DROP THE CAPTAIN

[Sir Why You Little 37,046]

I think JMac's game got better as it went on. During the First Q i said the same thing to my Dad. He made 2 Clangers right in front of me & was slow to move with the game.

But he got better, & tackled really well after Half Time.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I'm sorry I got it wrong Junior had a blinder 13 disposals 1 clearence 3 tackles 2 frees against(at least one cost us a goal to Franklin, only PJ gave away more) while Mitchell got 31 disposals and 4 clearences that is an awesome game whichever way you look at it. Robbo and Miller were also brilliant.

Yeah. Because stats equate a good game. There's more to football than numbers.

What would you judge it on ? What did he actually do for you to think that he had a great game considering his job was to limit Mitchell which he failed at.

Yeah, because no-one's EVER failed to curtail Mitchell before. Besides, that wasn't his only job.

His opponent was close to BOG. He's not getting the ball he hasn't got the ball all year. If he wasn't captain there would be more than just me wanting him out of the side. Our midfield got slaughtered if it wasn't for Sylvia being a one man band we would have got smashed by over 10 goals.

He was injured for a while numbnuts. To my knowledge the only way to get the ball in the stands is when you have itchy nads.

JMac was never really a huge stat getter. In his Bluey years he was, but before then he was always a solid 20-25 possession per game player. So he got smashed. So did everyone else.

Oh, and you're placing emphasis on Sylvia now? If Sylvia became half the player JMac is NOW, he'd still end up doing about half as much in his career. One good game and suddenly you're siding with Colin over a two-time B&F winner, and great servant of the club. And you expect us to take you seriously? The same thing happened to Neita towards the end of his career.

Show some respect.

[The Emblem 1]

yesterday, his chasing and tackling were excpetional... he went to other men that were not his and did everythign you would expect from a elader. at half time he gave the team a bake, and they responded....

yes, but its not a "stat" and if you:

a) only look at the newspapers, or

B) only watch games via the Tele, or

c) go to the games but are too thick to comprehend the contribution a player is making to the pattern of the game

Then you fall back on the stats...

[DemonDan... 77]

Jesus. What is it with Melbourne supporters? We're worse than Sydney supporters sometimes. Learn how to watch a game of footy. JMac was good today, coming off a recent injury too.

thank god someone knows whats goin on...

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I just watched the replay and I didn't appreciate McDonald's efforts from being at the game, especially his work in the contested situations.

[LITTLE STINGA 1]

Yeah. Because stats equate a good game. There's more to football than numbers.

Yeah, because no-one's EVER failed to curtail Mitchell before. Besides, that wasn't his only job.

He was injured for a while numbnuts. To my knowledge the only way to get the ball in the stands is when you have itchy nads.

JMac was never really a huge stat getter. In his Bluey years he was, but before then he was always a solid 20-25 possession per game player. So he got smashed. So did everyone else.

Oh, and you're placing emphasis on Sylvia now? If Sylvia became half the player JMac is NOW, he'd still end up doing about half as much in his career. One good game and suddenly you're siding with Colin over a two-time B&F winner, and great servant of the club. And you expect us to take you seriously? The same thing happened to Neita towards the end of his career.

Show some respect.

There's no need for name calling you don't have to agree with me but there is no need for that childish crap.

I would doubt that he would have had over 20 odd touches this year. He had an ordinary year last year and he has had a poor year this year.

You wrote that he got smashed but he still had an awesome game well I've never seen that happen and your saying you can't take me seriously?

Sylvia's last 6 weeks have been a lot better than Junior's and it had to be cause Sylvia was very lucky not to be dropped for more than 1 week at the start of the year. Overall Junior has obviously been a lot better than Sylvia but not this year no way.

[rpfc 28,493]

Sylvia's last 6 weeks have been a lot better than Junior's and it had to be cause Sylvia was very lucky not to be dropped for more than 1 week at the start of the year. Overall Junior has obviously been a lot better than Sylvia but not this year no way.

They have different roles, Sylvia relies on someone getting the ball to him. Junior has to get it himself, or stop someone from getting it.

Difficult to compare the two.

Junior is coming back from a hammy and comes and goes in games but around the stoppages his value rises. We are last, but we don't often get smashed in the clearances or contested possesions, and I dare say that the captain has something to do with that.

[Geddy Lee 582]

I thought J-Mac was fantastic, better than Brock, Jones easily but YMMV

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

There's no need for name calling you don't have to agree with me but there is no need for that childish crap.

I would doubt that he would have had over 20 odd touches this year. He had an ordinary year last year and he has had a poor year this year.

You wrote that he got smashed but he still had an awesome game well I've never seen that happen and your saying you can't take me seriously?

Sylvia's last 6 weeks have been a lot better than Junior's and it had to be cause Sylvia was very lucky not to be dropped for more than 1 week at the start of the year. Overall Junior has obviously been a lot better than Sylvia but not this year no way.

Fair enough. I could have done without the sarcasm. But that's it. JMac deserves a lot more respect from you, and as soon as you acknowledge the fact he offers more to the side than just 20+ possessions, I'll acknowledge where I've gone wrong. Also, he didn't have an ordinary year last year. It was as JMac as any year. IMO I thought he had a good game despite the stats, and if you want to split hairs, my point about him being smashed was to give you a little leeway. If YOU think he was smashed, consider the fact that just about everyone out there was smashed. That better?

In Sylvia's last six weeks he actually played footy. I'll say it again, JMac has been injured. He missed a couple, and then needed a couple to get fit again. JMac ran the game out beautifully on the weekend. Is this not a plus? Besides, Sylvia's last 6 weeks were not that flash either. He was doing nothing up until a couple of weeks ago when he started finding more of the ball, and as Bailey has suggested, he was the benificiary of a lot of downfield ball. I think that's a bit harsh on Bailey's part. I mean, you still have to get it and use it no matter where you are on the ground. But perhaps there's some truth to it.

And your last sentence is topical claptrap. He's played one good game this year. That's it. What a game it was, sure, but one good game. Junior has been solid besides injury, which he's ALWAYS been. Nothing more nothing less. And comparing a finisher to a battler/tagger is stupid as well.

[H_T 3,049]

He was injured for a while numbnuts. To my knowledge the only way to get the ball in the stands is when you have itchy nads.

I'll know next time, not to take a sip of coffee whilst reading a line like this........a clean up was required......thanks Dappa!