Pick Number 2

[Clanger King 9]

Just throwing this out there to get some percentages of what ppl think we should do. If there is a"other" let us know who.

[Jarka 767]

There are others who should be involved in the poll, namely Morabito, Lucas and even Dustin Martin as someone else has already suggested in another thread. We need to enter the draft with our eyes wide open

[beelzebub 23,196]

yep .both eyes wide open...one on Scully and the other on Trengove

[e25 5]

There are others who should be involved in the poll, namely Morabito, Lucas and even Dustin Martin as someone else has already suggested in another thread. We need to enter the draft with our eyes wide open

Cunnington and Rohan come up a lot too.

[H_T 3,032]

The likes of Morabito & Rohan should have been included in the poll despite favouritism for Trengove.

[Roost It 1,434]

I still think the club will choose Butcher and in 3 years time we'll all be stoked they did.

[Clanger King 9]

The likes of Morabito & Rohan should have been included in the poll despite favouritism for Trengove.

Aren't ppl saying that Trengove is closing the gap with number 1 not going further away from number 2?

[beelzebub 23,196]

Spose we could set tongues wagging by picking Trengove at 1...Scully at 2....... such would be the upset !! pmsl

I think these two are now well clear of the peleton !!

[H_T 3,032]

Aren't ppl saying that Trengove is closing the gap with number 1 not going further away from number 2?

Yes, some. That wasn't my point though. I'm saying the likes of Morabito & Rohan should have been included in the poll along with Butcher & Trengove. (despite the obvious favouritism for Trengove).

Quite a few have Morabito up there with Trengove and Rohan seems to have a bullet beside his name (on the up) and is a bit of a smoky to go early.

[Clanger King 9]

Yes, some. That wasn't my point though. I'm saying the likes of Morabito & Rohan should have been included in the poll along with Butcher & Trengove. (despite the obvious favouritism for Trengove).

Quite a few have Morabito up there with Trengove and Rohan seems to have a bullet beside his name (on the up) and is a bit of a smoky to go early.

Fair call. My bad. "Other" could be rather large then.

[e25 5]

Yes, some. That wasn't my point though. I'm saying the likes of Morabito & Rohan should have been included in the poll along with Butcher & Trengove. (despite the obvious favouritism for Trengove).

Quite a few have Morabito up there with Trengove and Rohan seems to have a bullet beside his name (on the up) and is a bit of a smoky to go early.

Yeah, depending on who has pick 3, both Morabito and Rohan could have more chance of going pick 3 than Butcher ( as we'll certainly take Trengove pick 2...)

[H_T 3,032]

Fair call. My bad. "Other" could be rather large then.

Fair enough, they can select 'other'.

[Guest Digga]

High Tower I think you live on here, seriously.

Fine

Pick 2 Trengove.

Take it easy no offence lol.

Edited August 27, 2009 by Digga

[drdrake 3,118]

It seems certain that Trengove is the second best midfielder, but do we know for certain that Butcher is the best tall, what are the other tall options that people think will go early. I believe we need to get the best tall forward with our second pick, if that is Butcher then we get him.

[e25 5]

It seems certain that Trengove is the second best midfielder, but do we know for certain that Butcher is the best tall, what are the other tall options that people think will go early. I believe we need to get the best tall forward with our second pick, if that is Butcher then we get him.

Lunacy.

[Tatu 416]

I still think the club will choose Butcher and in 3 years time we'll all be stoked they did.

Hope your right.

With jack viney as a father/son in 2011, MFC would have to many mid's if they take Trengove.

[Ryan Dee 140]

Hope your right.

With jack viney as a father/son in 2011, MFC would have to many mid's if they take Trengove.

You can't serously be thinking ahead that far? What if the kid choses not to play footy? Far out people are already thinking about 15 year old's who think they will play for the club.

Edited August 27, 2009 by Mr Morton

[Tatu 416]

You can't serously be thinking ahead that far? What if the kid choses not to play footy? Far out people are already thinking about 15 year old's who think they will play for the club.

2011 is only 3 years.

MFC have a 5 year plan.

[Ryan Dee 140]

2011 is only 3 years.

MFC have a 5 year plan.

yes, but not on 15 year old children who still have 2 years to get there in which anything could happen.

I'm also sure that they will not factor this child into their draft choices, which you seemed to have done with Trengove. They may have had a look at him, but not much more.

Edited August 27, 2009 by Mr Morton

[Tatu 416]

yes, but not on 15 year old children who still have 2 years to get there in which anything could happen.

I'm also sure that they will not factor this child into their draft choices, which you seemed to have done with Trengove. They may have had a look at him, but not much more.

anything could happen to Trengove, Scully or Butcher. anything can happen to anybody at any time?

I'm sure MFC can work out weather Viney wants to play AFL.

15 year old children? Tim Watson was 16 when he played his first game.

[Doggo 32]

Trengove for me, but would be happy with Morabito or Rohan also.

Not keen on Butcher, hoping Panos or Carlisle are still available at 18. Or, highly unlikely, Talia, who's probably the best of the lot, and definitely should go top 10.

[Wolfmother 182]

People have been talking themselves out of Butcher for a while on this forum and I can't understand why (if we recruit him he'll have a [censored] time at the club as everyone wants trengrove) but this guy has been talked about as the number two pick since last year he is a good player not some smokey who could go anywhere between 10-25. People need to realised that he is a top talent in the elite barrack and we are not talking potential but he has shown this at the underage level and that is why he is rated that high.

He has some issues with his game as do all players but they are not as major as people make out....

[Akum 2,660]

Trengove for me, but would be happy with Morabito or Rohan also.

Not keen on Butcher, hoping Panos or Carlisle are still available at 18. Or, highly unlikely, Talia, who's probably the best of the lot, and definitely should go top 10.

Any chance of taking Talia at #2 if we want KPP?

Edited August 27, 2009 by Akum

[Old Gregg 1]

Hope your right.

With jack viney as a father/son in 2011, MFC would have to many mid's if they take Trengove.

Too many midfielders?

1. How do you know that Viney will continue playing footy?

2. How do you know that he will want to come to Melbourne, and that his career will be decent?

3. There are other picks in the draft, not only 1 and 2. You realise that if we take Butcher, we will still get a good midfielder at pick 18. Does that mean we will have too many midfielders? And then there are picks 34 and 50. We still have picks other that 1, 2, and this potential F/S.

There are too many contradictions by some posters.

[Tatu 416]

Too many midfielders?

1. How do you know that Viney will continue playing footy?

2. How do you know that he will want to come to Melbourne, and that his career will be decent?

3. There are other picks in the draft, not only 1 and 2. You realise that if we take Butcher, we will still get a good midfielder at pick 18. Does that mean we will have too many midfielders? And then there are picks 34 and 50. We still have picks other that 1, 2, and this potential F/S.

There are too many contradictions by some posters.

1. i don't

2. i don't

How do you know MFC will use pick 18, 34 and 50 on mid's?if they take Butcher.