faultydet

Very unfair to be playing against drug cheats, so I agree with him. Can't wait to see them twist off when the last appeal avenue dies up.

Am I alone in thinking McDonald has the spatial awareness of Kosi from the Saints? Played like he was wearing blinkers and ear plugs

Surely we hold the record for having the most Rising Star nominations against us? Can someone with the time and patience put a list together please? I would bet we would have 3 to 4 times the amount of any other club in the last 5 years. Its another embarrassing indictment of our shiteful mess of a club. **Just checked the last 2 seasons. Seems I went off without the facts. 4 Noms for players against us in the past 2 seasons, while in the same period, the Saints had 6, GWS had 7

Jesus Christ. You must be joking surely? We were beaten by a mob of complete nobodies. As usual, we played a kid with 1 game under his belt, into a rising star nomination, when he should have been run through at the first bounce he lined up for. The sight of a poofy looking geek like Parish mouthing off at our players, without so much as a whimper in retaliation, made me want to spew. So typically Melbourne.

We have never had a "line in the sand" moment. Too many gentlemen of high repute on our list. Too soft, too gutless.

Agree 100% Kent was invisible, as was Vandenberg. Brayshaw looked like a first gamer, and Hogan was an embarrassment. Sooked all day, and gave repeated, half assed efforts with no hands in the air, just like the Watts of old that we all whined about. I was led to believe that this was the "new Melbourne". A team of "competitors". who would give 100% effort, 100% of the game. My first bet on an AFL game in my entire life, because I fell for the hot air, thinking we had finally turned the corner, and become a real football TEAM. We are still the old Melbourne. The butt of everyones jokes, the laughing stock of the game we invented. We are toxic, and even the wonder boys cant find a cure. essedon, the drug cheats, with their imbecile, jacket waving sycophants, are getting drunk and laughing at us yet again. Its always us, the pitiful dees, who throw ourselves under a bus, to make whatever team is in crisis look respectable. .......respect, something that our list doesn't seem to care about. Thanks guys, you look like ruining yet another season.

Melbourne Demons. The most embarrassing two words in the English language. Thanks again Dees. Gutsy, and determined from the first bounce.

Lose 100 bucks to Crownbet

Your argument was going well, until you included this rant. "worst atrocities in modern history"? Wow.

We are talking about a list compiled by Robbo. I wouldn't have been surprised if he had Hurley and Heppell in his top 10, arguing that they might have a successful appeal against their ban. Haven't read it myself, and wont bother now.

You assumed incorrectly. I was not making a point. It was in fact, to be taken at face value as a simple question, and I would have thought it didn't require explaining. Sometimes you look for things that aren't there prodee. You haven't read the article. Fine. Maybe someone who has will answer the question.

He doesn't need to go to pubs. He has a goon sack hidden in the toilet systern.

So none of the banned drug cheats made the list?

Like it. Hard to judge how good it really is, as I would have still been embarrassed by the same ad over the past decade. I guess it comes down to the level of respect your team demands from others. But again, I like it.

Trust your opinion. Tell me about Watts. Haven't seen 1 minute of the game.

They are all still crouching behind the "no positive test" argument. Sharapova isn't so lucky. After all this time, I think it's clear that we will never see any of the drug cheats come clean, and admit fault. Too bad for the cheats that WADA and CAS don't give a fig what they think. EAD Jobe. Hand the medal back.

I have the same view as this. I'm sure they are tired of waiting for him to be more physical. Its now or never for Jack.

You left out Jacka. easily makes that list.

Agree with this. I'm very surprised. but he actually looks to have genuinely improved as a player. I usually cringe when he tackles, because of a tendency to throw himself into the opponents back and give away dumb frees, but he has cut most of that out of his game, and been useful in both games. I'm tipping he will play rd1, and at this stage he will deserve it.

worst game of McDonalds life. Just get him off.

McDonald has been bloody awful all game. Absolute momentum killer with every touch. Lin Jong, another to the list of duds who kill us.

I think its a chance the singer is related to these two... Im glad I never found my own sister attractive.

Ridiculous suggestion. We are ALWAYS badly outnumbered at these games, and with the imbiciles turning up in their moron droves, with an "us against the world" mentality, I will lay all I have that our supporters come out second best. I agree with the earlier suggestion that the afl should step in and can this idea, but you just know that they wont. The only chance we have to shut them up and turn the day into a fizzer, is to jump them early, and pile on the goals. I hope our mob is up to it, but from recent experience, I fear we will be walked over, both on and off the field.

5 year offer on big money for Hooker hey? Pencil in picks 2 AND 3 for the drug cheats in the next draft. Bastards. Agree that with the big offers around for KPP's, and the need to re sign Fyfe, that it seems like a difficult task for Freo to fit Hogan into the salary cap, even if he did want to move in a couple of years. Its all good news for us. I think he will stay.

I liked that Hinkley said our boys simply hit the contest harder than his did. Speaks volumes about out list development.