Tom Lonergan

[Dee tention 611]

He cant get a game for Geelong.

Could slip into our forward line nicely. I would only trade a player for him though. No picks!

Bartram who is from Torquay could be possible. Miller? Dunn?

Thoughts?

[e25 5]

You like making stupid suggestions, don't you?

Do you even watch AFL football??

Or do you just look at the footy cards and dream about what the game would be like?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Yes, We should trade for every other Club reject. They might be handy...who knows when.

BTW, doesn't Newton have a distant 3rd cousin twice removed who lives in Lorne? Definite Geelong connection there.

[Mondê 525]

Of all the trade suggestions going around this has got to be up there with the worst. Tom Lonergan...*shudder*

[Rogue 585]

Or do you just look at the footy cards and dream about what the game would be like?

Haha :D

[deanox 8,795]

Or do you just look at the footy cards and dream about what the game would be like?

haha

seriously though, why the hell would anyone suggestion a 'geelong connection'? its not exactly like trying to fly perth to see family and friends, its 60 minutes by car, and i bet a pile of the geelong players live in melbourne anyway...

[Clanger King 9]

Melbourne don't need depth players. Get over trading recruiting dead wood

Edited September 6, 2009 by Clanger King

[Pipefitter 2,042]

Melbourne don't need depth players. Get over trading recruiting dead wood

Look at all the dead wood st kilda traded for. Not all worked but they sure would be happy with quite a few of them.

[WonnaJurah 5]

Look at all the dead wood st kilda traded for. Not all worked but they sure would be happy with quite a few of them.

especially Dawson, what a feelgood story that was

[Clanger King 9]

especially Dawson, what a feelgood story that was

They are a team that is in the window for a premiership of coarse you would want ready made players instead of kids. they haven't played there kids all year.

[1964nowMORE 449]

Melbourne don't need depth players. Get over trading recruiting dead wood

Good call above. Lonergan no thanks - we've already got Dunn who could cover similar spots as depth. Watches the Saints yesterday and the depth was irrelivant - Hayes, Riewoldt, Montagna, Fisher, Gilbert and Dal Santo just killed them......the effort of Milne, Eddy, Ball, Blake, King didn't matter.

Trade for real talent only - ala Boak.

[WonnaJurah 5]

They are a team that is in the window for a premiership of coarse you would want ready made players instead of kids. they haven't played there kids all year.

true Colm Begley they got from lions has been rarely sighted as well and only used 30 players wow

Edited September 7, 2009 by WonnaJurah

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

especially Dawson, what a feelgood story that was

Dawson was not a trade but a rookie draft pick up by St Kilda.

I think there is a difference trading something for someone and picking up the player for free.

true Colm Begley they got from lions has been rarely sighted as well and only used 30 players wow

At pick 83 in LY's draft it would have taken something significant for him to get a game.

[Big Kev 340]

He cant get a game for Geelong.

Could slip into our forward line nicely. I would only trade a player for him though. No picks!

Bartram who is from Torquay could be possible. Miller? Dunn?

Thoughts?

No thank you and we don't need Jake King either.

[WonnaJurah 5]

No thank you and we don't need Jake King either.

Nick Gill anyone?

[MadAsHell 4,089]

I'll pass.

[Disco Demons 92]

i can't wait for the draft to be over...need to stop this madness!

We don’t need to chase any players…much prefer melb keep the cheque book closed and chip away at the debt. Melb need to develop the players we already have to realise what we really need to buy down the track. i realise GC are coming into play...but in a couple years we should be able to grab a 26/27 old player to fill a gap. GC are not going to want these kinds of players. And melbs debt should be under control.

'just gotta grin and bare it', DB.

[H_T 2,941]

Bartram who is from Torquay could be possible. Miller? Dunn?

Thoughts?

Dunn occassionally travels through Geelong on the way to Bells for a surf..........so I guess he'd be an option......being familiar with Geelong and all..