bluey

Gary Ablett is rated 10, the doyen of midfielders, Jones would be about 3/10, the rest of our midfielders would be in the minus rating.

Todd Viney is a survivor, if anything, not sure why, last old boy standing. If I recall he has been a player, Development coach, Assistant coach, Senior coach, Recruiting Manager. I will leave it at that.

Terrible waste of resources, they should be spending time teaching the seniors how to kick, typical though.

A single common denominator with the good young AFL clubs, Port, Tigers and Dogs, they have not collected "Has Beens and Dead Beats", Yes some deft recruiting in Monfries, Maric and possibly Cramer. Chappy and Cross have been delisted by better clubs than us, so maybe we should just take the hard lesson rather than just continuing the same old mistakes every year.

We just wasted a complete drafting, on Pedersen, Dawes, Byrnes, Rodan and Gillies, set the club back another two years, if that is possible, wouldn't surprise me if they go for Chappy, Dids, Hunt, Jolly and Cross, anything is possible at the MFC.

I will give him a call.

MELBOURNE Nathan Jones 6 Jack Watts 3 Shannon Byrnes, Aaron Davey, Jack Viney 2 Dean Terlich 1 Came equal 7th in our Brownlow voting, not sure if we could afford to lose him.

I wonder what he does? who are his subordinates? who are his superiors?

He has shown no X factor, reminds me of a pick 60, making his way through the system, from day one you could see it in Travis and Robbie Flower, you have it or you don't. Not something you find in a few years, ask Cale, Tappy, Bater, Little Tommy, Trengrove.. I have researched hard, hoped, watched replays, but it just isn't there. Best of luck to the young lad, but it will take a miracle and then some.

I was shocked at Viney and Neelds decision to recruit his son, Toumpas, Byrnes, Pedersen, Rodan, and the Gillenator, and leave Wines in the can. Probably the worst decision ever, and we have made many, has left the club on the ropes. I have not seen one frame from Toumpas to make me think otherwise.

Well we can't get worse, that would be impossible, could the Saints get this bad ? that would be impossible.

Yeh, bad news, we have enough problems getting a kick.

People joined Demonology, and gave up their personal details, emails addresses, to participate in a football forum, not to have their private information to be handed over to the the [censored] family.

Suspend Trengrove, is that a penalty?

Yeh Colin, could be anything, a few years development.

Takes the odd grab but very limited in ability. Been hopeless most of the year, we have been looking for a leader, and has not put his hand up.

Yarran is a spud..

Lucky we have PJ, where would we be without him?, been a godsend.

Thanks, that explains it all, his manager, nothing to do with Jack, never speaks to his manager at all, probably never even met him , clears that up.

Typical Melbourne footballer, no loyalty, no ability, no bravery, look at me, will not sign up if I don't like the coach, we run the club, how great am I.

Yep, cheap talk, that's about it so far, said nothing nobody else has not promulgated over the years. Interim is interim, non committal, fly in and fly out, reminds me of our Gazza, lets see some action before sinking our super into ostrich oil.

The grim reaper, we need to move forward, not dwell on the past, plenty of reasons why we are duds, big deal. Seems to have plan zero, but blame the past.

Why do it, sees himself as a great savior maybe, hope he can handle himself better than Needle or Brock..

We lose like that every week, so what has Darwin got to do with it, worst post I have ever read.

I like Neale Craig , as a genuine person, and an experienced coach, would be devastated if they selected another spud as coach, some dreamer with a loser PowerPoint presentation, living in fantasy land with big ideas and a five year plan taking us nowhere.