640MD

I hope no one from Box Hill Hawks wants to be a hero for 15 minutes of fame But then Viney is not a 17 year old kid anymore and Box Hill is a long way from Geelong

Last year I hated watching OMac play, this year he deserves his spot playing excellent footy if he keeps improving at this rate he will be as good as TMac. Fantastic

It’s not often you want to quote or like every second post the respect this man has gained while here at Melbourne is immense. hardly new who or what he was at the start now most supporters will never forget his contributions outstanding thanks PJ

Ok I can agree he has improved showed a bit yesterday and while pedo is a bit heavier and hits packs harder Weideman has him covered in potential and youth. Don’t think he was best 22 at the start of this season but natural improvement will mean he will be at the end. Might be very important if we make September Once again the FD and others on this site are smarter or have more footy nous than me. So be it Go Dees

These results show one thing ABSOLUTELY no easy beats this year each match could be won by either side if we take these next three games other than full bore we will lose ! 4 flaming quarters not 3 Go Dees

Much prefer 2 Dogs as a monicker, very old joke

A Lot of good work goes unnoticed by some supporters but I am sure the FD sees it all. but yes you are correct really good form but it might have been seen as blocking by some biased umpires.

We seem to be back on track poor first bit but great 3rd great debut by Spargo and weideman is competing better than I have seen him do before come on dees

Out of form yes so they are dropped but then also my expectations of how good the players are just shows I am not a great judge. Lets hope TMac back today can liven up the forward line and we get a win. and Spargo debuts with a standout game. make us all feel much better Go Dees !!

Compared to what was expected of players before the jlt series, guys who get dropped should be in the best for Casey but rarely are. we seem to be moving deck chairs on the titanic

It’s a great but very old joke

It’s disappointing that our depth appears so shallow and if you cannot get your better players on the park only highlights the problem. whatablunder last year bringing Viney back so early then only to lose to Collingwood. A pity Vanders is so far off and might be forever off. If our lower level players cannot dominate or play well at vfl level they may as well play at Boronia or Echuca. No point in keeping them. Put up or pass off. I do hope to see a flag one day will make the supporting for decades almost bearable. But hurry up demons ! dont like Etihad will be watching on the Telstra app on the phone. Only decent thing about the phone contract.

I do like reading some of our posters some of you guys put a fair bit into the analysis of the games cant put up with the negative personal stuff. Ignore all that not sure I can be as positive as some of you but then it’s probably the culmination of 60 years or more supporting and being mostly shite for 40 of those years make 4 changes with fresh legs we can do the Bummers

Wrong. OK was about all he was better than useless and he did show a bit More than I expected less than I hoped, Lever to my mind had his best game in red n blue and OMac continues to improve i no longer look away when he gets he pill No pressure on the opposition coming from our forwards let’s them run it into space and overwhelms our defence. still I have felt far worse after some games but we should be aiming at 4 goals quarter not just one. And any shot on goal Weideman gets needs to go straight through over the umpires hat or he can stay at Casey for s while.

Physical fitness or mental fitness we do seem to give up late in a game or relax if we are a way in front. feeling rather dispondant just now as usual high hopes at the start of the year Couple of weeks in little or no real improvement. [censored] Off !!

At least you can get a smile on Land, if you read this thread, intellectual and articulate and no depression. and no political correctness required !

Like all your comments bar this one dont think he will be the one, he might in 12 months. Still I thought much the same about OMac but from middle last year he has pretty well advanced his output every match, but we lost games while he gained experience. But all I could go on a footy field was clumsily run around getting in every ones way. Not much skill at all! GoDees and UHSOB magoos!

I think we are still deep in the poo! nothing to enthuse about at Casey on Sunday and now we have the weed in. I might be wrong often am. But I would have thought to deserve a game as opposed to getting a game for experience he should have dominated as best on ground a couple of times. Last year he was worse that Watts first couple of games. I want to win games now. Before a bloody well die. Rather than wait while someone maybe gets experience. Or gets so bashed about he loses all confidence. Though we do have another game quickly so maybe the FD have it all in hand. As confusios said once. I hope broad does not show him any happy snaps! Lose all focus. Fingets crossed toes and eyes crossed go dees !! Hope we win but not at all confident Just my thoughts

Depressing watching this on my phone, just like ....

Plus he cant handball !!

Yes painfull only half interested but the ball is going through him forward even without his full effort

Just watching StKilda giants on the phone and there is an Article on Telstra football AFL about training to beat dusty don’t know how to copy or post it if you think it’s worthwhile please post it

A sports photographer would use a long lens. Big max could be 50 metres away he is blurred to the extreme. Not sharp so well out of the action !! So he is not close a kick behind I suggest bloody hell I hope we win on Tuesday night I do not expect a win, but they need to dish up something s lot more palatable than the tripe they gave last half, I will watch from here. Go Dees!!

Next week I want more run for the whole game, we were tired to the extreme in the last 10 minutes. Just watched the hawks train around our hats. and no bloody fumbles pick it up clean Go Dees !!

In. Pedo, perhaps Hunt, or Tyson out. Not sure Did not see enough, but we need fresh legs. Leave weideman to learn his craft and pick players for the conditions expected Go Dees !!