardy

34. Grimes

50. Patrick

PSD 1. MacDonald

[Daz's Dee's 113]

1. T Scully

2. J Trengove

11. J Butcher

18. K Stevens

34. L Patrick

50. M Daw

PSD. J Macdonald

Re Rookie J Meeson and add another Ruck Rookie

[Akum 2,660]

=1. T Scully

=1. J Trengove (Ican't see how on earth they can be separated, orwhy they have to be - $7500 bonus each)

11. N. Jetta (or any 'second-tier' mid who slips)

18. J. Carlisle (assuming Talia & Black are gone)

34. L Patrick

50. M Thorp

PSD. J Macdonald

[LITTLE STINGA 1]

1 - SCULLY

2 - TRENGOVE

11 - BLACK

18 - BALL

34 - GAWN

50 - PATRICK

[e25 5]

1. Scully

2. Trengove

11. Lucas

18. Mcmillan-Pittard

34. Griffiths

50. James Craig

[Whispering_Jack 29,777]

OK - one more try

1 Trengove

2 Scully

11 Talia

18 Vardy

34 Grimes

50 Thorp

66 Pass

PSD Joel Macdonald

[H_T 3,043]

=1. T Scully

=1. J Trengove (Ican't see how on earth they can be separated, orwhy they have to be - $7500 bonus each)

11. N. Jetta (or any 'second-tier' mid who slips)

18. J. Carlisle (assuming Talia & Black are gone)

34. L Patrick

50. M Thorp

PSD. J Macdonald

We already have Neville Jetta.

[The O 39]

1 Jack Trengove

2 Tom Scully

11 Aaron Black

18 Luke Ball

34 Mitch Thorpe

50 Brock McCauley (although wouldn't mind seeing Patrick or Grimes drafted here, although expect us to take a ruckman considering the interest in Meeson)

PSD Joel Macdonald

End result is 3 mids, 2 young KPP's and 1 running defender and 1 ruckman

Edited November 24, 2009 by The O