Everything posted by spirit of norm smith
-
The very, very contentious 50 for Dissent Rule
Love this post. So many supporters outraged by this non rule. It’s designed to help the umps BUT actually leads to more frustration and confusion. Tom McDonald complained about the Giants knocking the ball out of bounds. Free kick to Giants for arguing. Lever disappointed the Hill slipped into his arm and gets a 50 for showing disappointment. Himmelberg complains that he reckoned he touched the ball when Petty marked it. Nothing. Himmelberg complains when he tackles Hunt and it’s a ball up. Nothing. What’s the rule ?? And the “stand” rule for players on the mark. It’s completely inconsistent. Some umpires take 3-4 seconds after the player has played on, leaving the player on the mark helpless like they’re in concrete boots.
-
CHANGES: Rd 06 vs Richmond
Nervous week ahead Werridee. BBB could replace either Weid or Tmcd. Tmcd stays in probably on sentiment as he and Weid were probably about even on the night. Toss of the coin but Weid might miss out. Goody showed with Tomlinson that despite form, he wants his best premiership 22 back in formation.
-
POSTGAME: Rd 05 vs GWS
I think umpire 34 had another shocker. She umpired at Dees v Suns and was so biased against the Dees , not only giving wrong decisions and inconsistent decisions all night. Lucky the players can’t complain. I support the diversity but need to call out the poor sub standard umpiring.
-
POSTGAME: Rd 05 vs GWS
https://www.afl.com.au/video/743556/fritsch-goal-caps-off-brilliant-end-to-end-piece-of-play?videoId=743556&modal=true&type=video&publishFrom=1650110095001 Sparrow. Loved his run and continued running. As described… “selfless, brilliant”. We were right behind it and stood to applaud Tommy Sparrow’s effort. His goal !!
-
POSTGAME: Rd 05 vs GWS
20,791 I was at the game and I’d reckon it was 291 giants fans and 20,500 Dees supporters. And 3 imposters as umpires 🤦🏻♂️
-
VOTES: Rd 05 vs GWS
Sorry Balls but I was at the game and could not see Tmcd in our best 6 players or indeed the best 18 Dees on the night. Team effort all night yet to be honest Tmcd was poor in the first half (1 kick, 1 handball) and lifted to have some impact in the 2nd half. Still could hold his spot with a toss of the coin between Weid and Tmcd if Goody sees BBB back in.
-
VOTES: Rd 05 vs GWS
6 - May - absolutely sensational defender all night and rebounded well 5 - Gawn - stood tall in a very psychical encounter 4- Petracca - just made things happen 3- Viney - strong at the contest and in the tackle, and his goal topped off a good night 2- Pickett - pure excitement 1- Spargo - best game ever imv, with more energy and smart footy apologies to Harmesy, Clarry and Fritsch who were also very good.
-
CASEY: Rd 04 vs Coburg
Salem. Hibbo. Turner. Injured. Bbrown. Suspension Howes? Rested??
-
Gus and Gawny with Choco Williams
5-stars again this week. Gus and Gawny are media ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Love the 20%discount offer from Choco on Sherrin Precision footballs.
-
ANZAC Eve Guernsey 2022
It’s a big YES from me in the 2022 jumper
-
CASEY: Rd 04 vs Coburg
Hope to see Melksham and Mitch Brown back in this week.
-
AFLW: 2022 Best & Fairest
Yes through a blanket over the top 5 players including Karen Paxman. Paxman could conceivably have won the B&F.
-
CASEY: Rd 03 vs Williamstown
I agree Laurie was played in the midfield for Casey on the weekend but I can’t see him within the current rotation. Rotated forward and did 1-2 clever moves including a nice goal that indicate he is a more natural half forward imv.
-
AFLW: 2022 Best & Fairest
Amazingly close count. Daisy is a star ⭐️ Lauren Pearce had a great year as did Tayla Harris. I think Hanks was solid yet can keep on improving. Paxman, Birch and Mithen tied on 47, equal 5th and all three could have easily been higher up in the count. I think Birch was my player of the year. Premier defender in the game (Steven May like) and was rewarded with All Australian honour. Big 23 awaits. Go Dees
-
CASEY: Rd 03 vs Williamstown
Howes ✅JVR ✅ Woey jnr ✅ all looked good and should develop this year at Casey. Howes might even be considered later in the year perhaps for a senior run. Moniz-Wakefield was involved in the contest, cracked in and kicked a beautiful goal from the 50. One to work with imv. Bailey Laurie was ok but seems to be pencilled in as a small forward. Smart and creative type. Will aim to keep fit in 2022, and develop. Most promising game from Rosman. Still only in his 2nd year but held down key position in defence alongside Petty. Got the athletic ability, just needs to develop his footy skills and decisions. We have time to let him develop over the 22 and 23 seasons then assess.
-
CHANGES: Rd 05 vs GWS
Seriously / Mitch Brown hit and nothing reported. BenBrown niggled all night and gets two weeks. This week Weid and Tmcd get a reprieve. They need to STAND UP this week v Giants.
-
Finn Emile-Brennan
Agree. Tell the kid to settle down. He is a good prospect and would like him in red and blue.
-
Toby Bedford, Kade Chandler and Bailey Laurie…
Bedford and Chandler certainly are on the edge of selection. Spargo is ok and gives enough but his spot is still one that Bedford or Chandler could grab in my opinion. Laurie is in a development year. I agree he is more half forward than midfielder. We have plenty of small forwards so he’ll need to find some more tricks or pace to get an opportunity.
-
My 3 word player analysis V Port
Spargo has twice in last 2 weeks been within 30 metres with open space and tried to pass to a player in the goalsquare 🤦🏻♂️ 3 words - kick the goal !!!
-
AFLW GAMEDAY: Grand Final vs Adelaide
I think she named the sponsors. Daisy was all class 💙
-
AFLW GAMEDAY: Grand Final vs Adelaide
Crows as the Sth Australian womens AFL team. Port AFLW team will break up the group. Crows too strong. Too skilled. Too professional. Dees were brave. Tackling was amazing. The effort was unquestionable. Heads up … a great year despite today. best: Libby Birch ⭐️⭐️⭐️Fitzsimmons ⭐️⭐️⭐️Daisy ⭐️⭐️ Paxman ⭐️⭐️L.Pearce ⭐️Goldrick ⭐️
-
AFLW GAMEDAY: Grand Final vs Adelaide
3rd quarter so brave so determined so much better
-
AFLW GAMEDAY: Grand Final vs Adelaide
Lily - oh no !
-
AFLW GAMEDAY: Grand Final vs Adelaide
Run and kick long. TAYLA Harris. Kick long to Hore. Goal. Wow that’s the way. Run and run.
-
AFLW GAMEDAY: Grand Final vs Adelaide
Slow and slow and kick to a contest. What’s the strategy !?!?!?!