rjay

Because our club is full of amateurs who have no idea what to do about anything let alone about the player they've drafted and what is best for his long term development.

It's kind of stupid for the rising star award to be tied in with the "the fairest".. it's not the "Rising Star & Fairest" award. So whoever the rising star is, he should win it.

Too much hand wringing re Casey...it doesn't matter if we win VFL flags at this stage but it does matter that we develop players. It seems Jeffo is coming along nicely and AMW is playing himself into contention. Tholstrup will be ok, just a kid at the moment. We've been 3 senior players down all year (Gus, Melk and Smith) and that really takes a toll, then add travel emergencies and general injuries and the team hasn't been able to settle. We do have a ruck problem though and I'm sure the club know it. Our 2 VFL guys are struggling at VFL level and are nowhere near AFL standard.

It would be too raw and gut wrenching. being so close to the action but not able to really be a part of it... Nice of the club to offer but I can understand that he would rather keep his distance for a time. We really miss him as a player but probably not half as much as he misses playing.

He did...

"Knuckles" is also called "Silk"...

He may end up as a mid, it's where he played a lot of junior football I believe. ...but then again all these kids were stars as juniors so they all played mid. Could be a bit like Ed Richards who has developed his craft in defence and has now moved into the midfield. Give him time. Remember one of the greats that he shares a nick name with played a lot of his footy off half back and went into the midfield when the Hawks needed a lift. I would like to see him getting a bit more ball out of defence.

...and where did we finish on the ladder in those years?

Enjoy 'kev', I hope you have a great time. ...and thanks for your reports, very much appreciated.

No coincidence...EFC have a huge supporter base & they're winning. They have a poor percentage (bottom 6) so can't be their attractive free flowing footy.

I think that's spot on 'Biff'...

It's a little like what KB used to say about tackling...no point if you've got the ball. I think you are right in that it is an instruction. They brought the ball down and into play a few times yesterday. If they had of stayed on the ground it would have been an easy intercept.

I get your point but in this case the VFL tribunal is not made up of the same people as the AFL version. It's a seperate organisation. So consistency needs to be measured on their past actions.

Zach Tuohy

I suspected before, but now I'm sure you are taking the p... Enjoy!

So one player needs to show awareness but the other not???

It may or may not be but that's the way it's adjudicated. In this particular case where was the shepherd??? Smith's teammate had possession of the ball, not Parker's, there was no shepherd.

In the good old days that would be true 'Dee'', but now if you choose to bump and cause damage you're done. ...by the way, not sure if you are being serious or taking the ....

Would be a handy replacement for Brayshaw...can play mid, forward and back... ...but maybe this is for another thread.

Yes, they do have a tribunal...I would think he will have to front it.

Looked like a legit shepherd gone wrong except that none of his teammates had the footy. So not sure what he was attempting to do.

Sestan with 4 is a good return...

An extraordinary take on this great piece of music...

You're probably right...but I haven't been overly impressed with Fullarton forward or in the ruck. As it stands he (Fullarton) may be injured anyway.

He (Tommo) did play some time in the ruck at GWS...so maybe he is the better choice.