Demon Jack

Picking Sam Darcy who played 16 games over Naughton who played more games and kicked more goals is baffling. The AFL has a new love child

Loved watching him during his dashing heyday of 2016-17 before teams figured him out a bit in 2018. He was a half decent forward for us in 2019 but for me he played his best footy as a handy lockdown defender for us in 2021-22 following the retirement of Nev. He should be a premiership Demon but footy is a cruel game. Surprised that he was unable to hold down a spot in the Eagles defence this year.

All aboard ANB flag 2, electric boogaloo.

That's very disappointing if true. I thought he was worth persisting with for at least another year. Clearly the powers that be (whoever they are these days) don't agree. That winning tackle against North was one hell of a first involvement at AFL level.

Hardly a surprise at this point, but Jake is going around again! EDIT:.....And apparently TMac is as well!

Interesting to note that in his post-match interview, Maxy spoke about him and the likes of the 'older brigade' including McDonald and Melksham rocking up for day one of pre-season. Maybe a tentative confirmation that both TMac and Melky are going around again?

Aside from his missed shot at HT, I think it was the best game he's played all year.

Please tell me we didn't give Sharp a long term contract when we traded for him? Genuinely stunned he's managed to play 17 games this year.

From looking at an old 'potential father son' article on the Melbourne website, the White twins should both be 14 now. If they both want to go down that road, they'll be drafted in 2029.

6. Gawn 5. Langford 4. Rivers 3. Oliver 2. Salem 1. Fritsch

Rivers. Must. Play. Midfield

Our fourth quarters continue to be our achilles heel. Langford is a gem. Long, long pre-season ahead.

I could see all three in our starting 22 next year. AMW would likely be playing now if he hadn't injured his ACL and Mentha could fill the small forward void inside 50 while Kozzy plays more midfield time. Culley could be anything.

Billings is out of contract at the end of this season. I think we've seen the last of him.

I imagine that if McDonald and Melksham were retiring, it would've been announced by now so they could both be given a fitting tribute at the end of the match. Hopefully both play on next season.

Wow, uninspiring to the max. It would've been a great opportunity to give the likes of Laurie, Brown or even Kentfield or Mentha a go considering Casey have a bye this weekend. Everyone has checked out. What a drag of a year.

Missed out on selection in Carlton's final game of the year, which means he won’t hit the automatic trigger for an extra year at the Blues. Carlton can still offer him a new deal but is this one we should potentially look at? Mature body and can be played at either end of the ground. Tmac is no certainty to go around again next season and May's powers are dwindling. I've never been a huge fan but he could be a handy in-between while the likes of JVR, Jeffo and Adams continue to learn their craft.

His last three weeks have probably been the best he's played since his late 2023 hot patch when he booted six against the Tiges. I still think his best position is defence, but I wouldn't be upset if we persist with him up forward next season.

Is Sinnema eligible to be drafted this year or next? Sounds like a good prospect.

Disappointing performance. Very little spirit in that showing. Would Sparrow get a game in any other best 22? Has been coasting for years now.

Bruce has been huge for Brisbane over the last couple of years. Melbourne connection aside, this would be a fantastic acquisition.

Genuinely looked the part during the first 2/3rds of 2016 before he disappeared off of the face of the Earth. Never got a look in during 2017 under Goodwin for whatever reason before he was delisted.

Tend to agree. Jai is a much more versatile player as well. He can truly play anywhere and make a decent fist of it. Speaking of Hendo? Where's he been? Played an ok first couple of games then fell off the face of the earth.

It would seem a bit unfair to drop Adams after he was given the impossible task of guarding Naughton who's in the form of his life, but I can't imagine we'll be leaving May on the sidelines. I imagine Windsor will miss the remainder of the season. Lindsay seems the most logical replacement but Kolt has also had a good block of VFL form. I can't see any of Woey 2.0, Laurie or Brown getting a look in anytime soon.

Where is Sparrow at? Not sure if his 10 touch, 4 tackle games are going to impress the new coach.