Diamond_Jim

Everything you need to know about the new sub rule and more. Interesting that clubs basically admitted they were breaching the old rule. So much for medical ethics. https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/back-to-the-future-how-the-afl-s-new-substitute-rule-may-work-in-2023-20230125-p5cfbp.html Wonder who will be our sub. Under the medical sub rules I favoured Joel Smith as he provided cover if a key tall went down. If the main driver is now going to be fresh legs I'm not sure. Chandler jumps out but one would assume if he performs well in that role he would get a full game rather quickly. Assuming we are having a decent season I wouldn't mind seeing AMW and Woewodin exposed to AFL as the sub

yep just did the same but nothing jumped out from the last 20 posts or so that can be seen on the profile

mmmmmmm they got rid of a practice game so they could play the Harry Potter round in Adelaide and now clubs are adding a scratch match

If only.. both Colingwood and Adelaide beat us with quick ball movement in 2021 and it simply got worse in 2022 as more teams adopted that tactic against us last year. It is increasingly the new game style for many teams (see Hawthorn) so we need to work it out

We all know why we failed in the forward line last year but I'm interested in knowing what we might do to stop the kamikaze run on sides like Collingwood who seemed to take our defence apart even after we had the jinxed lead of around 26 points. Is the answer simply fix the forward line and kick more goals? I hope they have the analysis team working hard on what type of players and plays were used to cut our defence open. I have some gut feelings as to how it was done (attacking from our defensive pocket forward entries) but I'd love to see some serious analysis. And .. please... let's thrash the Pies this year.

Don't think we've had a game at Coburg since they remodelled the outer side of the ground. It certainly was a lovely venue not to mention convenient

If it is you'll need to get there early. The grandstand was conveniently condemned allowing them to knock it down. Not sure if that has been done but at best it will be a construction site with no seats. Not much space in the rest of the ground. Maximum capacity probably under 3k. You could lobby for Windy Hill perhaps .... A bit of 70's character left in that ground still Casey is a llllong way.. I agree

A lot of people made mistakes with the hubs. Harvey was not the lone ranger. A VFL list is not an AFL list anyway. Good luck to him if he wants to take his life in this direction

Of course the baseball training camps are in drop dead weather venues such as Florida. I would envisage a set up like a mock beach or similar with player interaction/hosting etc but as you say could be hard to do at Gosch's. Would make a nice Christmas present for footy tragics perhaps

A magnificent day weather wise for training... A few snakes basking on the warm tracks perhaps On a separate note one wonders how long it will be until some bright spark at the AFL (we can make money out of anything) comes up with a plan for charging fees to attend training. Going to "spring training" in baseball is big business.

Wonder why with skills of the modern player that both sides are not the "attacking side"

After our great 2021 season I rewatched every game. The kick to the forward pocket was a big element in 2021. It disappeared in the finals and the winning margins exploded even allowing for some inaccurate kicking in the first two finals. Perhaps we became too predictable in 2022

Having been involved in negotiations for a fair while your premise makes sense. I used to call it the "grieving period" in the sense that participants needed to replace their anger with a sense of compromise. Unfortunately we are taught to "maintain the rage." On the other hand compromise leads to a maintenance of the status quo which is perhaps more harmful in many instances. Now back to the subject... Palace Dees tell us more about the backgammon app you beat. I would have thought it's a mathematical equation like checkers

Interesting... mainly used to measure their own players which makes sense as they could access the data. Its use in recruitment is fascinating

With ChatGPT (the latest open source AI educational app) causing rumblings in educational circles you have to wonder how long until AI enters sport. My guess is that it is probably already used to some degree in NFL to predict the success probability of particular plays. Could it have application in Australian rules to predict trends in say centre bounces. I don't know if AI can interpret video yet but imagine if it could. For those who follow these things, humans lost the ability to beat computers at chess in around 2006 and even now you can download programs to your phone that will beat any human.

nor did Freo

Bowey for Hibberd Interesting... not impossible Petty obviously needs to be included. I'd question Melksham as the sub baring in mind that there is no longer a medical requirement for substitution. The old mantra when there was a similar sub rule was young fresh legs for the last quarter. Chandler fits that description but you already have him in the side. Not sure ANB is a lock. Given only one official practice match and no VFL games until Round 3 the intra club scratch matches assume some significance in determining the make up of the team. Going to be an interesting battle for 4-5 spots

If nothing is heard by Round 3 it's going to be one of those...will he/wont he seasons. How's Port's salary cap looking? Will they offer the magical million. His "normal" worth is probably circa $600k but Freo showed us that clubs are willing to offer big money if they think a player is "gettable".

I would have thought round 23 in 2021 had all the makings of a significant game. 50 plus point turnaround to secure the minor premiership and kick start a dominant final series. I suppose our loss to the Essendon "Reserves side" in 2017 (?) was significant as well but not in a nice way. To be significant a game needs to impact the competition as a whole.. both of these games did

The Eagles run and handball game with Cousins at its centre was a joy to watch. I can recall Armstrong in that GF. His job was to run with stars take the handpass and give it off. A limited role but he played it well. Would it work today? I'm not sure.

Watching the 2021 prelim against Geelong this week (needed some happy TV). Could not help but think how Scott turned around his team in 2022 whereas we went backwards if anything in our gameplan. Let's hope 2023 gives us a better mix

certainly worthy of discussion Percentage football may only get you so far

Thanks OD Of course the fault is we failed to move twenty years ago. The MCG precinct was always a pipe dream. Inner city was hard but mid city (20k radius) was possible. In reality there is no solution now. Richmond have compromised. Collingwood are doing nothing it seems. It is what it is.. Just imagine if we had been more powerful in the Junction Oval days. Casey on the 50k ring is not the solution unfortunately.... we need to be within the 30k ring As an aside I think Geelong will be the next to establish the modern training facilities. Some land on the Geelong- Ballarat road perhps

That bottom 8 is a surprise. Adelaide at 17 especially. Must have a soft spot for North as I see them as 17 or 18 and not 13 as suggested. The top 8... nearly has it right !! Ah.. just watched to the end. Initial ladder positions were for home and away Thanks

Quite likely that Melb Victory will be penalised with several games behind closed doors. Can't help wondering if the AFL would do similar if faced with the same problem. I think we all know the answer